Why do hemorrhoids bleed, and what actually stops it?
In adults with internal or external hemorrhoids presenting with rectal bleeding, what is the underlying cause of the bleeding, and which treatments (dietary/fiber measures, topical agents, office-based procedures such as rubber band ligation or sclerotherapy, or surgery) most effectively stop or reduce hemorrhoidal bleeding?
How people search for this, in their own words
- “why is my hemorrhoid bleeding”
- “how to stop hemorrhoids from bleeding”
- “how to stop internal hemorrhoids from bleeding”
- “can internal hemorrhoids bleed”
- “how to treat bleeding hemorrhoids”
- “how to treat internal hemorrhoids bleeding”
- “how long do internal hemorrhoids bleed”
Evidence review in plain language · compiled 2026-10-13 · checked 2026-10-13 · next 2026-11-13 · automated review, how it works
What the evidence says
Bottom line
Several office procedures and medicines have been shown in trials to reduce or stop hemorrhoid bleeding — but no study in this review actually explains why hemorrhoids bleed in the first place.
The strongest evidence comes from five well-conducted randomised trials comparing one bleeding-control option against another — banding, injection sclerotherapy, and artery-blocking procedures — and most show real improvement in bleeding. Almost none of the studies compared a treatment with doing nothing, so they answer 'which treatment works better' rather than 'does treatment help at all.' The basic biology of why hemorrhoids bleed was not tested in people in any of these studies.
How certain
High
5 well-conducted randomised trials address this question directly.
What it shows
Benefit shown
Most of the stronger evidence points to a benefit.
- studies found
- 140studies found
- randomised trials
- 26randomised trials
- people studied
- 43,616people studied
- reviews of trials
- 13reviews of trials
- years covered
- 2020–2026years covered
- finished, never published
- 3finished, never published
What the research shows
Improvement shown
Possible improvement
Possible improvement
Possible improvement
Insufficient evidence
Improvement shown
Underlying biological cause of bleeding
No study in this review tested, in humans, why hemorrhoids bleed. The only mechanism-focused work was done in rats and lab tissue samples, which doesn't reliably show what happens in people.
Not studied
What it may help with
- Rubber-band ligation and sclerotherapy (an injection that scars and shrinks the hemorrhoid) stopped or markedly reduced bleeding in multiple trials and cohort studies, including head-to-head comparisons against each other and against surgery.[1,2,3,4,5,6,7,8]
- Oral vein-supporting medicines (flavonoids, including micronized purified flavonoid fraction) reduced bleeding scores compared with placebo or routine care in several trials.[1,2,3,4,5,6]
- Procedures that block the artery feeding the hemorrhoid (embolization) reduced bleeding scores in multiple cohort studies and a small randomised trial.[1,2,3,4,5,6,7]
- Surgery to remove hemorrhoids controlled bleeding well in people with more severe disease, and a large comparison across many trials found it gave the lowest recurrence among procedural options.[1,2]
Important limitations
- Most studies compared one active treatment with another, not treatment against doing nothing, so how much benefit comes from the treatment itself versus natural improvement over time is often unclear.[1,2,3,4]
- Many studies were retrospective or single-arm with no comparison group, meaning people could have partly improved on their own rather than because of the treatment.[1,2,3,4,5,6]
- Follow-up was often short. In studies that did look further out, bleeding and other symptoms frequently returned, sometimes in a quarter or more of patients.[1,2,3,4]
- None of these studies explain, in humans, the underlying biology of why hemorrhoids bleed. The only mechanism research was done in rats and lab tissue, which doesn't necessarily reflect what happens in people.[1,2,3]
What the studies found
- Found a benefit79 · 56%
- Found no clear effect11 · 8%
- Mixed or unclear48 · 34%
- Found possible harm2 · 1%
What kind of studies
- Retrospective45 · 32%
- Randomised trial26 · 19%
- Case series20 · 14%
- Narrative review15 · 11%
- Prospective cohort14 · 10%
- Meta-analysis9 · 6%
- Systematic review4 · 3%
- Guideline2 · 1%
- Laboratory study2 · 1%
- Animal study2 · 1%
- Registry1 · 1%
The studies that decided it
Qureshi et al. 2026
AGA Clinical Practice Update on Diagnosis and Treatment of Hemorrhoids: Expert Review
Banding works better long-term than infraredGuidelineLow quality
size not given2026
Rubber band ligation and infrared coagulation are both effective, with banding giving longer-lasting control of bleeding and prolapse than infrared coagulation
- Who was studied
- people with hemorrhoids
- What they received
- various hemorrhoid treatments including diet/lifestyle changes, topical treatments, rubber band ligation, infrared coagulation, and surgery
- Compared with
- different treatments compared to each other or to no treatment
- Main outcome
- control of hemorrhoid symptoms including bleeding and prolapse
- Quality
- This is an expert opinion guideline based on a literature review without a systematic review or formal evidence grading.
- Limitations
- Because systematic reviews were not performed, these BPA statements do not carry formal ratings regarding the quality of evidence or strength of the presented considerations.
Taken word for word from the abstract
- population
Hemorrhoids are a common problem.
- intervention
Both hemorrhoid banding and infrared coagulation are safe, effective, and easy to perform in the office setting.
- comparator
Infrared coagulation and rubber band ligation have similar benefits in the short term.
- primaryOutcome
Rubber band ligation has longer-term benefits for treatment of prolapsing hemorrhoids and recurrent bleeding.
- result
Rubber band ligation has longer-term benefits for treatment of prolapsing hemorrhoids and recurrent bleeding.
- limitations
Because systematic reviews were not performed, these BPA statements do not carry formal ratings regarding the quality of evidence or strength of the presented considerations.
Clin Gastroenterol Hepatol · PMID 42067175 · Read it on PubMed ↗
Tian et al. 2023
Efficacy of two endoscopic rubber band ligation methods for symptomatic hemorrhoids: a randomized controlled trial
Both banding methods worked similarly for bleeding.Randomised trialModerate quality
70 people12 months
no significant difference in overall efficacy, recurrence, or symptom improvement (including bleeding) between the two ligation methods, but combined ligation caused more pain afterward
- Who was studied
- patients with symptomatic grade I to III hemorrhoids
- What they received
- rubber band ligation of the hemorrhoid plus nearby normal tissue (combined ligation)
- Compared with
- rubber band ligation of the hemorrhoid alone
- Main outcome
- overall therapeutic success rate (complete or partial resolution of symptoms)
- Quality
- it was a randomized trial but small, open-label (not blinded), and some patients were lost to follow-up.
- Limitations
- open-label design, small sample size (70 randomized, 62 completed follow-up)
Taken word for word from the abstract
- n
Seventy patients with symptomatic grade I to III hemorrhoids were randomly assigned to the hemorrhoid and combined ligation groups (35 in each group).
- population
symptomatic grade I to III hemorrhoids
- intervention
simultaneous ligation of hemorrhoids and proximal normal mucosa (combined ligation)
- comparator
ligation of hemorrhoids
- primaryOutcome
The primary outcome was overall therapeutic success rate (complete resolution and partial resolution rates).
- result
No significant differences in overall efficacy, recurrence rate, or efficacy for each symptom (including bleeding, prolapse, pain, anal swelling, itching, soiling, and constipation) were observed between groups.
- followUp
Patients were followed up at 3, 6, and 12 months to assess symptom improvement, complications, and recurrence.
Surg Endosc · PMID 37188908 · Read it on PubMed ↗
Huang et al. 2023
Tissue-selecting-technique mega-window stapler combined with anal canal epithelial preservation operation in prolapsed hemorrhoids
No difference in bleeding between techniques.Randomised trialModerate quality
204 people2023
No significant difference in bleeding or blood loss between the two surgical techniques, though the TST-MS group had better anal function scores and satisfaction
- Who was studied
- patients with prolapsed hemorrhoids undergoing surgery
- What they received
- tissue selecting technique with mega-window stapler (TST-MS) combined with anal canal epithelial preservation operation
- Compared with
- prolapse and hemorrhoids (PPH) combined with the external hemorrhoidectomy and inferior internal hemorrhoid ligation
- Main outcome
- anal function, recurrence, and surgical complications including bleeding
- Quality
- It was a randomized, evaluator-blinded trial but done at only one hospital, so the results may not generalize widely.
- Limitations
- Single-center trial design was noted implicitly by the study being described as single-center.
Taken word for word from the abstract
- n
A total of 204 participants were randomly divided into the two groups.
- population
treatment of prolapsed hemorrhoids
- intervention
tissue selecting technique with mega-window stapler (TST-MS) combined with anal canal epithelial preservation operation
- comparator
prolapse and hemorrhoids (PPH) combined with the external hemorrhoidectomy and inferior internal hemorrhoid ligation
- primaryOutcome
The anal function, reoccurrence, intraoperative variables, and operative complications were assessed.
- result
There was no significant difference between the two groups in the anal canal circumference, recurrence, intraoperative blood loss, weight of excised rectal mucosa, anal pain, bleeding, urinary retention, anal edge edema, and anatomical anal stenosis (all P > 0.05).
Asian J Surg · PMID 35961908 · Read it on PubMed ↗
Jin et al. 2021
Interventional treatments for prolapsing haemorrhoids: network meta-analysis
Surgery cuts recurrence but causes more bleeding.Meta-analysisLow quality
9,232 peopleminimum follow-up of 6 weeks
Surgical removal methods (open/closed hemorrhoidectomy, stapled hemorrhoidopexy) had the lowest recurrence but caused more pain, bleeding, urinary retention, and bowel incontinence than less invasive options.
- Who was studied
- patients with grade II-III (prolapsing) hemorrhoids
- What they received
- various procedural treatments for hemorrhoids (e.g., hemorrhoidectomy, stapled hemorrhoidopexy, rubber band ligation, Doppler-guided artery ligation)
- Compared with
- other procedural treatments compared head-to-head across studies
- Main outcome
- symptom recurrence, post-procedure pain, and complications (bleeding, urinary retention, bowel incontinence)
- Quality
- Most of the included trials (73%) were judged high risk of bias, and there was notable inconsistency between studies.
- Limitations
- 59 of 79 RCTs (73%) were at high risk of bias, with variable heterogeneity in direct comparisons, especially for recurrence and pain outcomes.
Taken word for word from the abstract
- population
grade II-III haemorrhoids
- intervention
Fourteen different treatments were analysed in the network meta-analysis
- comparator
RCTs comparing procedural interventions for grade II-III haemorrhoids
- primaryOutcome
Primary outcomes of interest were: symptom recurrence at a minimum follow-up of 6 weeks, postprocedural pain measured on a visual analogue scale (VAS) on day 1, and postprocedural complications (bleeding, urinary retention, and bowel incontinence).
- result
Open and closed haemorrhoidectomy, and stapled haemorrhoidopexy were associated with worse pain, and more postprocedural bleeding, urinary retention, and bowel incontinence, but had the lowest rates of symptom recurrence.
- n
Seventy-nine RCTs were identified, including 9232 patients.
- followUp
symptom recurrence at a minimum follow-up of 6 weeks
BJS Open · PMID 34633439 · Read it on PubMed ↗
Küçükay et al. 2021
Superior Rectal Artery Embolization with Tris-Acryl Gelatin Microspheres: A Randomized Comparison of Particle Size
Embolization reduced bleeding, bigger particles worked bestRandomised trialModerate quality
42 people12 months
93% clinical success rate overall, with the greatest reduction in bleeding score seen in the group treated with the largest (900-1,200 μm) particles
- Who was studied
- adults with symptomatic hemorrhoid disease (various grades)
- What they received
- superior rectal artery embolization using tris-acryl gelatin microspheres of different particle sizes
- Compared with
- different microsphere particle sizes (500-700 μm vs 700-900 μm vs 900-1,200 μm) within the embolization procedure
- Main outcome
- clinical success rate at 12 months after embolization
- Quality
- it was a randomized trial but small, with only 14 patients per group and no comparison to a non-embolization control.
- Limitations
- small sample size per arm, minor complication rate of 54%, and no Goligher score improvement despite other gains
Taken word for word from the abstract
- n
Forty-two patients (male, 30; female, 12; median age, 45 years) with symptomatic HD
- population
symptomatic hemorrhoidal disease (HD)
- intervention
superior rectal artery embolization (SRAE) with different-sized tris-acryl gelatin microspheres
- comparator
divided into 3 experimental arms (500-700 μm, 700-900 μm, and 900-1,200 μm groups; each had 14 patients)
- primaryOutcome
The primary outcome measure was the clinical success rate at 12 months.
- result
The clinical success rate was 93%. Of the groups, the best French bleeding score decrease was obtained in the 900-1,200 μm group.
J Vasc Interv Radiol · PMID 33640516 · Read it on PubMed ↗
Jin et al. 2021
Efficacy of modified rubber band ligation in the treatment of grade III internal hemorrhoids
Less post-op bleeding than surgery.Randomised trialModerate quality
120 people2021
MRBL caused significantly less post-operative pain, bleeding, and urine retention than MMH, with stable anal pressure; recurrence rates were similar between groups
- Who was studied
- patients with grade III internal hemorrhoids (hemorrhoid prolapse)
- What they received
- modified rubber band ligation (MRBL)
- Compared with
- Milligan-Morgan hemorrhoidectomy (MMH) surgery
- Main outcome
- post-operative pain, bleeding, urine retention, anal pressure, and recurrence
- Quality
- it was a randomized trial with a reasonable number of patients, but surgery versus a non-surgical procedure cannot be blinded, which could bias how outcomes like pain were assessed.
- Limitations
- Abstract does not mention blinding, length of overall follow-up for recurrence, or single vs multi-center design.
Taken word for word from the abstract
- n
A total of 120 patients with grade III internal hemorrhoids were randomly assigned to receive MRBL or Milligan-Morgan haemorrhoidectomy (MMH) (n=60 per group).
- population
patients with grade III internal hemorrhoids
- intervention
modified rubber band ligation (MRBL)
- comparator
Milligan-Morgan haemorrhoidectomy (MMH)
- primaryOutcome
The post-operative pain, bleeding, urine retention and feeling of anal distension were recorded, and the resting anal pressure (RAP) and post-operative recurrence rate were compared between two groups.
- result
The post-operative pain, bleeding and urine retention in the MRBL group were improved significantly as compared with the MMH group (P<0.05), but the feeling of anal distension was similar between them (P>0.05).
- result
The post-operative recurrence rate was comparable between two groups (P>0.05).
Ann Palliat Med · PMID 33081476 · Read it on PubMed ↗
Mishra et al. 2020
Polidocanol versus phenol in oil injection sclerotherapy in treatment of internal hemorrhoids: A randomized controlled trial
Polidocanol stopped bleeding better than phenolRandomised trialModerate quality
150 peoplethree months
polidocanol stopped bleeding in more patients after one session (60.6% vs 38.1%) and after two sessions (94.7% vs 84%), with fewer sessions needed and higher patient satisfaction
- Who was studied
- patients with grade-1 and grade-2 bleeding internal hemorrhoids
- What they received
- injection sclerotherapy with 3% polidocanol
- Compared with
- injection sclerotherapy with 5% phenol in oil
- Main outcome
- being free of rectal bleeding after treatment
- Quality
- it was a randomized trial with a reasonable number of patients, but follow-up was only three months and details on blinding are not reported.
- Limitations
- short follow-up of three months; no mention of blinding of outcome assessment
Taken word for word from the abstract
- n
A total of 150 patients were enrolled, 75 in each group.
- population
All patients with grade-1 and 2 hemorrhoids, were selected and randomised into two groups
- intervention
3% polidocanol
- comparator
5% phenol in oil
- primaryOutcome
observed for "free of bleeding" or "persistent bleeding."
- result
At the end of the first sclerotherapy session with polidocanol, 60.6% of patients versus 38.1% in phenol group had stopped per rectal bleeding (p=0.009). After the second sclerotherapy session, 94.7% of patients in the polidocanol group and 84% of patients in the phenol group were treated successfully.
- followUp
All patients were followed-up for three months
Turk J Gastroenterol · PMID 32519957 · Read it on PubMed ↗
Sheikh et al. 2020
Micronized Purified Flavonoid Fraction in Hemorrhoid Disease: A Systematic Review and Meta-Analysis
Less bleeding with flavonoid drug.Meta-analysisModerate quality
size not given2020
MPFF significantly reduced bleeding and discharge, and improved overall symptoms; pain tended to decrease but was not statistically significant
- Who was studied
- people with hemorrhoid disease (acute or after medical/surgical treatment)
- What they received
- micronized purified flavonoid fraction (MPFF; Daflon), a vein-supporting drug
- Compared with
- placebo or no treatment
- Main outcome
- bleeding, pain, itching, discharge, and overall improvement
- Quality
- This pools several randomized trials, but only 4 of 11 studies could be combined numerically and the underlying trials vary in quality and design.
- Limitations
- Only 4 of 11 identified studies were included in the quantitative pooling, and no treatment duration limit was set, meaning study designs and follow-up varied widely.
Taken word for word from the abstract
- population
patients with HD
- intervention
micronized purified flavonoid fraction (MPFF; Daflon®)
- comparator
MPFF treatment was compared to placebo or no treatment for acute HD or for relief of symptoms after patients had undergone medical management or a surgical procedure to remove hemorrhoids
- primaryOutcome
The main endpoints investigated were bleeding, pain, pruritus, discharge or leakage, and overall improvement.
- result
Quantitative meta-analysis of four studies indicated that MPFF treatment provided significant benefits for bleeding (odds ratio [OR] 0.082, 95% confidence interval [CI] 0.027-0.250; P < 0.001), discharge/leakage (OR 0.12, 95% CI 0.04-0.42; P < 0.001), and overall improvement according to patients (OR 5.25, 95% CI 2.58-10.68; P < 0.001) and investigators (OR 5.51, 95% CI 2.76-11.0; P < 0.001).
Adv Ther · PMID 32399811 · Read it on PubMed ↗
What actually helps, on this site
Treatments Dr. Kamrava performs for this:
More about the condition:
All 140 studiesEvery study that answered the question, with its design, size and result.
The other 132 studiesEverything else the search returned, including anything retracted.
Barone et al. 2026
LigaSure versus conventional excisional haemorrhoidectomy: A systematic review and meta-analysis with trial sequential analysis of randomised controlled trials
Less pain and bleeding with LigaSure surgery.Meta-analysisModerate qualityRelated question
3,277 people2026
LigaSure reduced pain, bleeding, wound discharge and urinary retention, but showed no difference in recurrence, infection, or other long-term outcomes
- Who was studied
- patients having surgery to remove hemorrhoids
- What they received
- LigaSure (energy-sealing device) hemorrhoidectomy
- Compared with
- conventional excisional haemorrhoidectomy
- Main outcome
- postoperative pain and complications such as bleeding, wound discharge and urinary retention
- Quality
- It pooled 43 randomized trials with over 3,000 patients, which is fairly robust for short-term outcomes, but the authors note uncertainty remains for recurrence and other long-term results.
- Limitations
- Evidence regarding recurrence and other long-term anorectal outcomes remains limited.
Taken word for word from the abstract
- n
Forty-three unique RCTs comprising 3,277 participants were analysed.
- intervention
comparing LigaSure with conventional haemorrhoidectomy
- comparator
Randomised controlled trials comparing LigaSure with conventional techniques were included.
- population
Conventional excisional haemorrhoidectomy remains the gold standard treatment for grade IV haemorrhoids
- primaryOutcome
lower risks of postoperative wound discharge, postoperative bleeding and acute urinary retention
- result
LigaSure was associated with lower postoperative pain scores on days 1 and 2 and during the first and second postoperative weeks, reduced analgesic requirements and intraoperative blood loss, shorter operating time and time to return to daily activities, and lower risks of postoperative wound discharge, postoperative bleeding and acute urinary retention. No statistically significant differences were observed in immediate postoperative pain, pain on postoperative day 3 or week 4, recurrence, length of hospital stay, constipation, pruritus, surgical site infection, incomplete healing, anal fissure, anal stenosis, or faecal incontinence.
- limitations
uncertainty remains for several outcomes, and evidence regarding recurrence and other long-term anorectal outcomes remains limited.
Colorectal Dis · PMID 42816945 · Read it on PubMed ↗
Makunaite et al. 2026
Five-Year Follow-up of the Double-Blinded Randomized Controlled Trial Comparing Laser Hemorrhoidoplasty With Sutured Mucopexy and Excisional Hemorrhoidectomy
No clear difference in bleeding recurrence.Randomised trialLow quality
102 people5 years
symptom recurrence at 5 years was 24% after excisional hemorrhoidectomy, 29% after laser hemorrhoidoplasty, and 44% after sutured mucopexy, a difference that was not statistically significant; bleeding recurred in 18% (hemorrhoidectomy), 31% (mucopexy), and 31% (laser)
- Who was studied
- patients with symptomatic second- or third-degree hemorrhoids
- What they received
- laser hemorrhoidoplasty and excisional hemorrhoidectomy
- Compared with
- sutured mucopexy
- Main outcome
- return of hemorrhoid symptoms over 5 years
- Quality
- it is a small, single-center study and the main difference between treatments did not reach statistical significance.
- Limitations
- This is a single-center study with a relatively small sample size.
Taken word for word from the abstract
- n
A total of 102 patients were evaluated at 5 years (34 per group).
- population
Patients with symptomatic second- or third-degree hemorrhoids 5 years after surgery were interviewed via telephone or online questionnaire.
- intervention
Patients randomly assigned to laser hemorrhoidoplasty, excisional hemorrhoidectomy, and sutured mucopexy were followed up at 5 years after surgery.
- comparator
sutured mucopexy
- primaryOutcome
Recurrence of symptoms was the primary outcome
- result
Kaplan-Meier estimates of 5-year symptom recurrence were 24% for excisional hemorrhoidectomy, 29% for laser hemorrhoidoplasty, and 44% for sutured mucopexy; these differences did not reach statistical significance (log-rank p = 0.076).
- result
Specific recurrences included bleeding in 18% (excisional hemorrhoidectomy), 31% (sutured mucopexy), and 31% (laser hemorrhoidoplasty)
- limitations
This is a single-center study with a relatively small sample size.
Dis Colon Rectum · PMID 42478482 · Read it on PubMed ↗
Gallo et al. 2026
Use of mesoglycan in the acute phase of hemorrhoidal disease, the aCute HaemORrhoidal MEsoglycan Study (CHORMES): A double-blind, randomized controlled trial
Fewer symptoms; less bleeding in severe casesRandomised trialLow quality
52 people40 days treatment plus 30-day telephone follow-up
mesoglycan group had a significantly greater reduction in overall symptom score than placebo, with bleeding improving significantly only in the grade III subgroup
- Who was studied
- adults with symptomatic grade II to III hemorrhoids
- What they received
- oral mesoglycan
- Compared with
- placebo
- Main outcome
- change in hemorrhoid symptom score (itching, pain, bleeding, swelling) from baseline to day 40
- Quality
- This was a small phase 2 trial of 52 patients, so the results need confirmation in larger studies.
- Limitations
- Small sample size (52 patients), phase 2 trial, bleeding benefit only shown in a subgroup (grade III) rather than the whole group.
Taken word for word from the abstract
- n
Fifty-two patients were randomized (26 mesoglycan, 26 placebo), and 48 completed the study.
- population
enrolled adults with symptomatic grade II to III hemorrhoidal disease
- intervention
receive oral mesoglycan or placebo for 40 days
- comparator
Participants were randomly assigned (1:1) to receive oral mesoglycan or placebo for 40 days
- primaryOutcome
The primary endpoint was the change in the Hemorrhoidal Disease Symptom Score from baseline to day 40.
- result
mesoglycan resulted in a significantly greater reduction in Hemorrhoidal Disease Symptom Score compared with placebo (-7.5 ± 5.9 vs -3.9 ± 5.4; P = .027)
- result
Bleeding improved significantly in the grade III subgroup (P = .03).
Surgery · PMID 42442141 · Read it on PubMed ↗
Zamlout et al. 2026
Laser hemorrhoidoplasty versus LigaSure hemorrhoidectomy for grade II-IV hemorrhoidal disease: a systematic review and meta-analysis
Less pain, but more recurrence.Meta-analysisVery low qualityRelated question
461 people2026
LHP caused less pain and faster recovery, but had higher recurrence than LigH; no difference in bleeding or other complications
- Who was studied
- adults with grade II-IV hemorrhoids
- What they received
- laser hemorrhoidoplasty (LHP)
- Compared with
- LigaSure hemorrhoidectomy (LigH)
- Main outcome
- postoperative pain, time to return to routine activities, and recurrence
- Quality
- The abstract itself states the certainty of evidence is very low, based on only five small studies.
- Limitations
- Certainty of evidence is very low; based on only five studies; authors call for further high-quality randomized trials.
Taken word for word from the abstract
- n
Data from 461 patients (213 LHP, 248 LigH) across five studies were analyzed.
- population
We included all eligible studies involving adults with grade II-IV hemorrhoids.
- intervention
laser hemorrhoidoplasty (LHP)
- comparator
LigaSure hemorrhoidectomy (LigH)
- primaryOutcome
Primary outcomes included postoperative pain, time to return to routine activities, and recurrence.
- result
Patients in the LHP group reported significantly lower pain scores on postoperative day 1 (MD: - 1.61 points; p = 0.025), earlier return to routine activities (MD: -5.75 days; p = 0.0002), shorter operative time (MD: -6.5 min; p = 0.002), and shorter hospital stay (MD: -0.3 days; p < 0.0001) compared to the LigH group. Conversely, LigH demonstrated a significantly lower risk of recurrence (RD: 0.12; 95% CI: [0.05, 0.19]). No significant differences were observed regarding postoperative bleeding, wound infection, urinary retention, or thrombosis.
- quality
The certainty of evidence is very low.
BMC Surg · PMID 42374341 · Read it on PubMed ↗
Wu et al. 2026
Cap-assisted endoscopic sclerotherapy for bleeding-predominant grade III hemorrhoids: efficacy and risk factor analysis focusing on two dimensions of bleeding score
Sclerotherapy reduced bleeding, but often recurred.RetrospectiveLow quality
82 people24 months
96.3% had improved bleeding symptoms at 3 months, but 25.3% had bleeding recurrence by 24 months
- Who was studied
- patients with bleeding grade III internal hemorrhoids
- What they received
- cap-assisted endoscopic sclerotherapy with polidocanol injection via long needle
- Compared with
- none (single-arm, before-after comparison)
- Main outcome
- improvement in bleeding and prolapse symptoms at 3 months, and bleeding recurrence over follow-up
- Quality
- This was a retrospective study with no comparison group, so it can't prove the treatment itself caused the improvement.
- Limitations
- Single-arm retrospective design without a control group; single-center study implied by patient count.
Taken word for word from the abstract
- n
This single-arm retrospective observational study included 82 patients with bleeding-predominant grade III internal HDs
- population
82 patients with bleeding-predominant grade III internal HDs
- intervention
Cap-assisted endoscopic sclerotherapy (CAES) via a long needle
- intervention
single CAES procedure by the injection of liquid polidocanol via a long needle
- comparator
This single-arm retrospective observational study
- primaryOutcome
Treatment efficacy was assessed at 3 months post-CAES using the conventional Hemorrhoid Disease Severity Score (HDSS; based on the frequency of symptoms, including bleeding) and the score of the intensity dimension of the bleeding symptom.
- result
The effective rates for bleeding and prolapse symptoms were 96.3% and 58.2%, respectively.
- result
During a follow-up of 24 months, the bleeding recurrence rate was 25.3% (20/79).
- followUp
During a follow-up of 24 months
Tech Coloproctol · PMID 42323500 · Read it on PubMed ↗
Alsalaumy 2026
Open haemorrhoidectomy combined with lateral internal sphincterotomy versus conventional haemorrhoidectomy: a prospective randomized comparative study
Less pain and bleeding after surgeryRandomised trialLow qualityRelated question
120 peopletwo weeks
adding sphincterotomy reduced pain and early bleeding compared with hemorrhoidectomy alone
- Who was studied
- adults with grade III or IV hemorrhoids having surgery
- What they received
- open hemorrhoidectomy plus lateral internal sphincterotomy
- Compared with
- open hemorrhoidectomy alone
- Main outcome
- postoperative pain and bleeding after surgery
- Quality
- it is a randomized trial but single-center, only 120 patients, outcomes partly based on unblinded patient report, and the trial was registered only after it finished.
- Limitations
- abstract does not mention blinding of outcome assessors, long-term follow-up beyond two weeks, or details on bleeding severity or need for intervention.
Taken word for word from the abstract
- population
A total of 120 patients with Grade III or IV haemorrhoids
- intervention
the group of open haemorrhoidectomy with lateral internal sphincterotomy (Group A, n = 60)
- comparator
the group of open haemorrhoidectomy alone (Group B, n = 60)
- primaryOutcome
Pain and postoperative bleeding were compared during the first 24 h, 48 h, one week and two weeks thereafter.
- result
Bleeding occurred in 5% of patients in Group A compared to 41.6% in Group B at 24 h (p < 0.001), and in 5% versus 35% at 48 h (p < 0.001). No further bleeding episodes were observed in Group A beyond the first postoperative week.
- n
A total of 120 patients with Grade III or IV haemorrhoids were randomly divided into two groups
BMC Surg · PMID 41992176 · Read it on PubMed ↗
Huang et al. 2026
Evaluation of short-term outcomes of Endoscopic Super-Hemorrhoidal Banding for mixed hemorrhoids with prolapsed internal hemorrhoids: a retrospective study
Similar cure rate, less pain with bandingRetrospectiveLow quality
480 people2026
Cure rates were similar between groups, but the banding procedure had shorter surgery and hospital stay, less pain, and fewer urinary retention complications; one patient in each group had severe bleeding that was stopped with suture or endoscopic clip closure
- Who was studied
- mixed hemorrhoids with Grade II-IV internal hemorrhoid prolapse as the main symptom
- What they received
- Endoscopic Super-hemorrhoidal Banding (ESHB)
- Compared with
- Milligan-Morgan hemorrhoidectomy (MMH)
- Main outcome
- cure rate and postoperative complications including bleeding
- Quality
- This was a retrospective comparison of two surgeries without randomization, so differences between groups could be due to factors other than the treatment itself, and follow-up was short-term.
- Limitations
- Retrospective observational design with no randomization; abstract states long-term efficacy still requires further validation
Taken word for word from the abstract
- n
245 patients underwent Milligan-Morgan hemorrhoidectomy (MMH) and 235 patients underwent ESHB
- population
mixed hemorrhoids with Grade II-IV internal hemorrhoid prolapse as the main symptom
- intervention
Endoscopic Super-hemorrhoidal Banding (ESHB)
- comparator
patients underwent Milligan-Morgan hemorrhoidectomy (MMH) as the control group
- primaryOutcome
Treatment outcomes included efficacy measurement, operative time, hospital stay, postoperative anal pain scores, and incidence of complications like bleeding and urinary retention were compared.
- result
The cure rates were 69.36% in the ESHB group and 72.65% in the MMH group, with no statistically significant difference between the two groups (P > 0.05). The observation group had significantly shorter operative time and hospital stay (P < 0.01), lower postoperative anal pain scores and incidence of urinary retention (P < 0.01). One patient in each group had severe postoperative bleeding, which stopped after surgical suture or endoscopic titanium clip closure.
BMC Surg · PMID 41987169 · Read it on PubMed ↗
Wang et al. 2026
Ruiyun procedure for hemorrhoids versus tissue-selective therapy stapler for grade II-III hemorrhoids: an exploratory retrospective comparative study
Similar healing, fewer complications with one surgeryRetrospectiveLow qualityRelated question
192 people1 year
no significant difference in overall efficacy or one-year recurrence, but RPH had shorter operative time, less bleeding, faster recovery and higher satisfaction
- Who was studied
- patients with Grade II-III hemorrhoids
- What they received
- Ruiyun procedure for hemorrhoids (RPH)
- Compared with
- tissue-selecting therapy (TST) stapler
- Main outcome
- treatment effectiveness rate at one month and recurrence rate within one year after surgery
- Quality
- it is a retrospective, non-randomized comparison of two surgeries with possible differences in patient selection, so it carries limited weight on bleeding mechanisms or treatment.
- Limitations
- retrospective design with potential differences in baseline characteristics between groups, limiting causal interpretation
Taken word for word from the abstract
- n
A retrospective analysis was conducted on 192 patients with Grade II-III hemorrhoids, comprising 80 patients who underwent RPH and 112 who underwent TST.
- population
patients with Grade II-III hemorrhoids
- intervention
Ruiyun procedure for hemorrhoids (RPH)
- comparator
tissue-selecting therapy (TST)
- primaryOutcome
The primary outcomes were the treatment effectiveness rate at one month and the recurrence rate within one year postoperatively.
- result
No significant differences were found in the overall clinical efficacy or the one-year recurrence rate between the groups (p > 0.05). However, the RPH group demonstrated significant advantages, including shorter operative time, reduced intraoperative blood loss, faster return to normal activities, lower anal pain scores on postoperative days 1 and 3, a lower incidence of fecal urgency and higher patient satisfaction (all p < 0.05).
BMC Surg · PMID 41906143 · Read it on PubMed ↗
Marino et al. 2026
Ligasure versus voyant hemorrhoidectomy: comparison of 30-day postoperative complications
Similar complication rates between devices.Prospective cohortLow qualityRelated question
123 people30-day
no significant differences in bleeding, urinary retention, or anal stenosis between the two devices
- Who was studied
- adults with grade III and IV hemorrhoids undergoing surgical removal
- What they received
- LigaSure radiofrequency hemorrhoidectomy
- Compared with
- Voyant radiofrequency hemorrhoidectomy
- Main outcome
- 30-day postoperative complications: bleeding, urinary retention, and anal stenosis
- Quality
- This was a small, non-randomized observational comparison of two surgical devices, not a trial testing why hemorrhoids bleed or how to stop it medically.
- Limitations
- Observational (not randomized) design, single comparison of two surgical devices rather than addressing bleeding mechanism or non-surgical treatment.
Taken word for word from the abstract
- population
grade III and IV hemorrhoids
- intervention
LigaSure hemorrhoidectomy
- comparator
Voyant hemorrhoidectomy
- primaryOutcome
compare the 30-day postoperative outcomes of LigaSure hemorrhoidectomy versus Voyant hemorrhoidectomy for grade III and IV hemorrhoids in terms of bleeding, urinary retention, and anal stenosis
- result
No statistical differences were observed between the two groups in terms of postoperative bleeding, urinary retention, and anal stenosis.
- n
In total, 123 patients were enrolled (61 in group A and 62 in group B).
Minerva Surg · PMID 41804964 · Read it on PubMed ↗
Öner et al. 2026
Effect of Doppler-guided Hemorrhoidal Artery Ligation Technique and Mucopexy on Posttreatment Symptoms in Hemorrhoidal Disease
Less pain, but more recurrence in severe cases.RetrospectiveLow quality
94 peopleyear 1
pain dropped sharply by one month, 92.6% had symptoms resolve, but recurrence was much higher in grade IV disease (31.25%) than grade III (8.16%)
- Who was studied
- adults with symptomatic grade II to IV hemorrhoids not helped by other treatment
- What they received
- Doppler-guided hemorrhoidal artery ligation, with or without mucopexy
- Compared with
- before vs after surgery, no separate comparison group
- Main outcome
- pain scores, symptom resolution, and recurrence after surgery
- Quality
- This was a retrospective look-back at one group's records with no comparison group, so it can't prove the procedure itself caused the improvement.
- Limitations
- Retrospective design, no control group, single-center database
Taken word for word from the abstract
- n
A total of 94 patients (59 males, 35 females; mean age: 47.8 ± 12.4 y) underwent the procedure.
- population
patients with symptomatic grade II to IV hemorrhoidal disease
- intervention
Doppler-guided hemorrhoidal artery ligation (DG-HAL) technique, with or without concomitant mucopexy
- comparator
A retrospective analysis was conducted using a prospectively maintained database of patients who underwent DG-HAL ± mucopexy
- primaryOutcome
Treatment efficacy was evaluated based on changes in symptom severity and hemorrhoid grade across follow-up periods.
- result
Mean Visual Analogue Scale (VAS) scores for pain were 7.43 (postoperative day 1), 1.72 (week 1), and 0.37 (month 1), demonstrating significant improvement (P < 0.001).
- result
Recurrence rates were 8.16% (4/49) in grade III and 31.25% (5/16) in grade IV hemorrhoids.
- result
Overall symptom resolution was achieved in 92.6% of patients, and 90.4% reported high satisfaction with the treatment.
Surg Laparosc Endosc Percutan Tech · PMID 41635963 · Read it on PubMed ↗
Gao et al. 2026
Comparative efficacy of Ma Yinglong ointment and Gangtai suppository for hemorrhoids: A retrospective cohort study
Mixed: less pain with one, less bleeding with other.RetrospectiveLow quality
514 people14 days
Ma Yinglong gave better pain/swelling relief and quality of life, but Gangtai suppository gave slightly better bleeding control; overall response rates and adverse reactions were similar
- Who was studied
- patients with hemorrhoids
- What they received
- Ma Yinglong hemorrhoid ointment
- Compared with
- Gangtai suppository
- Main outcome
- symptom scores (pain, swelling, bleeding) and quality of life at 7 and 14 days
- Quality
- This was a retrospective, non-randomized comparison, so differences between groups could be due to other factors, not just the treatments.
- Limitations
- Retrospective cohort design without randomization; abstract does not mention blinding or statistical significance testing for all comparisons.
Taken word for word from the abstract
- n
514 hemorrhoid patients (2024) were equally divided into Ma Yinglong (n=257) and Gangtai suppository (n=257) groups
- population
Hemorrhoidal disease (HD) is a common anorectal condition
- intervention
Ma Yinglong hemorrhoid ointment
- comparator
Gangtai Suppositories
- primaryOutcome
Symptom scores, quality of life and adverse reactions were compared between the two groups at days 7 and 14.
- result
Ma Yinglong Hemorrhoid Ointment demonstrated significant advantages in pain relief Visual Simulation Score (VAS score: 1.2 vs 2.0) and swelling reduction, with markedly improved quality of life scores (88.7 vs 76.3). The Gangtai Suppository treatment group showed superior bleeding control (bleeding score: 0.6 vs 0.7).
Pak J Pharm Sci · PMID 41620906 · Read it on PubMed ↗
Yin et al. 2026
Preliminary Results of Open Excisional Hemorrhoidectomy Combined With 3% Polidocanol Foam Sclerotherapy in Patients With Grade IV Hemorrhoidal Disease: A Randomized Controlled Open-Label Single-Center Study
Faster recovery, less post-op bleeding.Randomised trialLow quality
36 people1 to 2 months
recovery was about 6 days faster, with less bleeding and less pain medication use, with added sclerotherapy
- Who was studied
- adults aged 18 to 75 with grade IV hemorrhoids undergoing surgery
- What they received
- surgical hemorrhoid removal plus polidocanol foam injection into remaining tissue
- Compared with
- surgical hemorrhoid removal alone
- Main outcome
- time to return to daily activities
- Quality
- Very small, single-center, unblinded trial with short follow-up, so results may not hold up in larger studies.
- Limitations
- Small sample size, nonblinded, single-center design, and short follow-up period.
Taken word for word from the abstract
- n
Thirty-six patients aged 18 to 75 years with grade IV hemorrhoidal disease were enrolled and randomized equally to 2 groups.
- population
Thirty-six patients aged 18 to 75 years with grade IV hemorrhoidal disease were enrolled and randomized equally to 2 groups.
- intervention
The experimental group underwent Milligan-Morgan hemorrhoidectomy combined with 3% polidocanol foam sclerotherapy
- comparator
the control group underwent Milligan-Morgan hemorrhoidectomy with no additional therapy
- primaryOutcome
The primary outcome was the time to return to daily activities.
- result
The experimental group demonstrated a mean 5.78-day earlier return to normal activities and work than the control group (mean ± SD: 19.28 ± 8.35 vs 25.06 ± 7.85 days; 95% CI, -11.27 to -0.29 days; p = 0.04), reduced postoperative bleeding (0-3 scale; estimate -0.45; 95% CI, -0.72 to -0.16; p = 0.002), lower analgesic use (0-3 scale; estimate -0.38; 95% CI, -0.66 to -0.09; p = 0.009)
- limitations
Small sample size, nonblinded, single-center design, and short follow-up period.
- followUp
improved symptom scores at 1 to 2 months
Dis Colon Rectum · PMID 41603644 · Read it on PubMed ↗
Han et al. 2025
[Multicenter, randomized, open-label, and positive-controlled clinical trial of Pien Tze Huang Capsules combined with Compound Pien Tze Huang Hemorrhoid Ointment in postoperative management of mixed hemorrhoids]
Less wound ooze, not less bleeding.Randomised trialModerate qualityRelated question
240 peoplepostoperative day 7
Wound exudation scores were significantly lower with Pien Tze Huang treatment, but wound bleeding scores and granulation scores showed no significant difference between groups
- Who was studied
- patients who had surgery (Milligan-Morgan hemorrhoidectomy) for mixed hemorrhoids
- What they received
- Pien Tze Huang Capsules taken orally plus Compound Pien Tze Huang Hemorrhoid Ointment applied to the wound, on top of standard sitz baths
- Compared with
- Mayinglong Shexiang Hemorrhoid Ointment applied to the wound, on top of standard sitz baths
- Main outcome
- wound fluid discharge, wound bleeding, and new tissue growth scores after surgery
- Quality
- It was a randomized multicenter trial with a reasonable sample size, but it was open-label (not blinded) and only followed wounds for 7 days using scored outcomes rather than hard clinical endpoints.
- Limitations
- Open-label design, short 7-day treatment and follow-up period, and no statistically significant benefit on bleeding, pain, or granulation outcomes.
Taken word for word from the abstract
- population
patients who underwent Milligan-Morgan hemorrhoidectomy for mixed hemorrhoids were enrolled
- intervention
The treatment group additionally received Pien Tze Huang Capsules orally(2 capsules per dose, 3 times per day) and topical application of Compound Pien Tze Huang Hemorrhoid Ointment(2.5 g, twice per day)
- comparator
the control group received topical Mayinglong Shexiang Hemorrhoid Ointment(2.5 g, twice per day)
- primaryOutcome
Primary efficacy endpoints included wound exudation scores, wound bleeding scores, and wound granulation tissue formation scores
- result
the wound exudation scores on postoperative day 7 was significantly lower in the treatment group compared to that in the control group(P<0.05)
- result
No statistically significant differences were observed between the two groups in wound bleeding scores, wound granulation tissue formation scores, analgesic use rate or amount, or incidence of adverse reactions
- n
A total of 240 patients who underwent Milligan-Morgan hemorrhoidectomy for mixed hemorrhoids were enrolled
Zhongguo Zhong Yao Za Zhi · PMID 41508088 · Read it on PubMed ↗
Ren et al. 2026
Evaluation of the nursing effect of mirabilite fomentation on postoperative edema, pain, and urinary retention in patients with mixed hemorrhoids
Less bleeding, faster healing after surgeryRetrospectiveLow qualityRelated question
72 peopleday 7
mirabilite group had lower bleeding scores, less edema, less pain, lower urinary retention, and faster wound healing than control
- Who was studied
- patients who had surgery for mixed hemorrhoids (external stripping and internal ligation)
- What they received
- mirabilite fomentation as a post-surgery nursing treatment
- Compared with
- standard postoperative nursing care (control group)
- Main outcome
- postoperative bleeding, edema, pain, and urinary retention after hemorrhoid surgery
- Quality
- This was a retrospective, single-center study without randomization, so bias and confounding can't be ruled out despite statistical matching.
- Limitations
- Retrospective design, single hospital, no randomization, and the question here is about causes and treatment of hemorrhoid bleeding generally, while this study only examines post-surgical nursing care.
Taken word for word from the abstract
- population
patients who underwent external stripping and internal ligation for circumferential mixed hemorrhoids
- intervention
single-agent mirabilite fomentation
- comparator
Patients were divided into a mirabilite fomentation group and a control group according to postoperative nursing methods
- primaryOutcome
Observational indicators included postoperative bleeding, anal margin edema, sensation of distension, pain (visual analogue scale), urinary retention and time to first urination, wound healing time, overall efficacy, adverse reactions, and patient satisfaction
- result
the mirabilite fomentation group had lower bleeding scores on postoperative day 3 and day 7
- result
The reduction in edema area and height was more pronounced (both P < .05)
- result
The incidence of urinary retention was lower in the mirabilite group (11.1% vs 30.6%, P = .044)
- result
Wound healing time was reduced (14.53 ± 2.17 days vs 17.06 ± 2.48 days, P < .001)
- n
Propensity score matching was applied to control confounding factors, yielding 72 comparable cases (36 in each group).
Medicine (Baltimore) · PMID 41496147 · Read it on PubMed ↗
Liao et al. 2025
[Endoscopic rubber band ligation and injection therapy for grade I - III internal hemorrhoids: analysis of clinical efficacy and safety]
Both treatments similarly effective; ERBL caused more bleedingRetrospectiveLow qualityRelated question
313 people3 months
No significant difference in effectiveness between ERBL and EIS, but ERBL had higher complication rates including bleeding and urinary retention, while EIS had less pain and less anal distension
- Who was studied
- patients with grade I-III internal hemorrhoids who failed conservative treatment or couldn't have surgery
- What they received
- endoscopic rubber band ligation (ERBL)
- Compared with
- endoscopic injection sclerotherapy (EIS)
- Main outcome
- treatment effectiveness (cure/improvement) and recurrence rate within 3 months after procedure
- Quality
- This is a retrospective study comparing two treatments without a true control group, so it cannot show why hemorrhoids bleed or test what stops bleeding directly.
- Limitations
- Retrospective design, not randomized, and focuses on comparing two active treatments rather than explaining bleeding mechanism or an untreated comparison.
Taken word for word from the abstract
- n
a total of 313 patients were included, including 200 in the ERBL group and 113 in the EIS group
- population
A total of 613 patients with grade I to III internal hemorrhoids who underwent ERBL or EIS
- intervention
endoscopic rubber band ligation (ERBL)
- comparator
endoscopic injection sclerotherapy (EIS)
- primaryOutcome
Statistical analysis revealed no statistically significant difference in efficacy between the two groups within 3 months after the operation
- result
The total incidence of complications in the ERBL group was significantly higher than that in the EIS group [29.5% (59/200) vs. 4.4% (5/113), χ²=27.910, P<0.001], mainly reflected in postoperative bleeding [18.0% (36/200) vs. 3.5% (4/113), χ²=13.544, P<0.001] and urinary retention [8.5% (17/200) vs. 0, χ²=10.157, P=0.001]
Zhonghua Wei Chang Wai Ke Za Zhi · PMID 41397826 · Read it on PubMed ↗
Tin et al. 2025
The aCute HemORrhoidal disease evALuation International Study (CHORALIS): Subanalysis of the effectiveness of conservative treatment during the acute phase of hemorrhoidal disease in Vietnam
Bleeding and other symptoms improved.Prospective cohortLow quality
202 peoplefour weeks
bleeding improved in 68.2% of patients in the venoactive drug group by week one, and overall symptoms decreased from a mean of 4.6 to 1.0 by week four
- Who was studied
- adults with acute hemorrhoidal disease in Vietnam
- What they received
- conservative treatment, mainly a venoactive drug (micronized purified flavonoid fraction)
- Compared with
- none reported; outcomes compared to patients' own baseline over time
- Main outcome
- improvement in hemorrhoid symptoms (pain, discomfort, bleeding) and quality of life
- Quality
- This was an observational study without a comparison group, so improvement over time cannot be clearly attributed to the treatment itself.
- Limitations
- No control group was used, and the study only measured changes over time within treated patients.
Taken word for word from the abstract
- n
Among the 202 patients
- population
adult patients (≥18 years) diagnosed with acute hemorrhoidal disease (≤48 h since onset) who received conservative treatment
- intervention
conservative treatment, particularly micronized purified flavonoid fraction-based therapy
- comparator
At week one, the venoactive drug group showed symptom improvement rates of 63% for pain, 56.8% for discomfort, and 68.2% for bleeding.
- primaryOutcome
assess the effectiveness of conservative treatment in improving symptoms and quality of life in patients with acute hemorrhoids in Vietnam
- result
The mean number of symptoms per patient decreased from 4.6 ± 1.9 at baseline to 1.0 ± 1.5 at week four.
- result
At week one, the venoactive drug group showed symptom improvement rates of 63% for pain, 56.8% for discomfort, and 68.2% for bleeding.
J Int Med Res · PMID 41299195 · Read it on PubMed ↗
Liao et al. 2025
Short-term and patient-reported outcomes of laser hemorrhoidoplasty plus excisional hemorrhoidectomy for the treatment of grade IV hemorrhoid
Less pain, bleeding improved by surgeryRetrospectiveLow qualityRelated question
232 peoplepostoperative week 6
Laser plus excisional surgery caused less urinary retention and less pain than LigaSure surgery, and bleeding improved by 6 weeks after surgery
- Who was studied
- patients with grade IV hemorrhoids
- What they received
- laser hemorrhoidoplasty plus excisional hemorrhoidectomy
- Compared with
- LigaSure hemorrhoidectomy
- Main outcome
- surgical results and 30-day complications
- Quality
- This was a retrospective study comparing patients treated at different time periods rather than a randomized trial, so differences could be due to other factors.
- Limitations
- retrospective design with historical (non-randomized) comparison group; authors state further prospective studies with larger numbers are needed
Taken word for word from the abstract
- n
A total of 92 patients who underwent LHP plus EH and 140 who underwent LigaSure hemorrhoidectomy were included.
- population
Patients with grade IV hemorrhoid undergoing LHP plus EH
- intervention
LHP plus excisional hemorrhoidectomy (EH)
- comparator
LigaSure hemorrhoidectomy
- primaryOutcome
The primary outcome was the surgical results and 30-day complications.
- result
Patients who underwent LHP plus EH had a lower frequency of urinary retention than those who underwent LigaSure hemorrhoidectomy.
- result
Regarding patient-reported outcomes, pain, bleeding, and prolapse improved after postoperative week 6.
- followUp
improved after postoperative week 6
Sci Rep · PMID 41285870 · Read it on PubMed ↗
Xiang et al. 2025
The effect of endoscopic polidocanol carbon dioxide foam for internal hemorrhoids: a retrospective study
Same effectiveness, fewer pain complicationsRetrospectiveLow qualityRelated question
158 people1 month
Both foams were equally effective, but carbon dioxide foam caused significantly less anal pain and swelling
- Who was studied
- patients with internal hemorrhoids
- What they received
- endoscopic sclerotherapy with polidocanol carbon dioxide foam
- Compared with
- endoscopic sclerotherapy with polidocanol air foam
- Main outcome
- clinical effectiveness and complication rate one month after treatment
- Quality
- This is a retrospective, non-randomized comparison without blinding, so differences could be due to factors other than the treatment itself.
- Limitations
- Retrospective design, not randomized, relies partly on patient self-report, single timepoint follow-up of one month.
Taken word for word from the abstract
- population
internal hemorrhoids
- n
A retrospective analysis was conducted on 158 patients who received endoscopic polidocanol foam sclerotherapy for internal hemorrhoids between October 2022 and September 2023.
- intervention
received polidocanol carbon dioxide foam (study group)
- comparator
underwent endoscopic polidocanol sclerotherapy with polidocanol air foam (control group)
- primaryOutcome
The primary outcomes of this study were clinical effect and the incidence of complications 1 month after surgery.
- result
The study group exhibited significantly fewer patients with anal pain and anal swelling compared to the control group (P < 0.05), and importantly, no severe complications were observed.
- result
Both groups exhibited comparable clinical effects, surgical costs, hospitalization durations, and dosages of polidocanol, with no statistically significant differences observed (all P > 0.05).
PeerJ · PMID 41282992 · Read it on PubMed ↗
Wang et al. 2025
Comparative effectiveness and recurrence rates of endoscopic sclerotherapy, ligation, and combined therapy for grades I-III internal hemorrhoids
Combined ligation plus sclerotherapy worked best.RetrospectiveLow quality
253 people3 months
combined therapy had the highest efficacy (95.8%) and lowest recurrence (4.3%), followed by ligation then sclerotherapy, especially for more severe grades
- Who was studied
- patients with grade I-III internal hemorrhoids treated at one hospital
- What they received
- endoscopic treatments for internal hemorrhoids: sclerotherapy, rubber band ligation, and combined ligation-sclerotherapy
- Compared with
- the three endoscopic treatment methods compared against each other
- Main outcome
- treatment efficacy within 3 months and recurrence of symptoms after 3 months
- Quality
- This was a retrospective study without randomization, with small group sizes (especially the combined therapy group of only 24 patients), so differences between treatments may not be reliable.
- Limitations
- Retrospective design; unequal and small group sizes, particularly the combined therapy group (n=24); no mention of blinding or control for confounding factors.
Taken word for word from the abstract
- n
A total of 253 patients were included
- population
patients who underwent endoscopic minimally-invasive treatment for internal hemorrhoids at Wuhu First People's Hospital from January 2020 to December 2024
- intervention
endoscopic sclerotherapy (ES), endoscopic rubber band ligation (RBL), and combined ligation - sclerotherapy (CT)
- comparator
Patients were divided into ES, RBL, and CT groups.
- primaryOutcome
Efficacy was assessed within 3 months post-treatment, and recurrence was defined as symptom reappearance > 3 months post-treatment.
- result
the efficacy rate was 90.6% (95/107) for ES, 92.6% (113/122) for RBL, and 95.8% (23/24) for CT. CT showed the highest efficacy, especially for grade III hemorrhoids (95.0% [19/20]).
- result
CT had the lowest rate (4.3% [1/23]), followed by RBL (9.7% [11/113]) and ES (11.6% [11/95])
- followUp
Efficacy was assessed within 3 months post-treatment
BMC Surg · PMID 41239416 · Read it on PubMed ↗
Turunen et al. 2025
Massive Rectal Bleeding After Rubber Band Ligation of Internal Hemorrhoids: A Case Report
Found harmCase seriesVery low qualityRelated question
1 people2025
she had massive rectal bleeding 15 days later from an ulcer with a visible vessel at the banding site, stopped with a clip and hemostatic spray
- Who was studied
- a 34-year-old woman with internal hemorrhoids treated with rubber band ligation
- What they received
- rubber band ligation of internal hemorrhoids
- Compared with
- none
- Main outcome
- delayed rectal bleeding after the procedure and how it was stopped
- Quality
- this is a single patient case report, so it cannot show how often this happens or what reliably works.
- Limitations
- single case report; no comparison group; cannot estimate frequency or generalize treatment effectiveness
Taken word for word from the abstract
- n
A 34-year-old White woman presented with massive rectal bleeding
- population
A 34-year-old White woman presented with massive rectal bleeding 15 days after suction RBL of internal hemorrhoids
- intervention
Rubber band ligation (RBL) is a common treatment for internal hemorrhoids
- comparator
She was not taking anticoagulants, antiplatelets, or NSAIDs and had no history of bleeding disorders
- primaryOutcome
complications such as delayed bleeding can occur
- result
Flexible sigmoidoscopy revealed a 10-mm ulcer with a visible vessel at the previous banding site. Hemostasis was achieved with clip placement and hemostatic spray.
WMJ · PMID 41197059 · Read it on PubMed ↗
Wang et al. 2025
Modified sclerobanding versus rubber band ligation for grade II/III hemorrhoidal disease: a retrospective study
Less bleeding, fewer treatment failures.RetrospectiveLow quality
307 peopleOne-year follow-up
modified sclerobanding had no delayed major bleeding cases versus five in the rubber band ligation group, lower recurrence (6.8% vs 17.0%) and lower treatment failure (6.8% vs 18.6%)
- Who was studied
- patients with grade II/III hemorrhoidal disease
- What they received
- modified sclerobanding (rubber band ligation combined with polidocanol foam sclerotherapy)
- Compared with
- traditional rubber band ligation alone
- Main outcome
- treatment failure rate and delayed massive bleeding after the procedure
- Quality
- this was a retrospective, non-randomized comparison from one hospital, so other differences between groups could explain the results.
- Limitations
- retrospective design, single center, baseline differences in anticoagulant history and hospital stay length between groups
Taken word for word from the abstract
- n
Among the 307 patients, 162 received mSB and 125 underwent traditional RBL.
- population
patients with grade II/III HD who underwent RBL
- intervention
modified sclerobanding (mSB) procedure, which combines rubber band ligation (RBL) with 3% polidocanol foam sclerotherapy (PFS)
- comparator
traditional RBL
- primaryOutcome
The primary outcomes assessed were treatment failure rates and the incidence of delayed massive bleeding (DMB)
- result
The mSB group had no cases of delayed major bleeding, compared to five cases in the RBL group. The recurrence (6.8% vs. 17.0%) and treatment failure (6.8% vs. 18.6%) rates were significantly lower in the mSB group (P < 0.05).
Int J Colorectal Dis · PMID 41047429 · Read it on PubMed ↗
Chiarioni et al. 2025
The Combination of Fluocinolone Acetonide and Ketocaine Hydrochloride in the Conservative Management of Symptomatic Hemorrhoidal Disease: An Overview of Preclinical and Clinical Data
Eases pain and swellingNarrative reviewLow qualityRelated question
size not given2025
the combination provided rapid symptom relief and was well tolerated, with mostly mild and temporary side effects
- Who was studied
- people with hemorrhoidal disease
- What they received
- topical fluocinolone acetonide and ketocaine hydrochloride combination
- Main outcome
- relief of hemorrhoid symptoms such as pain, itching, and inflammation
- Quality
- this is a narrative overview citing unspecified preclinical and clinical data without describing study design, size, or statistics, so it carries limited weight.
- Limitations
- abstract does not describe study methodology, number of patients, comparator treatment, or specific data on bleeding outcomes
Taken word for word from the abstract
- population
Hemorrhoidal disease (HD) is a prevalent anorectal disorder that affects up to 36% of the general population.
- intervention
Topical formulations containing fluocinolone acetonide (FLA) and ketocaine hydrochloride (KH) combine anti-inflammatory and anesthetic effects, providing rapid and sustained relief from pain, itching, and inflammation.
- primaryOutcome
providing rapid and sustained relief from pain, itching, and inflammation
- result
Treatment with FLA/KH is an effective and well-tolerated option for managing acute HD.
- result
The FLA/KH formulation provides targeted local action with minimal systemic absorption and predominantly mild and transient adverse events.
J Gastrointestin Liver Dis · PMID 41004811 · Read it on PubMed ↗
Suzuki 2025
Combined therapy of HIFU rectoanal lifting (HIFU-RAL) and sclerotherapy for prolapsed hemorrhoids and rectal mucosal prolapse: A case series
Prolapse shrank, no bleeding data given.Case seriesVery low qualityRelated question
10 people16.0 months
prolapsed lesions were visibly reduced or resolved immediately after the procedure, with no adverse events or recurrences during follow-up
- Who was studied
- adults with prolapsed hemorrhoids or rectal mucosal prolapse
- What they received
- combined HIFU rectoanal lifting (HIFU-RAL) and ALTA sclerotherapy
- Main outcome
- reduction or resolution of the prolapsed hemorrhoid or rectal mucosal lesion
- Quality
- This is a very small case series of only 10 patients with no control group, so it cannot reliably show whether the treatment works better than other options.
- Limitations
- Small sample size, no comparator group, and the abstract does not specifically address hemorrhoid bleeding or why hemorrhoids bleed.
Taken word for word from the abstract
- n
This case series included 10 symptomatic patients, consisting of 5 men and 5 women.
- population
Clinical examination identified 8 cases of prolapsed hemorrhoids (Goligher grade III-IV) and 2 cases of rectal mucosal prolapse.
- intervention
we applied a transanal high-intensity focused ultrasound (HIFU) technique, namely HIFU rectal lifting (HIFU-RAL), combined with aluminum potassium sulfate and tannic acid (ALTA) sclerotherapy for treating prolapsed hemorrhoids
- primaryOutcome
The combined efficacy of HIFU-RAL and ALTA sclerotherapy was evaluated over time.
- result
In all cases, the prolapsed lesions were visibly reduced or resolved immediately after the procedure.
- followUp
median: 16.0 months; interquartile range: 10.5-25.8 months
Medicine (Baltimore) · PMID 40922264 · Read it on PubMed ↗
Al Jnainati et al. 2025
Outcomes of embolization therapy of superior rectal arteries for the management of grade 1 to 3 internal hemorrhoids: a systematic Review of clinical studies
Embolization reduced hemorrhoid bleeding in most.Systematic reviewLow quality
810 people2025
technical success in 93-100% of procedures, symptom/bleeding improvement in 63-94%, mild self-limited side effects, and symptoms returning in 8-20% of patients
- Who was studied
- adults with grade I-III internal hemorrhoids, often when office treatments failed or surgery was not wanted
- What they received
- superior rectal artery embolization (the "Emborrhoid" procedure)
- Compared with
- mostly no direct comparison group; only two small studies compared it with rubber-band ligation or sclerotherapy
- Main outcome
- whether the procedure technically worked, whether bleeding/symptoms improved, complications, and return of symptoms
- Quality
- the review combined small, differently-designed studies without a pooled statistical analysis and had very few studies comparing embolization to other treatments.
- Limitations
- small single-center studies, inconsistent techniques, heterogeneity prevented meta-analysis, and few comparative trials against standard treatments
Taken word for word from the abstract
- population
grade I-III internal hemorrhoids when office therapies fail or surgery is undesirable
- intervention
Superior rectal artery embolization ("Emborrhoid") offers a catheter-based alternative
- comparator
Only two small, heterogeneous comparative studies versus rubber-band ligation or sclerotherapy were available, precluding a pooled analysis.
- primaryOutcome
Prespecified outcomes were technical success, clinical success (≥ 2-point fall in bleeding score or equivalent), adverse events, and recurrence.
- result
Technical success reached 93-100%. Clinical success ranged from 63 to 94%, yielding marked bleeding control and symptom relief.
- result
Recurrence necessitating repeat treatment affected 8-20% of patients, usually when collateral arterial supply persisted.
- n
Twenty-two studies encompassing 810 procedures qualified.
Int J Colorectal Dis · PMID 40877526 · Read it on PubMed ↗
Zhu et al. 2025
Multicenter analysis of the efficacy and factors related to recurrence of endoscopic sclerotherapy for internal hemorrhoids: a large-sample, retrospective cohort study
Sclerotherapy effective, low recurrence short-termRetrospectiveLow qualityRelated question
1,147 people3 to 49 months (mean: 25.61 ± 13.23 months)
92.85% of patients had an effective response, with 12.21% recurrence overall
- Who was studied
- patients with internal hemorrhoids
- What they received
- endoscopic sclerotherapy
- Compared with
- none (before/after comparison across hemorrhoid grades)
- Main outcome
- treatment effectiveness, complications, and recurrence rate
- Quality
- This is a retrospective study without a control group, so it cannot prove the treatment itself caused the improvement compared to no treatment.
- Limitations
- Retrospective design with no comparison group; abstract does not report how bleeding stopped mechanistically, only recurrence rates after treatment.
Taken word for word from the abstract
- n
A total of 1147 patients underwent the procedure
- population
patients with internal hemorrhoids treated with endoscopic sclerotherapy
- intervention
endoscopic sclerotherapy
- comparator
The recurrence rate, recurrence time, and related factors for different hemorrhoid grades were analyzed.
- primaryOutcome
assess hemorrhoid grading, treatment efficacy, complications, and recurrence rates
- result
The overall effective rate was 92.85% (1065/1147).
- followUp
follow-up periods ranging from 3 to 49 months (mean: 25.61 ± 13.23 months)
Surg Endosc · PMID 40856750 · Read it on PubMed ↗
Sipos et al. 2025
[Treatment of hemorrhoids with rectal artery embolization]
Bleeding and symptoms mostly resolved.Case seriesLow quality
15 people12-week
bleeding scale score dropped to an average of 0.23, and 14 of 15 patients became symptom-free
- Who was studied
- patients with stage 2 or 3 hemorrhoids (most with pain and bleeding)
- What they received
- superior rectal artery embolization (blocking blood flow to hemorrhoid vessels via a groin puncture)
- Compared with
- none (before-and-after in same patients)
- Main outcome
- hemorrhoidal bleeding scale score at 12-week follow-up
- Quality
- This is a small, uncontrolled case series of only 15 patients with no comparison group, so results could be due to other factors.
- Limitations
- Small sample size, no control group, first experience of operators, short follow-up period.
Taken word for word from the abstract
- n
our first 15 treated patients
- population
20% of our patients were in stage 2 and 80% were in stage 3 of the disease before the intervention. 80% of our patients had pain, 80% had bleeding
- intervention
superselective embolization of the superior mesenteric artery branches with hairy coils under local anesthesia from a femoral puncture
- comparator
The analysis of our clinical study was performed based on a prospective clinical design
- primaryOutcome
The average value on the basis of the hemorrhoidal bleeding scale during early control was 0.23 and the average value was 0.23 during the 12-week control
- result
Out of 15 patients, 14 became completely asymptomatic and complaint-free, and 1 patient’s hemorrhoidal bleeding scale value decreased from 6 to 3 during the follow-up
- followUp
during the 12-week control
Orv Hetil · PMID 40581923 · Read it on PubMed ↗
Martins et al. 2026
Operative versus nonoperative treatment of thrombosed external hemorrhoids: a systematic review and meta-analysis
Less recurrence with surgery, no bleeding difference.Meta-analysisModerate quality
851 people2026
Surgery lowered recurrence risk but showed no significant difference in bleeding risk compared to conservative treatment
- Who was studied
- patients with thrombosed external hemorrhoids
- What they received
- surgical treatment (excision surgery)
- Compared with
- nonoperative (conservative) management
- Main outcome
- risk of recurrence and risk of bleeding
- Quality
- It pooled six studies with moderate-to-high variability between them (I2 up to 60%), and bleeding results had a very wide confidence interval, limiting confidence.
- Limitations
- Heterogeneity between studies (I2 = 54% and 60%), and the bleeding comparison had a wide confidence interval crossing no effect
Taken word for word from the abstract
- n
We included six studies with a total of 851 patients, of whom 390 (45.8%) underwent surgical treatment.
- population
Thrombosed external hemorrhoids are a complication of hemorrhoids characterized by severe pain, swelling, and lump formation due to acute venous engorgement.
- intervention
Surgical treatment was associated with a lower risk of recurrence compared to conservative management
- comparator
identify clinical trials comparing surgery with conservative treatment in thrombosed external hemorrhoids
- primaryOutcome
there were no significant differences in the risk of bleeding between the groups (RR 0.96; 95% CI 0.27-3.44; P = 0.95; I2 = 60%)
- result
Our main findings indicated no significant difference in bleeding between surgery and conservative treatment groups. However, operative management is associated with significantly lower recurrences, which should be the preferred choice.
Updates Surg · PMID 40576944 · Read it on PubMed ↗
Alessa et al. 2025
The Outcome of Laser Ablation Hemorrhoidoplasty versus Conventional Hemorrhoidectomy
Less pain and bleeding after laserRetrospectiveLow qualityRelated question
100 people2025
Laser hemorrhoidoplasty patients had milder pain and less bleeding than conventional hemorrhoidectomy patients
- Who was studied
- patients with hemorrhoids (piles) undergoing surgical treatment
- What they received
- laser ablation hemorrhoidoplasty
- Compared with
- conventional surgical hemorrhoidectomy
- Main outcome
- postoperative pain and bleeding after surgery
- Quality
- This was a retrospective, non-randomized comparison with unequal disease severity between groups, so differences could be due to patient selection rather than the treatment itself.
- Limitations
- Retrospective design, groups differed in hemorrhoid severity (laser group had more second-degree, conventional group more severe third/fourth-degree), which could bias outcome comparisons.
Taken word for word from the abstract
- n
50 patients who underwent laser hemorrhoidoplasty and another 50 patients who underwent conventional hemorrhoidectomy
- population
50 patients who underwent laser hemorrhoidoplasty and another 50 patients who underwent conventional hemorrhoidectomy
- intervention
laser hemorrhoidoplasty
- comparator
conventional surgical hemorrhoidectomy
- primaryOutcome
Clinical outcomes revealed that laser hemorrhoidoplasty was associated with less postoperative pain and bleeding.
- result
bleeding outcomes were more favorable in the laser group, with 100% experiencing minor bleeding compared to the conventional group, which showed a higher incidence of both minor and moderate bleeding.
Ann Afr Med · PMID 40576418 · Read it on PubMed ↗
Zhang et al. 2025
The Comparison Between Endoscopic Ligation and Sclerotherapy on the Treatment Effect and Anorectal Function in Patients With Internal Hemorrhoids
Both treatments similar; sclerotherapy slightly better for bleeding.RetrospectiveLow quality
32 people3-month follow-up
no significant difference in treatment effect of postoperative bleeding, prolapse, constipation, and complications between the 2 groups, though CAES showed some advantage for bleeding
- Who was studied
- patients with internal hemorrhoids
- What they received
- endoscopic ligation
- Compared with
- cap-assisted endoscopic sclerotherapy (CAES)
- Main outcome
- treatment effect on bleeding, prolapse, constipation, complications, psychological condition and anorectal function
- Quality
- Very small, non-randomized comparative study with short 3-month follow-up, so results are uncertain.
- Limitations
- Small sample size (n=32), not randomized, short follow-up of 3 months
Taken word for word from the abstract
- n
Thirty-two patients who underwent minimally invasive endoscopic treatment for internal hemorrhoids were recruited
- population
patients with internal hemorrhoids
- intervention
Group A undergoing endoscopic ligation (n=14)
- comparator
Group B receiving CAES (n=18)
- primaryOutcome
To evaluate the treatment effect of endoscopic ligation and cap-assisted endoscopic sclerotherapy (CAES) for patients with internal hemorrhoids, symptom relief, complication rate and psychological condition, and the anorectal function were observed.
- result
There was no significant difference in the treatment effect of postoperative bleeding, prolapse, constipation, and complications between the 2 groups. However, Group A has certain advantages in the treatment of prolapse and constipation before and after treatment, and Group B has certain advantages in bleeding.
- followUp
with a 3-month follow-up
Surg Laparosc Endosc Percutan Tech · PMID 40530787 · Read it on PubMed ↗
Grossi et al. 2025
SHAPE-skin-sparing hemorrhoidectomy and PExy: a novel technique for the surgical treatment of hemorrhoidal disease
Symptoms sharply improved after surgery.Case seriesLow qualityRelated question
21 people1-month follow-up
symptom severity scores dropped sharply after surgery (HDSS from 16 to 0, SHS from 20 to 4), with few complications
- Who was studied
- adults with advanced (grade III-IV) hemorrhoidal disease needing surgery
- What they received
- new surgical technique combining skin-sparing hemorrhoidectomy with tissue fixation (SHAPE)
- Compared with
- none - single group, before-and-after comparison
- Main outcome
- change in hemorrhoid symptom severity scores one month after surgery
- Quality
- this is a small study of only 21 patients with no comparison group and just one month of follow-up, so it can't show how well the surgery works long-term or compared to other treatments.
- Limitations
- no control group, very short follow-up, small sample size, and the study measures overall symptom scores rather than directly explaining or testing why bleeding occurs or stops.
Taken word for word from the abstract
- n
A prospective analysis was conducted on 21 consecutive patients with grade III-IV HD
- population
21 consecutive patients with grade III-IV HD who underwent SHAPE
- intervention
Skin-Sparing Hemorrhoidectomy and Pexy (SHAPE), a novel hybrid technique that integrates the excisional approach of closed hemorrhoidectomy with the tissue-sparing and fixation benefits of suture ligation with mucopexy
- comparator
A prospective analysis was conducted on 21 consecutive patients with grade III-IV HD who underwent SHAPE on 3 hemorrhoidal columns
- primaryOutcome
At 1-month follow-up, patients experienced a significant reduction in symptoms, with the Hemorrhoidal Disease Severity Score (HDSS) decreasing from a median of 16 to 0
- result
the Hemorrhoidal Disease Severity Score (HDSS) decreasing from a median of 16 to 0 (p < 0.001) and the Short Health Scale (SHS) from 20 to 4 (p < 0.001)
- followUp
At 1-month follow-up
Updates Surg · PMID 40399727 · Read it on PubMed ↗
Liu et al. 2025
The comparison of doppler-guided haemorrhoidal artery ligation and the tissue selecting technique for patients with grade III/IV haemorrhoids: a retrospective cohort study
Less pain, but more recurrence.RetrospectiveLow quality
251 people3 years
DG-HAL caused less pain, fewer complications and less bleeding after surgery, but had a higher rate of prolapse coming back after 3 years compared to TST
- Who was studied
- patients with grade III/IV hemorrhoids
- What they received
- Doppler-guided hemorrhoid artery ligation (DG-HAL)
- Compared with
- tissue-selecting technique (TST) surgery
- Main outcome
- post-operative pain, bleeding, complications, and recurrence rate
- Quality
- This was a retrospective comparison without randomization, so differences between groups could be due to factors other than the treatment itself.
- Limitations
- Retrospective cohort study design, not randomized.
Taken word for word from the abstract
- n
We conducted a retrospective analysis of 251 patients with grade III/IV hemorrhoids between January 2019 and January 2021.
- population
This study aimed to evaluate the efficacy and the safety of Doppler-guided hemorrhoid artery ligation (DG-HAL) and tissue-selecting technique (TST) in patients with grade III/IV hemorrhoids.
- intervention
Doppler-guided hemorrhoid artery ligation (DG-HAL)
- comparator
tissue-selecting technique (TST)
- primaryOutcome
post-operative visual analog scale (VAS) for pain, post-operative bleeding, post-operative defecation, urinary retention, and recurrence rate (prolapse and bleeding)
- result
DG-HAL had fewer complications, lower bleeding rates, and less early post-operative pain but showed a higher recurrence rate than TST at the 3-year follow-up, especially in grade IV patients.
Updates Surg · PMID 40210842 · Read it on PubMed ↗
Palmieri et al. 2025
Tips and tricks of anorectal care with topical lidocaine (octose-dan) administration: retrospective, anecdotical, spontaneous, and observational study
Topical lidocaine eased anorectal symptoms.Case seriesVery low qualityRelated question
30 peopletwo months
28 of 30 patients had significant symptom improvement
- Who was studied
- patients with grade 1, 2 or 3 hemorrhoids, anal fissures, or anal fistulas
- What they received
- 5% lidocaine ointment (Octosedan) applied around the anus before and after bowel movements for two months
- Compared with
- no control group; some had previously tried flavonoid or heparinoid treatments
- Main outcome
- relief of pain, itching, soiling and discomfort around bowel movements
- Quality
- This was a small, uncontrolled, self-described anecdotal study without a comparison group, so it cannot reliably show the treatment caused the improvement.
- Limitations
- Described by the authors themselves as anecdotical, spontaneous and observational, with no control group and mixed anorectal conditions (hemorrhoids, fissures, fistulas) lumped together.
Taken word for word from the abstract
- population
30 patients both sexes (15 males and 15 females), recruited from the Second Opinion Medical Consulting Network for a spontaneous anecdotical post marketing evaluation of grade 1,2,3 haemorrhoids (n=23), anal fistulas (n=2) and fissures (n=5)
- intervention
5% lidocaine ointment (Octosedan Laboratori Baldacci S.p.A., Italy) for two months
- comparator
Of the 19 patients previously treated with flavonoids or heparinoid therapy with unsatisfactory results, 9 (30%) participants found benefit from the new treatment.
- primaryOutcome
the primary endpoints of the investigation were tolerability and effectiveness to relieve pain, itching, soiling and discomfort at rest or during and after stool emission
- result
28/30 treated patients had significantly symptom impro-vement (p<0.0001)
- n
30 patients both sexes (15 males and 15 females)
Clin Ter · PMID 40176588 · Read it on PubMed ↗
Groshilin et al. 2025
[Treatment of acute hemorrhoids according to the results of a multicenter observational study]
Less bleeding, pain with diosminProspective cohortVery low quality
220 people30 days
By day 7, pain, discomfort, itching and blood streaks during defecation were reduced compared with baseline, and 73% of patients had smaller hemorrhoidal nodes; by day 30 most complaints had resolved and quality of life scores improved, with no reported side effects.
- Who was studied
- adults aged 18 to 64 with grade I-II acute hemorrhoids (including bleeding) seen in outpatient clinics
- What they received
- oral diosmin (Phlebodia 600) taken daily for at least 36 days
- Compared with
- no comparison group; outcomes compared to patients' own baseline before treatment
- Main outcome
- resolution of hemorrhoid symptoms (pain, bleeding, itching, swelling) and quality of life
- Quality
- This was a single-arm observational study with no control group, so improvements over time cannot be separated from natural healing or other factors.
- Limitations
- No control or placebo group was used, so it cannot show whether diosmin itself caused the improvement rather than natural resolution of acute hemorrhoids.
Taken word for word from the abstract
- n
The total sample size analyzed was 220 patients
- population
Outpatients (both men and women) aged 18 to 64 with a confirmed diagnosis of grade I-II acute hemorrhoids
- intervention
Therapy with Phlebodia 600 (diosmin) commenced no later than three days after the onset of clinical symptoms
- intervention
the medication was administered for at least 36 days
- comparator
compared to baseline
- primaryOutcome
resolution of complaints and stabilization of all key clinical parameters
- result
early resolution and reduction of complaints such as pain, discomfort, itching, and blood streaks during defecation were observed by the control visit after seven days of therapy, compared to baseline.
- result
In 73% of cases, a reduction in the size of hemorrhoidal nodes was noted within this period.
- result
after 30 days, not only was there consistent resolution of complaints in the majority of patients, but there was also a significant improvement in quality of life (SF-36)
Khirurgiia (Mosk) · PMID 40103253 · Read it on PubMed ↗
Gravante 2025
Sclerotherapy for hemorrhoidal disease: Recent evolutions of an oldies goldy
New foam technique looks promising.Narrative reviewVery low qualityRelated question
size not given2025
the editorial states results are promising but does not give specific outcome data
- Who was studied
- people with internal hemorrhoids, grade II-III
- What they received
- sclerotherapy with polidocanol foam, including combined with rubber-band ligation (sclerobanding), delivered endoscopically
- Compared with
- endoscopic rubber band ligation
- Main outcome
- treatment effectiveness/outcomes for hemorrhoids
- Quality
- This is an editorial commentary discussing other studies, not original research with its own data.
- Limitations
- This is an editorial/commentary piece without original patient data, sample size, or detailed outcome statistics reported.
Taken word for word from the abstract
- population
patients with grade II-III internal hemorrhoids
- intervention
endoscopic delivery for patients with grade II-III internal hemorrhoids
- intervention
the combination of polidocanol foam with rubber-band ligation (the historical counterpart of sclerotherapy) in a technique called "sclerobanding"
- comparator
present results compared with endoscopic rubber band ligation
- result
The results achieved are promising.
- primaryOutcome
present results compared with endoscopic rubber band ligation
World J Gastroenterol · PMID 40062327 · Read it on PubMed ↗
Dutta 2025
Multilayered numerical modelling of bio-thermal aspects during laser assisted treatment of internal haemorrhoid developed in rectum
Computer model of laser heat in tissue.Laboratory studyVery low qualityRelated question
size not given2025
Temperature drops were seen at the interfaces between tissue layers, and the model matched a previously published numerical model with negligible variation
- Who was studied
- Computer model of rectal tissue layers (muscle, submucosa, mucosa) representing an internal hemorrhoid, not real patients
- What they received
- Simulated laser-assisted therapy using a Gaussian laser beam as heat source
- Compared with
- A previously published numerical model used for verification
- Main outcome
- Temperature changes across the layers of rectal tissue during simulated laser treatment
- Quality
- This is a theoretical mathematical/computer model of tissue heating, not a study in real patients, so it cannot show whether bleeding is actually stopped.
- Limitations
- Purely computational modeling of heat transfer, no human or animal data, no bleeding outcome measured, no patient numbers.
Taken word for word from the abstract
- population
the physical domain is considered as multilayered tissue (three different layers of rectum: muscle, submucosa and mucosa)
- intervention
A Gaussian laser beam is considered as heat source to destroy the abnormal growth inside the rectum.
- comparator
The research outcome is verified with the published numerical model with negligible variation.
- primaryOutcome
Temperature variation in multi-layered tissue is investigated for laser heat input and absorption radius along the temporal and spatial coordinate.
- result
Temperature drop has been evidenced in the interfaces of multi-layered rectum tissue.
- result
The research outcome is verified with the published numerical model with negligible variation.
Lasers Med Sci · PMID 39969619 · Read it on PubMed ↗
Xu et al. 2025
Clinical effects of endoscopic resection of hypertrophied anal papillae combined with internal hemorrhoid ligation therapy: a retrospective study
More pain, same bleeding rate.RetrospectiveLow qualityRelated question
47 people3 months
combined treatment caused more pain but similar rates of bleeding and swelling as resection alone
- Who was studied
- patients with enlarged (hypertrophic) anal papillae
- What they received
- endoscopic removal of enlarged anal papillae plus internal hemorrhoid ligation
- Compared with
- endoscopic removal of enlarged anal papillae alone
- Main outcome
- postoperative pain, bleeding, swelling, and treatment success at 3 months
- Quality
- This was a small, retrospective study without randomization, so it can't reliably separate true treatment effects from chance or bias.
- Limitations
- Retrospective design, small sample size (47 patients), no randomization, and the abstract does not address why hemorrhoids bleed or the general mechanism of bleeding control.
Taken word for word from the abstract
- population
47 patients from our center who underwent endoscopic resection of hypertrophic anal papillae, with or without internal hemorrhoids ligation
- intervention
the anal papillae resection + internal hemorrhoid ligation group
- comparator
the anal papillae resection group
- primaryOutcome
postoperative pain intensity and duration, postoperative bleeding severity, presence of anal edema, and follow-up outcomes at 3 months postoperatively
- result
The postoperative pain intensity was higher in the group undergoing anal papillae resection combined with internal hemorrhoid ligation, with a median Visual Analog Scale (VAS) score of 1 (0, 2), and the duration of pain was longer, with a median of 1 (0, 2) day.
- result
However, there were no statistically significant differences in the incidence of postoperative bleeding or anal edema.
- n
A retrospective study was conducted on 47 patients
Surg Endosc · PMID 39934277 · Read it on PubMed ↗
Sapkota Upadhya et al. 2024
Efficacy and Safety of Colonoscopic Band Ligation for Lower Gastrointestinal Bleeding due to Hemorrhoid
Bleeding stopped in most patientsCase seriesLow quality
28 people3 months
bleeding resolved in 96.4% and prolapse in 92% of patients at 3 months, with high patient satisfaction
- Who was studied
- patients with lower gastrointestinal bleeding caused by hemorrhoids
- What they received
- colonoscopic rubber band ligation of hemorrhoids
- Compared with
- none (single-arm study, no comparison group)
- Main outcome
- resolution of bleeding and other hemorrhoid symptoms after treatment
- Quality
- This was a small, one-year, single-center study with no comparison group and over half the patients had complications, so it can't prove the treatment works better than alternatives.
- Limitations
- No control group, small sample size (28 of 108 patients), single center, post-procedure complications in 53.5% of cases, and authors call for multicenter research with longer follow-up.
Taken word for word from the abstract
- n
We included 28 among 108 patients presenting to the surgical outpatient department with Lower gastrointestinal bleeding.
- population
Lower gastrointestinal bleeding due to hemorrhoids
- intervention
Colonoscopic Rubber band ligation
- comparator
This study, conducted in a tertiary care center of Nepal over one year, explores the immediate, late complications, efficacy and treatment satisfaction of patients undergoing Colonoscopic Rubber band ligation for lower GI bleeding due to hemorrhoids.
- primaryOutcome
Symptoms of irritation, discharge, pain resolved in all patients at 3 months and that of bleeding and prolapse in 96.4% and 92% respectively.
- result
Symptoms of irritation, discharge, pain resolved in all patients at 3 months and that of bleeding and prolapse in 96.4% and 92% respectively.
J Nepal Health Res Counc · PMID 39923169 · Read it on PubMed ↗
Baş et al. 2025
Emborrhoid technique in hemorrhoidal disease: Retrospective analysis of data from a single center
Less bleeding after artery embolization.RetrospectiveLow quality
18 people6 months
bleeding severity score dropped from 6.6 before treatment to about 3.4-3.8 at 1, 3, and 6 months, with recurrence in 2 patients
- Who was studied
- patients with severe (grade 4) bleeding hemorrhoids who could not have surgery
- What they received
- coil embolization (blocking) of the superior rectal artery
- Compared with
- none; before-and-after comparison within same patients
- Main outcome
- severity of rectal bleeding, measured before and after treatment
- Quality
- this was a small, retrospective study of only 18 patients with no comparison group, so it cannot prove the procedure itself caused the improvement.
- Limitations
- small sample size, retrospective design, no control group, single center
Taken word for word from the abstract
- n
18 patients (11 males, 7 females)
- population
rectal bleeding caused by Goligher grade 4 hemorrhoids, where surgery is contraindicated
- intervention
coil embolization of the superior rectal artery
- comparator
The mean Paris bleeding severity score was 6.6±1.1 before treatment, 3.4±1.5 at the first month
- primaryOutcome
rectal bleeding grading was assessed using the Paris bleeding severity score
- result
The mean Paris bleeding severity score was 6.6±1.1 before treatment, 3.4±1.5 at the first month, 3.8±1.61 at the third month, and 3.6±1.29 at the sixth month. Recurrence occurred in one patient at the first month and in another at the third month.
Ulus Travma Acil Cerrahi Derg · PMID 39775512 · Read it on PubMed ↗
Mustapha et al. 2025
LigaSure versus conventional Milligan MORGAN hemorrhoidectomy in Nigerian patients with symptomatic hemorrhoids
Less bleeding and pain with LigaSure surgeryRandomised trialLow qualityRelated question
52 people3 months
LigaSure caused less blood loss (10.0 mL vs 26.5 mL), lower pain scores at 2 weeks (5.5 vs 6.0), and shorter surgery time (18.04 vs 34.19 min) than Milligan-Morgan
- Who was studied
- adults with grade III and IV symptomatic hemorrhoids in Nigeria
- What they received
- LigaSure hemorrhoidectomy (vessel-sealing device surgery)
- Compared with
- conventional Milligan-Morgan hemorrhoidectomy
- Main outcome
- blood loss, pain, surgery duration, and symptom resolution after hemorrhoid removal surgery
- Quality
- Small randomized trial with only 52 patients and short follow-up, so results may not be reliable or generalizable.
- Limitations
- Small sample size; abstract does not describe blinding; outcomes assessed only up to 3 months
Taken word for word from the abstract
- n
Fifty-two patients were randomized equally into the two arms.
- population
patients with grade III and grade IV hemorrhoids
- intervention
LigaSure hemorrhoidectomy
- comparator
conventional Milligan-Morgan hemorrhoidectomy
- primaryOutcome
the duration of the procedure, estimated blood loss, and resolution of symptoms
- result
The median blood loss in the LigaSure group was 10.0 mL, whereas the median blood loss in the Milligan-Morgan group was 26.5 mL, (p = 0.0001). The median postoperative pain at 2 weeks using the VAS was 5.5 in the LigaSure group, and in the Milligan-Morgan group, it was 6.0 (p = 0.002). The mean duration of surgery in the LigaSure group was 18.04 min and 34.19 min in the Milligan-Morgan group (p = 0.0001).
World J Surg · PMID 39578689 · Read it on PubMed ↗
Balkrishna et al. 2024
Co-administration of Ayurvedic medicines Arshogrit and Jatyadi Ghrit, attenuate croton oil-induced hemorrhoids in rat model of recto-anal inflammation by modulating TNF-α and IL-1β levels
Reduced bleeding and swelling in rats.Animal studyVery low qualityRelated question
size not given2024
the combination reduced swelling, hemorrhage, tissue damage and inflammatory markers compared to untreated animals
- Who was studied
- rats with chemically induced hemorrhoid-like inflammation in the rectal/anal area
- What they received
- oral Ayurvedic medicine Arshogrit plus topical Jatyadi Ghrit
- Compared with
- standard steroid drug (prednisolone) and untreated croton oil exposure
- Main outcome
- reduction in swelling, bleeding, tissue damage and inflammation markers in the recto-anal area
- Quality
- this is an early-stage animal experiment, not a human study, so it cannot show whether this works in people with hemorrhoids
- Limitations
- study was done in rats with chemically induced disease, not in humans with naturally occurring hemorrhoids; number of animals not stated
Taken word for word from the abstract
- population
Wistar rats by inducing hemorrhoids development with the application of croton oil preparation (COP) in the recto-anal area
- intervention
AG, which was administered orally at the doses of 20, 60 and 200 mg/kg/day and JG, which was topically applied (100 mg/animal/day)
- comparator
Prednisolone was employed as the standard drug and was administered orally at the dose of 1 mg/kg/day
- primaryOutcome
Gross pathological observation demonstrated remarkable decrease in croton oil-induced swelling, hemorrhage and formation of pseudomembrane
- result
AG and JG were able to attenuate the croton oil-induced macro and microscopic anomalies.
Drug Dev Ind Pharm · PMID 39565131 · Read it on PubMed ↗
Mou et al. 2024
Endoscopic polidocanol foam sclerobanding for treatment of internal hemorrhoids: A novel outpatient procedure
New method needs more study.Narrative reviewVery low qualityRelated question
size not givenone-year
EFSB is a novel therapy for internal hemorrhoids, but future studies with a larger sample, multiple treatment sessions, and long-term follow-up are required to confirm these findings
- Who was studied
- patients with grades II and III internal hemorrhoids
- What they received
- endoscopic polidocanol foam sclerobanding (EFSB)
- Compared with
- endoscopic rubber band ligation (ERBL)
- Main outcome
- prolapse recurrence and post-procedural pain/bleeding
- Quality
- this is a commentary discussing another study rather than reporting its own original data or specific results.
- Limitations
- future studies with a larger sample, multiple treatment sessions, and long-term follow-up are required to confirm these findings
Taken word for word from the abstract
- population
patients with grades II and III internal hemorrhoids
- intervention
Endoscopic polidocanol foam sclerobanding (EFSB) is a novel approach
- comparator
Endoscopic rubber band ligation (ERBL) is a safe, convenient, quick, and economical outpatient procedure
- primaryOutcome
long-term relief from prolapse recurrence and reduced 24-h post-procedural pain
- result
Results showed that EFSB is a novel therapy for internal hemorrhoids, but future studies with a larger sample, multiple treatment sessions, and long-term follow-up are required to confirm these findings.
- followUp
one-year follow-up
World J Gastroenterol · PMID 39563748 · Read it on PubMed ↗
Lei et al. 2024
Does hemorrhoidal artery embolization really benefit patients with hemorrhoids?
Commentary only, no results given.Narrative reviewVery low qualityRelated question
size not given2024
The letter discusses patient selection, materials, and methods needed to improve safety and effectiveness, without reporting specific outcome data.
- Who was studied
- people with severe hemorrhoidal bleeding needing treatment
- What they received
- hemorrhoidal artery embolization
- Main outcome
- safety and effectiveness of the embolization procedure
- Quality
- This is an opinion letter/commentary with no original patient data or results reported.
- Limitations
- No original data; commentary only, discusses factors like patient selection and technique that may affect outcomes without providing results.
Taken word for word from the abstract
- intervention
Hemorrhoidal artery embolization is a promising approach to severe hemorrhoidal bleeding treatment
- population
severe hemorrhoidal bleeding treatment
- primaryOutcome
improve the safety and effectiveness of the procedure
- result
inappropriate patient selection and the use of different embolization procedures may affect the clinical efficacy and cause serious complications
World J Gastroenterol · PMID 39563747 · Read it on PubMed ↗
Voinov 2024
[The effectiveness of flavonoids in the postoperative treatment of patients with hemorrhoids]
Less post-surgery bleeding with flavonoids.Randomised trialLow qualityRelated question
135 people60 days
Lower pain, bleeding and tenesmus at days 7, 21, 40 and 60 compared to the control group, but no difference in itching
- Who was studied
- adults with stage III or IV hemorrhoids who had surgery to remove them (hemorrhoidectomy)
- What they received
- purified micronized flavonoid fraction taken after surgery
- Compared with
- no flavonoid treatment after surgery
- Main outcome
- patient-reported severity of pain, bleeding, itching and tenesmus after surgery
- Quality
- It was a single-center randomized trial using simple envelope randomization without mention of blinding, and symptoms were self-assessed by patients, which limits confidence in the result.
- Limitations
- Single-center study, randomization method may allow prediction of group assignment, no blinding described, and outcomes were patient-reported.
Taken word for word from the abstract
- population
Patients with stage III and IV hemorrhoids aged over 18 years who patients who underwent hemorrhoidectomy were included.
- intervention
Patients in the main group were recommended to use a purified micronized flavonoid fraction
- comparator
In the control group (70 patients), the use of this group of drugs was not expected.
- primaryOutcome
Patients independently assessed the intensity of symptoms - pain, tenesmus, itching and bleeding.
- result
After 7, 21, 40 and 60 days, a statistically significant lower severity of pain, bleeding and tenesmus was revealed among patients in the main group compared to the control group.
- n
135 patients were randomized.
Khirurgiia (Mosk) · PMID 39268736 · Read it on PubMed ↗
Zhou et al. 2024
[Clinical analysis of percutaneous superselective superior rectal artery embolization for grades Ⅱ-Ⅲ internal hemorrhoids]
Less bleeding after artery embolization.RetrospectiveLow quality
22 people12 months
bleeding, quality of life, and prolapse scores all significantly improved after embolization
- Who was studied
- adults with grade II-III internal hemorrhoids
- What they received
- percutaneous superselective superior rectal artery embolization
- Compared with
- before vs after treatment in same patients (no control group)
- Main outcome
- bleeding score, quality of life score, and prolapse score
- Quality
- Small retrospective study of only 22 patients with no comparison group, so improvement cannot be clearly attributed to the treatment alone.
- Limitations
- Retrospective design, small sample size, no control group, and common side effects like tenesmus and anal bulge in most patients.
Taken word for word from the abstract
- n
22 patients with grades Ⅱ-Ⅲ internal hemorrhoids who underwent superselective superior rectal artery embolization
- population
22 patients with grades Ⅱ-Ⅲ internal hemorrhoids who underwent superselective superior rectal artery embolization
- intervention
percutaneous superselective superior rectal artery embolization in the treatment of grades Ⅱ-Ⅲ internal hemorrhoids
- comparator
The clinical scores before and after treatment were compared by the nonparametric rank sum test
- primaryOutcome
French bleeding score,quality of life score,prolapse score
- result
Compared with those prior to operation, the French bleeding score,quality of life score,and prolapse score were significantly improved (all P<0.05).
Zhonghua Nei Ke Za Zhi · PMID 39183158 · Read it on PubMed ↗
Godeberge et al. 2024
An international observational study assessing conservative management in hemorrhoidal disease: results of CHORALIS (aCute HemORrhoidal disease evALuation International Study)
Flavonoid drugs eased bleeding and pain fasterProspective cohortLow quality
3,505 people4 weeks
Venoactive drugs improved symptoms and quality of life overall, with MPFF showing significantly better symptom relief and faster improvement than diosmin
- Who was studied
- adults with acute hemorrhoid symptoms, mostly mild to moderate grade
- What they received
- venoactive drugs, mainly micronized purified flavonoid fraction (MPFF)
- Compared with
- diosmin (another venoactive drug)
- Main outcome
- improvement in hemorrhoid symptoms (pain, bleeding, swelling, itching, soiling) and quality of life
- Quality
- This was an observational study without a placebo or randomization, so it cannot prove the drugs caused the improvement.
- Limitations
- Observational design with no control group or randomization; relied on patient-reported questionnaires.
Taken word for word from the abstract
- n
Of 3592 participants, 3505 were analyzed
- population
adult outpatients consulting for spontaneous complaints of hemorrhoids (graded using Goligher classification)
- intervention
particularly micronized purified flavonoid fraction (MPFF; 73.7%)
- comparator
and diosmin (14.6%)
- primaryOutcome
improved signs/symptoms (number/intensity/frequency of pain, discomfort, bleeding, swelling, itching and soiling) and QoL
- result
MPFF was associated with a significantly greater proportion of patients with no symptoms (48.8 vs diosmin 34.4%, p < 0.001), pain disappearance (69.7 vs diosmin 52.8%, p < 0.001)
- followUp
The 4-week observational prospective CHORALIS study
J Comp Eff Res · PMID 39132755 · Read it on PubMed ↗
Daðadóttir et al. 2024
Comparison of gastrointestinal bleeding in patients with and without liver cirrhosis
Hemorrhoids more common bleeding cause in cirrhosis.RetrospectiveLow qualityRelated question
493 people45 days
hemorrhoids 40% vs. 6% (p = 0.002)
- Who was studied
- patients with liver cirrhosis
- What they received
- A retrospective study on cirrhotics hospitalized for GIB 2010-2021, matched with control group of non-cirrhotics (1:4) for upper vs. lower GIB.
- Compared with
- matched with control group of non-cirrhotics (1:4) for upper vs. lower GIB
- Main outcome
- The clinical characteristics, management and outcomes in patients with and without liver cirrhosis was compared to determine the overall features of GIB in patients with liver cirrhosis compared with non-cirrhotics.
- Quality
- This is a retrospective, matched comparison study without any treatment tested, so it can't show what stops hemorrhoid bleeding.
- Limitations
- Retrospective design, matched cohort, no information on hemorrhoid treatment or bleeding mechanism, and no randomization.
Taken word for word from the abstract
- n
Overall 102 cirrhotics had GIB, matched with 391 non-cirrhotics
- population
cirrhotics hospitalized for GIB 2010-2021, matched with control group of non-cirrhotics (1:4) for upper vs. lower GIB
- intervention
A retrospective study on cirrhotics hospitalized for GIB 2010-2021, matched with control group of non-cirrhotics (1:4) for upper vs. lower GIB.
- comparator
matched with control group of non-cirrhotics (1:4) for upper vs. lower GIB
- primaryOutcome
The clinical characteristics, management and outcomes in patients with and without liver cirrhosis was compared to determine the overall features of GIB in patients with liver cirrhosis compared with non-cirrhotics.
- result
hemorrhoids 40% vs. 6% (p = 0.002)
Scand J Gastroenterol · PMID 39105571 · Read it on PubMed ↗
Chen et al. 2024
Clinical outcomes of laser hemorrhoidoplasty with feeding vessels suture ligation: a retrospective study in a single center
Less pain than traditional surgery.RetrospectiveLow qualityRelated question
323 people2024
the laser surgery group had significantly less pain after surgery and fewer cases of urinary retention than the traditional surgery group
- Who was studied
- patients with symptomatic grade II-III hemorrhoids
- What they received
- laser hemorrhoidoplasty with suture ligation of the feeding blood vessels
- Compared with
- traditional Milligan-Morgan hemorrhoidectomy surgery
- Main outcome
- postoperative pain and complications after surgery
- Quality
- This is a retrospective, non-randomized comparison of two surgeries, so differences in pain could be influenced by factors other than the treatment itself.
- Limitations
- Retrospective study design without randomization; focuses on postoperative pain rather than directly measuring bleeding or recurrence outcomes.
Taken word for word from the abstract
- population
patients with symptomatic grade II-III hemorrhoids who underwent laser hemorrhoidoplasty with feeding vessel suture ligation and Milligan-Morgan hemorrhoidectomy
- intervention
laser hemorrhoidoplasty with feeding vessel suture ligation
- comparator
Milligan-Morgan hemorrhoidectomy
- primaryOutcome
postoperative pain, discomfort after discharge, hemorrhoid recurrence, and any complications
- result
the LHP group exhibited superior performance compared to traditional surgery at postoperative 4 h, before discharge, and during the first and second outpatient visits, with statistically significant differences
- result
the LHP group had a lower rate of urinary retention and experienced significantly less pain, with statistically significant differences
- n
The study included 323 patients, with 173 undergoing laser hemorrhoidoplasty (LHP) and 150 undergoing Milligan-Morgan hemorrhoidectomy.
Tech Coloproctol · PMID 38955875 · Read it on PubMed ↗
Sazal et al. 2024
Gold Standard yet Inconspicuous- Our Experience of Conventional Haemorrhoid Surgeries in a Peripheral Free of Cost Hospital of Bangladesh
Surgery gave low complication rates.Case seriesLow qualityRelated question
64 people12 months
most patients had complication-free recovery, with only rare cases of delayed healing, pain, urinary retention, infection, or bleeding
- Who was studied
- adults with hemorrhoidal disease, mostly grade 3-4, treated at a free hospital in Bangladesh
- What they received
- conventional haemorrhoid surgery
- Compared with
- none (single group, no comparison treatment)
- Main outcome
- complications and recurrence after surgery over 12 months
- Quality
- this is a small, single-group study with no comparison treatment, so it cannot show what caused bleeding or compare it to other options
- Limitations
- no control group, small sample size, single hospital setting, late patient presentation
Taken word for word from the abstract
- n
Total 64 adult patients with mean age 38.6 years
- population
Total 64 adult patients with mean age 38.6 years and male female ratio 1.7:1 were included in this study
- intervention
evaluate the outcome of conventional surgeries
- comparator
This descriptive, prospective, observational study was performed from diagnosis of haemorrhoidal disease to surgical intervention
- primaryOutcome
Clinico-pathological data and outcome in the form of complications and recurrence within follow-up period was studied
- result
Complication less recovery was seen in 56(87.5%) cases, where delayed wound healing and pain was reported in 2(3.6%) patient each, followed by 1(1.6%) each reported urinary retention, anal sepsis, primary bleeding and reactionary bleeding
Mymensingh Med J · PMID 38944729 · Read it on PubMed ↗
Kwiatkowska et al. 2024
The influence of supportive therapy with a six-component myophlebotropic preparation on the reduction of symptoms in patients with symptoms of hemorrhoidal disease
Less pain, itching, and bleeding with defecation.Randomised trialLow quality
61 people30 days
the supplement group had significantly less pain, burning, itching, bleeding during defecation, and more overall symptom relief after 30 days than the placebo group
- Who was studied
- patients with stage II and III hemorrhoidal disease with symptoms like pain, burning, itching and bleeding
- What they received
- six-component myophlebotropic dietary supplement added to standard local treatment
- Compared with
- standard local treatment plus placebo
- Main outcome
- severity of hemorrhoid symptoms (pain, burning, itching, bleeding) and overall symptom relief
- Quality
- small number of patients split into two small groups and relies partly on subjective symptom scales, which limits confidence in the findings.
- Limitations
- Small sample size (29 vs 32 patients); outcomes partly based on subjective VAS and yes/no symptom reporting; no mention of blinding details beyond placebo control.
Taken word for word from the abstract
- n
The control group (Group I) of 29 patients receiving standard local treatment plus placebo and the study group (Group II) of 32 patients receiving the same local treatment and a six-component myophlebotropic product.
- population
Patients with stage II and III hemorrhoidal disease with clinical symptoms such as pain, burning, itching and bleeding were qualified for the study.
- intervention
the study group (Group II) of 32 patients receiving the same local treatment and a six-component myophlebotropic product
- comparator
The control group (Group I) of 29 patients receiving standard local treatment plus placebo
- primaryOutcome
To assess the effect of a multi-ingredient myophlebotropic dietary supplement used as an adjunct on the rate and effectiveness of symptom relief in patients with stage II and III hemorrhoidal disease.
- result
The treatment did not affect the rate of spontaneous bleeding, which was low at the beginning of the study, but significantly reduced the rate of bleeding during defecation.
- result
After 30 days of observation, it was found that the improvement in the severity of hemorrhoidal disease symptoms was significantly higher in the group using the tested preparation.
- followUp
after 30 days of therapy
Pol Przegl Chir · PMID 38940246 · Read it on PubMed ↗
Xue et al. 2024
Effect of Pressure and Nonpressure Dressings on Postoperative Complications in Patients With Mixed Hemorrhoids: A Single-blind Controlled Study
Less pain and retention, not bleeding.Randomised trialModerate qualityRelated question
186 people2024
nonpressure dressings caused less urinary retention, less pain, less skin injury and swelling, but no difference in bleeding, length of stay or cost, and no bleeding occurred in either group
- Who was studied
- adults with grade II to III mixed hemorrhoids having hemorrhoid surgery (modified Milligan-Morgan hemorrhoidectomy)
- What they received
- nonpressure wound dressing after surgery
- Compared with
- pressure wound dressing after surgery
- Main outcome
- postoperative complications including urinary retention, pain, skin injury, swelling, and bleeding control
- Quality
- It was a randomized trial with a reasonable number of patients, but it was only single-blind and focused on post-surgical dressing type rather than on bleeding itself.
- Limitations
- Single-blind design, population limited to surgical hemorrhoidectomy patients excluding those with cardiovascular/cerebrovascular disease, and bleeding was not the main focus of comparison.
Taken word for word from the abstract
- population
A total of 186 patients with grade II to III mixed hemorrhoids who had been excluded from cardiovascular and cerebrovascular diseases and anorectal surgery were included
- intervention
nonpressure dressings group
- comparator
pressure dressings group
- primaryOutcome
The incidence of acute urinary retention and medical adhesive-related skin injury, pain, hemostatic effect, anal distension, anal edema, use of analgesics, length of hospital stay, and hospitalization costs were compared between the two groups.
- result
The incidence of acute urinary retention in both men and women was significantly lower in the nonpressure dressing group
- result
No primary bleeding was observed in both groups.
- result
there were no significant differences between both groups in terms of anal edema scores, length of stay, or hospitalization expenses
- n
A total of 186 patients with grade II to III mixed hemorrhoids
J Perianesth Nurs · PMID 38864797 · Read it on PubMed ↗
Pitesa et al. 2024
Flavonoids and post haemorrhoidectomy recovery: a systematic review and meta-analysis
Less pain and bleeding after hemorrhoid surgery.Meta-analysisModerate qualityRelated question
775 people2024
flavonoids significantly reduced post-operative pain and reduced bleeding compared to the non-flavonoid groups
- Who was studied
- patients having surgery to remove hemorrhoids (haemorrhoidectomy) for severe symptomatic hemorrhoids
- What they received
- flavonoid medication given around the time of hemorrhoidectomy surgery
- Compared with
- non-flavonoid treatment (implied control group in the pooled trials)
- Main outcome
- pain after hemorrhoidectomy surgery
- Quality
- it pools multiple randomized trials, which is strong evidence, but the abstract does not describe how consistent the studies were or address bias, and the findings are about surgical recovery rather than bleeding from untreated hemorrhoids.
- Limitations
- abstract does not report heterogeneity, bias assessment, or details of flavonoid regimens used; only mentions this is about post-surgical recovery, not natural hemorrhoid bleeding
Taken word for word from the abstract
- population
following excisional haemorrhoidectomy
- intervention
the potential of flavonoids in alleviating the postoperative symptom burden following excisional haemorrhoidectomy
- comparator
in favour of the flavonoid groups
- primaryOutcome
The primary outcome investigated was post-operative pain.
- result
statistically significant decreases in post-operative pain in favour of the flavonoid groups (Standardized Mean Difference -0.66 [95% confidence intervals (CI) -0.82, -0.52]; P < 0.00001), and bleeding (Odds Ratio 0.13 [95% CI 0.09, 0.19]; P < 0.00001)
- n
Ten articles with 775 patients were included.
ANZ J Surg · PMID 38847122 · Read it on PubMed ↗
Tutino et al. 2024
Transanal eco-Doppler evaluation after hemorrhoidal artery embolization
Reduced hemorrhoid blood flow, but symptom link weak.Prospective cohortLow quality
11 people1 month
blood flow to hemorrhoids significantly decreased after embolization, but this flow reduction only weakly matched improvement in bleeding scores
- Who was studied
- patients with bleeding hemorrhoids (score ≥4, Goligher grade II or III) who failed non-surgical treatment
- What they received
- hemorrhoidal artery embolization (Emborrhoid procedure)
- Compared with
- before vs after treatment (same patients, no control group)
- Main outcome
- change in arterial blood flow to hemorrhoids measured by ultrasound Doppler
- Quality
- very small pilot study of only 11 patients with no comparison group, so the findings are preliminary and could be due to chance.
- Limitations
- Pilot study with small sample size; weak correlation between flow changes and symptom scores; no control group.
Taken word for word from the abstract
- n
Eleven patients underwent Emborrhoid.
- population
consecutive patients with hemorrhoidal bleeding scores (HBSs) ≥ 4, Goligher scores of II or III, failure of non-operative management, and a candidate for Emborrhoid were included
- intervention
Hemorrhoidal artery embolization (Emborrhoid) is a novel method for the treatment of severe hemorrhoidal bleeding.
- comparator
Endoanal ultrasound with eco-Doppler was performed preoperatively and 1 month after the procedure.
- primaryOutcome
The primary endpoint was to quantify the changes in arterial hemorrhoidal flow after treatment.
- result
After treatment, the overall MSP values were significantly reduced (P = 0.008) although the correlation between MSP and HBS changes was weak (P = 0.570).
World J Gastroenterol · PMID 38813050 · Read it on PubMed ↗
Jin et al. 2024
Laser hemorrhoidoplasty vs. rubber band ligation: a randomized trial comparing 2 mini-invasive treatment for grade II hemorrhoids
Less bleeding and pain with laser.Randomised trialLow quality
70 people1 year after surgery
LHP improved pain, bleeding, and anal distension more than RBL within 2 weeks, but recurrence rates were similar at 1 year
- Who was studied
- patients with grade II hemorrhoids
- What they received
- laser hemorrhoidoplasty (LHP)
- Compared with
- Rubber Band Ligation (RBL)
- Main outcome
- postoperative pain, bleeding, and feeling of anal distension after surgery
- Quality
- Small single-center trial of only 70 patients with short-term outcome measures and no mention of blinding.
- Limitations
- Small sample size (n=70), single-center design, and no mention of blinding or long-term bleeding outcomes beyond 1 year recurrence.
Taken word for word from the abstract
- n
A total of 70 patients with grade II hemorrhoids were randomly assigned to receive LHP or Rubber Band Ligation (RBL) (n = 35 per group)
- population
70 patients with grade II hemorrhoids
- intervention
laser hemorrhoidoplasty (LHP)
- comparator
Rubber Band Ligation (RBL)
- primaryOutcome
The postoperative pain, bleeding, feeling of anal distension(local falling, swelling, foreign body sensation, stool) and postoperative recurrence rate were compared between the two groups.
- result
The postoperative pain, bleeding, and feeling of anal distension in the LHP group were improved significantly as compared with the RBL group within 2 weeks after surgery (P < 0.01).
- result
There was no difference in the recurrence rate between the two groups at 1 year after surgery (P > 0.05).
BMC Surg · PMID 38797851 · Read it on PubMed ↗
Marik et al. 2024
Effectiveness and tolerability of rectal ointment and suppositories containing sucralfate for hemorrhoidal symptoms: a prospective, observational study
Eased non-bleeding hemorrhoid symptoms, uncontrolled studyProspective cohortVery low qualityRelated question
60 people2024
symptom severity score improved significantly from baseline in both treatment groups
- Who was studied
- adults with mild-to-moderate symptomatic non-bleeding hemorrhoids
- What they received
- sucralfate rectal ointment or suppositories applied twice daily
- Compared with
- none; before-and-after comparison with no control group
- Main outcome
- patient-reported hemorrhoid symptom severity score (mSSS)
- Quality
- This was an uncontrolled observational study with no placebo or comparator group, so improvement could be due to natural healing rather than the treatment, and it also excluded bleeding hemorrhoids, the condition in question.
- Limitations
- No control group, not randomized or blinded, and study explicitly excluded bleeding hemorrhoids.
Taken word for word from the abstract
- n
Five investigators enrolled 60 patients
- population
Adult patients with diagnosed, mild-to-moderate, symptomatic non-bleeding hemorrhoids treated with rectal ointment or suppositories containing sucralfate were enrolled.
- intervention
Patients were administered treatment twice per day for at least 1 week until symptom resolution and/or for a maximum of 4 weeks.
- comparator
The primary endpoint was patient-assessed effectiveness on a modified Symptom Severity Score (mSSS, range 0 to 14).
- primaryOutcome
The primary endpoint was patient-assessed effectiveness on a modified Symptom Severity Score (mSSS, range 0 to 14).
- result
Mean patient-assessed mSSS at baseline was 6.6 ± 1.9 and was significantly improved overall and in the ointment and suppository groups individually by -4.6 ± 2.0, -4.4 ± 1.8, and -4.8 ± 2.2, respectively (p < 0.0001).
Int J Colorectal Dis · PMID 38750150 · Read it on PubMed ↗
Deng et al. 2024
Preoperative Blood Transfusion Requirements for Hemorrhoidal Severe Anemia: A Retrospective Study of 128 Patients
Lower transfusion threshold had fewer reactions.RetrospectiveLow qualityRelated question
128 people2024
the restrictive-transfusion group had fewer transfusion reactions and lower costs, but longer surgery time, compared to the liberal-transfusion group
- Who was studied
- patients with severe anemia caused by bleeding hemorrhoids, requiring blood transfusion before surgery
- What they received
- restrictive blood transfusion (transfusing to a lower hemoglobin target before surgery)
- Compared with
- liberal blood transfusion (transfusing to a higher hemoglobin target before surgery)
- Main outcome
- transfusion amount, transfusion reactions, hospital costs, and surgery time
- Quality
- this is a retrospective study without randomization, so differences between groups could be due to other factors, not just the transfusion strategy.
- Limitations
- retrospective design, no randomization, only looked at surgical hemorrhoid patients with severe anemia needing transfusion rather than hemorrhoid bleeding in general
Taken word for word from the abstract
- n
This retrospective cohort study included 128 patients with hemorrhoidal severe anemia
- population
patients with hemorrhoidal severe anemia admitted to 3 hospitals
- intervention
PHB <70 as the restrictive-threshold group (RG)
- comparator
PHB ≥70 g/L as the liberal-transfusion group (LG)
- primaryOutcome
The general condition, bleeding duration, hemoglobin level on admission, transfusion volume, length of stay, immune transfusion reaction, surgical duration, and hospitalization cost were compared between the 2 groups.
- result
The LG had a significantly higher transfusion volume (4.77±2.22 units), frequency of immune transfusion reactions (1.22±0.58), and hospitalization costs (16.69±3.31 thousand yuan) than the RG
Med Sci Monit · PMID 38704632 · Read it on PubMed ↗
Togo et al. 2024
Anal disorders in pregnant and postpartum women: epidemiological, diagnostic and therapeutic aspects in 10 maternities of Bamako in Mali
Describes risk factors, not what stops bleeding.Prospective cohortLow qualityRelated question
1,422 people6 weeks after delivery
38.4% (546) of women had anal pathologies, including hemorrhoidal disease in 13% (192), with identified risk factors such as age ≥30, chronic constipation, newborn weight >3500 g, and prolonged fetal expulsion time
- Who was studied
- pregnant women followed from first trimester through six weeks after delivery in Bamako, Mali
- What they received
- treatment based on counseling on hygiene and diet, laxatives, local topicals, analgesics, and perineal rehabilitation
- Compared with
- none reported
- Main outcome
- occurrence of anal pathologies (hemorrhoidal disease, anal fissure, anal incontinence) and their risk factors
- Quality
- this is a descriptive observational study without a comparison group, so it cannot show whether any treatment actually works or how bleeding is stopped.
- Limitations
- no control group or outcome data on whether treatments relieved symptoms such as bleeding; study focuses on epidemiology and risk factors rather than treatment efficacy
Taken word for word from the abstract
- n
we followed up 1,422 pregnant women
- population
pregnant women admitted to the hospitals and who were followed up through the postpartum
- intervention
The treatment was based on counseling on hygiene and diet, the use of laxatives, local topicals, and analgesics along perineal rehabilitation.
- comparator
We carried out a prospective, multi-centric, and analytical study
- primaryOutcome
we found 38.4% (546) with anal pathologies (hemorrhoidal diseases in 13% (192), anal fissure in 10.5% (150) and anal incontinence in 8.6% (123)
- result
Risk factors for the hemorrhoidal disease were age of patient ≥30 years old aRR=5.77, 95% CI 4.57-7.34; p=0.000; a existence of chronic constipation aRR=2.61, 95% CI 1.98-3.44; p=0.000; newborn weight >3500 g aRR= 1.61, 95% CI 1.25-2.07; p=0.000 and fetal expulsion time >20 minutes aRR= 6.04, 95% CI 5.07-7.27; p=0.000.
Pan Afr Med J · PMID 38681103 · Read it on PubMed ↗
Fathallah et al. 2024
Hemorrhoidal disease: Epidemiological study and analysis of predictive factors for surgical management
Surgery reduced bleeding more than other treatments.Prospective cohortLow qualityRelated question
472 people2024
bleeding and prolapse scores decreased significantly after treatment, with greater improvement and higher satisfaction in the surgery group
- Who was studied
- patients with hemorrhoidal disease seeking treatment
- What they received
- medical, instrumental, or surgical treatment for hemorrhoids
- Compared with
- different treatment types compared to each other (medical vs instrumental vs surgical)
- Main outcome
- change in bleeding and prolapse scores and patient satisfaction after treatment
- Quality
- This was a single-center observational study without randomization, so differences between treatment groups could be due to patient selection rather than the treatment itself.
- Limitations
- Single-center, non-randomized comparison of treatment groups; abstract does not describe why bleeding occurs or isolate a specific intervention tested against a control.
Taken word for word from the abstract
- n
including 472 patients
- population
Bleeding, prolapse and pain were the main reasons for consultation.
- intervention
Treatment modalities were medical (44%),±instrumental (72%), and surgical (17%).
- comparator
improvement was more marked in the surgery group with a better rate of "very good satisfaction" (73% vs. 54%, P=0.003)
- primaryOutcome
the bleeding score and prolapse score decreased significantly (P=0.002 and P≤0.0001, respectively)
- result
improvement was more marked in the surgery group with a better rate of "very good satisfaction" (73% vs. 54%, P=0.003)
J Visc Surg · PMID 38580520 · Read it on PubMed ↗
Gallo et al. 2024
Sclerotherapy with 3% polidocanol foam for the treatment of mucocutaneous bridges and/or residual piles after open excisional hemorrhoidectomy
Fewer symptoms, no bleeding after combined treatment.RetrospectiveLow qualityRelated question
18 people3 months
77.8% of patients were symptom-free at 3 months, with significant drop in symptom scores from 16 to 2, and no bleeding or complications occurred
- Who was studied
- adults aged 18-75 with grade IV hemorrhoidal disease
- What they received
- open excisional hemorrhoidectomy combined with 3% polidocanol foam sclerotherapy on remaining tissue bridges/piles
- Compared with
- no comparator group; before-after comparison within same patients
- Main outcome
- symptom score (HDSS) and quality of life (SHS-HD) at 3 months after surgery
- Quality
- This was a small retrospective study of only 18 patients with no comparison group, so it's hard to know how much the sclerotherapy itself helped versus the surgery alone.
- Limitations
- single-center retrospective study; small sample size; short follow-up; no control group for comparison
Taken word for word from the abstract
- n
a total of 18 patients with IV-degree HD, aged between 18 and 75 years
- population
18 patients with IV-degree HD, aged between 18 and 75 years with symptomatic HD according to the Goligher classification
- intervention
combined treatment of open excisional hemorrhoidectomy and the use of ST on the remnant muco-cutaneous bridges/residual piles
- comparator
from 16 preoperatively (T0) to 2 at 3-month follow-up (T3)
- primaryOutcome
The Hemorrhoidal Disease Symptom Score (HDSS), the Short Health Scale for HD (SHS-HD) score and the Vaizey Incontinence Score were used to assess symptoms
- result
A total of 77.8% (14/18) of the patients were symptom-free (hemorrhoidal disease symptom score (HDSS) score = 0) after 3 months.
- result
Neither post-operative bleeding nor any type of complications occurred.
Updates Surg · PMID 38480640 · Read it on PubMed ↗
Gallo et al. 2024
Clinical evidence and rationale of mesoglycan to treat chronic venous disease and hemorrhoidal disease: a narrative review
Less rectal bleeding with mesoglycan.Narrative reviewVery low qualityRelated question
size not given2024
mesoglycan significantly reduced the severity of signs and symptoms and the risk of rectal bleeding
- Who was studied
- people with chronic venous disease or hemorrhoid disease
- What they received
- oral mesoglycan (a glycosaminoglycan supplement)
- Compared with
- standard postoperative care alone / usual treatment
- Main outcome
- severity of hemorrhoid symptoms and risk of rectal bleeding
- Quality
- This is a narrative review summarizing multiple trials without reporting their design details, sample sizes, or statistical rigor, so it cannot be weighed like a single controlled study.
- Limitations
- The abstract does not describe study designs, sample sizes, blinding, or statistical results for the cited trials, and it combines findings across two different diseases (CVD and HD).
Taken word for word from the abstract
- population
In patients with HD, mesoglycan significantly reduced the severity of signs and symptoms and the risk of rectal bleeding.
- intervention
oral mesoglycan reduced the severity of CVD signs and symptoms
- comparator
adding mesoglycan to standard postoperative care reduced pain, improved HRQoL, reduced incidence of thrombosis, and facilitated an earlier return to normal activities/work, compared with standard postoperative care alone
- primaryOutcome
mesoglycan significantly reduced the severity of signs and symptoms and the risk of rectal bleeding
- result
In patients with HD, mesoglycan significantly reduced the severity of signs and symptoms and the risk of rectal bleeding.
Updates Surg · PMID 38356039 · Read it on PubMed ↗
Batra et al. 2025
Injection sclerotherapy for the treatment of haemorrhoids in anticoagulated patients
Bleeding stopped in most patients.RetrospectiveLow quality
20 people6 months
90% of patients had no more bleeding after injection treatment, while staying on blood thinners
- Who was studied
- patients with symptomatic hemorrhoids who were on blood thinners (anticoagulation)
- What they received
- injection sclerotherapy
- Main outcome
- no bleeding for at least six months
- Quality
- small retrospective study of only 20 patients with no comparison group, so results could be due to chance or other factors.
- Limitations
- Retrospective case note review, small sample size, no control group, single center.
Taken word for word from the abstract
- n
A total of 20 patients with a median age of 64 years (range 35-86, 14 male) who underwent 32 IST treatments were identified.
- population
Patients treated with an IST for SH between 1 April 2014 and 30 November 2021 were identified. Anticoagulation was not stopped in these patients as they were at high risk of developing thromboembolism
- intervention
Injection sclerotherapy (IST) has been proposed as a treatment option for these patients.
- primaryOutcome
The primary outcome was symptom resolution, defined as no patient reporting bleeding for at least six months.
- result
Symptom resolution was achieved in 18 (90%) patients using IST while continuing anticoagulation treatment, with two (10%) patients requiring alternative interventions.
Ann R Coll Surg Engl · PMID 38174849 · Read it on PubMed ↗
Eminoğlu 2023
Stapled hemorrhoidopexy. A single-center study on over 600 patients with long term follow-up
Recurrent bleeding in some patients.Case seriesLow qualityRelated question
646 peopleone year
11% had grade 3 or 4 recurrence, 7% needed drug therapy for hemorrhoidal bleeding, and some needed band ligation or repeat surgery
- Who was studied
- people with stage 2 or 3 hemorrhoid disease
- What they received
- stapled hemorrhoidopexy surgery
- Compared with
- none (single group followed over time)
- Main outcome
- recurrence and complications after surgery, including bleeding
- Quality
- This is a single-center case series without a comparison group, so it cannot show whether the surgery itself caused the improvement or how it compares to other treatments.
- Limitations
- No control group, single surgeon, single center, and follow-up relied partly on phone calls rather than exams.
Taken word for word from the abstract
- n
646 patients were included.
- population
Patients with stage 2 and stage 3 hemorrhoidal disease included.
- intervention
Patients who were operated with stapled hemorrhoidopexy (SH) technique
- comparator
RESULTS: 646 patients were included.
- primaryOutcome
68 patients ( 11%) developed grade 3 or 4 recurrence
- result
68 patients ( 11%) developed grade 3 or 4 recurrence 38 (6 %) of these patients were treated with Milligan Morgan hemorroidectomy. 19 patients with bleeding were treated with band ligation . Fourty-five patients (7%) required drug therapy for treating hemorrhoidal bleeding.
Ann Ital Chir · PMID 38131339 · Read it on PubMed ↗
Onder et al. 2023
A retrospective comparative study of hemorrhoidal artery ligation versus ligasure hemorrhoidectomy for the third degree hemorrhoidal disease
Artery ligation healed faster than Ligasure surgery.RetrospectiveLow qualityRelated question
91 people2023
ADHL had shorter hospital stay and quicker resolution of postoperative bleeding than LH, with similar recurrence rates
- Who was studied
- patients with third degree hemorrhoidal disease
- What they received
- Doppler-guided ligation of hemorrhoidal arteries (ADHL)
- Compared with
- Ligasure hemorrhoidectomy (LH)
- Main outcome
- postoperative bleeding duration, pain, hospital stay, and recurrence
- Quality
- This was a retrospective, non-randomized comparison of two surgical techniques without blinding or control for confounders.
- Limitations
- Retrospective design; authors state prospective randomized controlled studies are needed
Taken word for word from the abstract
- n
The number of patients included in the study was 91.
- population
Patients treated with ADHL and LH for HD in our Surgery Clinic were included in the study.
- intervention
Doppler-guided ligation of the hemorrhoidal arteries (ADHL)
- comparator
Ligasure hemorrhoidectomy (LH)
- primaryOutcome
bleeding during and after the operation, length of hospital stay, postoperative pain scoring, and postoperative results
- result
In the postoperative period, bleeding was not observed after an average of 1.4 days in group 1, while this period was 4.9 days in group 2.
- result
The mean hospital stay was 1.5 days in the ADHL-treated group, compared to. 3.05 days in the LH group.
Asian J Surg · PMID 37659951 · Read it on PubMed ↗
Long et al. 2023
Milligan-Morgan hemorrhoidectomy combined with non-doppler hemorrhoidal artery ligation for the treatment of grade III/IV hemorrhoids: a single centre retrospective study
Less bleeding with artery ligation added.RetrospectiveLow qualityRelated question
115 people12 months
combined surgery had less bleeding, less pain, fewer complications, and lower recurrence than surgery alone
- Who was studied
- patients with grade III/IV hemorrhoids
- What they received
- hemorrhoid removal surgery combined with tying off the hemorrhoid artery (no ultrasound guidance)
- Compared with
- hemorrhoid removal surgery alone
- Main outcome
- pain, bleeding, swelling, and recurrence after surgery
- Quality
- This was a retrospective, single-center study comparing two patient groups rather than a randomized trial, so bias cannot be ruled out.
- Limitations
- Retrospective design, single center, not randomized
Taken word for word from the abstract
- n
We conducted a retrospective analysis of 115 patients with grade III/IV hemorrhoids, 53 patients had received MMH + ND-HAL, and the remaining 62 patients received MMH.
- population
115 patients with grade III/IV hemorrhoids
- intervention
MMH + ND-HAL
- comparator
received MMH
- primaryOutcome
intraoperative blood loss, postoperative visual analog scale (VAS) for pain, analgesic consumption, postoperative bleeding, perianal incision edema, urinary retention, anal stenosis, anal incontinence incidence, recurrence rate (prolapse or bleeding), and patient satisfaction
- result
The intraoperative blood loss, the incidence of postoperative bleeding, perianal incision edema, and urinary retention in the MMH + ND-HAL group was lower than that in the MMH group (P < 0.05).
- followUp
At follow-up by telephone or outpatient 12 months after surgery
BMC Gastroenterol · PMID 37653473 · Read it on PubMed ↗
Huang et al. 2023
The efficiency and safety of modified tissue-selecting therapy stapler combined with complete anal canal epithelial preservation operation in circumferential mixed hemorrhoids: a randomized controlled trial
Better cure, less recurrence than PPH.Randomised trialModerate qualityRelated question
306 people12 months
M-TST-CACP group showed a higher cure rate, lower recurrence, lower anal incontinence score, and lower rate of anal stenosis than the PPH group
- Who was studied
- patients with circumferential mixed hemorrhoids
- What they received
- modified tissue-selecting therapy stapler combined with complete anal canal epithelial preservation operation (M-TST-CACP)
- Compared with
- procedure for prolapse and hemorrhoids (PPH)
- Main outcome
- cure rate, recurrence, anal incontinence, and anal stenosis after surgery
- Quality
- It was a randomized trial but only the statistical analyst was blinded, and it was conducted at a single center, which limits confidence in the results.
- Limitations
- Single-center study with blinding limited to the statistical analyst; postoperative bleeding was tracked as a safety measure but no specific data or comparison on bleeding were given.
Taken word for word from the abstract
- population
circumferential mixed hemorrhoids
- intervention
modified tissue-selecting therapy stapler combined with complete anal canal epithelial preservation operation (M-TST-CACP)
- comparator
procedure for prolapse and hemorrhoids (PPH)
- primaryOutcome
higher cure rate (6 months: 74.51% vs. 64.71%, P = 0.044)
- result
M-TST-CACP group showed a higher cure rate (6 months: 74.51% vs. 64.71%, P = 0.044), lower recurrence (6 months: 0% vs. 4.58%, P = 0.015; 12 months: 0.65% vs. 5.88%, P = 0.010), lower anal incontinence score (1 month: 1.29 ± 1.17 vs. 1.93 ± 1.33; 3 months: 1.07 ± 0.87 vs. 1.59 ± 1.01; 6 months: 0.58 ± 0.61 vs. 1.00 ± 0.90; all P < 0.001), and lower rate of anal stenosis (1 month: 0% vs. 7.84%; 3 months: 0% vs. 9.80%; both P < 0.001) than the PPH group.
- n
A total of 306 patients were finally included for analysis.
- followUp
12 months: 0.65% vs. 5.88%, P = 0.010
Langenbecks Arch Surg · PMID 37620667 · Read it on PubMed ↗
Fiordaliso et al. 2023
Treatment of haemorrhoids in pregnancy: A retrospective review
Fiber and stool softeners considered safest option.Narrative reviewVery low quality
size not given2023
Fiber, stool softeners and mild laxatives are considered safe; topical medication and oral phlebotonics need caution due to lack of safety/efficacy evidence; anal packing can help with massive bleeding; surgery reserved for severe cases
- Who was studied
- pregnant women with hemorrhoids
- What they received
- various hemorrhoid treatments (fiber, stool softeners, laxatives, topical medication, phlebotonics, anal packing, hemorrhoidectomy)
- Compared with
- no formal comparator; narrative synthesis of treatment options
- Main outcome
- safe and effective management of hemorrhoids in pregnancy, including bleeding control
- Quality
- This is a non-systematic literature review without pooled data, numbers of patients, or quality assessment of included studies.
- Limitations
- No language selection or systematic methodology described, no participant numbers given, and abstract notes lack of strong evidence for several treatments in pregnancy.
Taken word for word from the abstract
- population
commoner during pregnancy and the puerperium
- intervention
Fiber supplement, stool softener and mild laxatives are generally safe for pregnant women. Topical medication or oral phlebotonics may be used with special caution
- comparator
Hemorrhoidectomy is reserved in strangulated or extensively thrombosed hemorrhoids, and hemorrhoids with intractable bleeding.
- primaryOutcome
treatment of hemorrhoidis in pregnancy
- result
In case of massive bleeding, anal packing could be a simple and useful maneuver.
- result
Topical medication or oral phlebotonics may be used with special caution because the strong evidence of their safety and efficacy in pregnancy is lacking.
Ann Ital Chir · PMID 37530049 · Read it on PubMed ↗
De Gregorio et al. 2023
Catheter-directed hemorrhoidal embolization for rectal bleeding due to hemorrhoids (Goligher grade I-III): prospective outcomes from a Spanish emborrhoid registry
Fewer bleeding episodes after embolization.RegistryLow quality
80 people12 months
68.7% had no rectal bleeding at 12 months; 31.3% had bleeding come back
- Who was studied
- adults with bleeding hemorrhoids, grade I-III (mild to moderate)
- What they received
- catheter-directed embolization of the rectal artery using microcoils
- Compared with
- none (before-after comparison within same patients)
- Main outcome
- absence of rectal bleeding after treatment
- Quality
- This was a single-group registry study without a comparison group, so improvement can't be separated from natural changes over time.
- Limitations
- No control group, so it's unclear how much of the improvement is due to the procedure itself.
Taken word for word from the abstract
- n
Eighty patients (62.5% males) with a mean age of 48 ± 9 years were recruited prospectively.
- population
All patients had symptomatic bleeding hemorrhoids. All patients were classified according to Goligher classification: grade I (13.7%), grade II (71.1%), grade III (15%), and no grade IV were recruited in this study.
- intervention
In all cases, microcoils were used to embolize the superior rectal artery(SRA), and microspheres if recurrence of bleeding occurred.
- comparator
VAS and QL improved 4 points and 1.5 respectively after embolization.
- primaryOutcome
Fifty-five (68.7%) participants had the absence of rectal bleeding after 12 months of embolization.
- result
Fifty-five (68.7%) participants had the absence of rectal bleeding after 12 months of embolization. VAS and QL improved 4 points and 1.5 respectively after embolization. A total of 25/80 (31.3%) had a recurrence in rectal bleeding.
Eur Radiol · PMID 37458757 · Read it on PubMed ↗
Pastor Peinado et al. 2023
Quality of life and outcomes after rubber band ligation for haemorrhoidal disease
Fewer symptoms after banding.Prospective cohortLow qualityRelated question
100 people6 months
significant improvement in symptom and quality of life scores, 89% success rate, 76% high satisfaction
- Who was studied
- patients with symptomatic grade II-III hemorrhoids who did not improve after 6 months of conservative treatment
- What they received
- rubber band ligation
- Compared with
- before vs after treatment, no control group
- Main outcome
- quality of life scores (symptom severity and health status)
- Quality
- this was a single-group observational study without a comparison group, so improvement cannot be clearly credited to the treatment alone
- Limitations
- no control group; observational design; abstract does not describe how bleeding specifically was assessed or why it stops
Taken word for word from the abstract
- n
A total of 100 patients were finally included.
- population
patients with symptomatic grade II-III haemorrhoids who did not improve after 6 months of conservative treatment
- intervention
rubber band ligation (RBL)
- comparator
This was a prospective cohort observational study where patients with haemorrhoidal disease and indication for RBL were included
- primaryOutcome
Patient´s quality of life was assessed by scores: HDSS (Hemorrhoidal Disease Symptom Score) and SHS (Short Health Scale)
- result
a significant reduction was found in the HDSS and SHS scores (p < 0.001)
- result
The overall success rate of banding was 89%.
Langenbecks Arch Surg · PMID 37349572 · Read it on PubMed ↗
Tümer et al. 2023
Comparing outcomes of laser hemorrhoidoplasty and LigaSure hemorrhoidectomy in grade II-III hemorrhoidal disease: a retrospective analysis
Less pain, more recurrence with laser.RetrospectiveLow quality
size not given2023
laser group had lower pain and less intraoperative bleeding but higher recurrence (9.4% vs 2.5%)
- Who was studied
- patients with grade II-III hemorrhoidal disease
- What they received
- laser hemorrhoidoplasty
- Compared with
- LigaSure hemorrhoidectomy
- Main outcome
- postoperative pain measured by Visual Analog Scale
- Quality
- It is a retrospective study without a reported sample size, which limits how much confidence we can place in the comparison.
- Limitations
- Retrospective design; number of patients not reported; higher recurrence rate in the laser group than the comparator.
Taken word for word from the abstract
- population
patients with grade II-III hemorrhoidal disease
- intervention
laser hemorrhoidoplasty
- comparator
LigaSure hemorrhoidectomy
- primaryOutcome
The primary outcome was the difference in postoperative pain between the two groups, as assessed using the Visual Analog Scale (VAS).
- result
Patients in the laser hemorrhoidoplasty group experienced significantly lower postoperative pain compared to those in the LigaSure hemorrhoidectomy group. Bleeding amounts during the operation were also significantly lower in the laser group. However, the recurrence rate was higher in the laser group compared to the LigaSure group (9.4% versus 2.5%).
ANZ J Surg · PMID 37312422 · Read it on PubMed ↗
Pfeil et al. 2023
[Hemorroids Therapy: a Tailored Approch]
Various treatments relieve symptoms well.Narrative reviewVery low quality
size not given2023
most patients improve with conservative treatment and sclerotherapy controls symptoms well, with surgery offering further options if these fail
- Who was studied
- patients with symptomatic haemorrhoids
- What they received
- conservative treatment, sclerotherapy, and various surgical options (e.g., Fergusson, Milligan-Morgan, Longo haemorrhoidopexy, HAL-RAR, IRT, LT, RFA)
- Compared with
- different treatment options within the tailored approach
- Main outcome
- symptom control and quality of life
- Quality
- This is a narrative overview describing treatment options without presenting specific trial data or outcome statistics.
- Limitations
- No quantitative data, patient numbers, or comparative outcomes are reported; the abstract is descriptive rather than evidence-based.
Taken word for word from the abstract
- population
symptomatic haemorrhoids
- intervention
Besides well-known procedures such as Fergusson, Milligan-Morgan procedure or haemorrhoidopexy (Longo) there are less invasive options such as HAL-RAR, IRT, LT and RFA.
- comparator
A tailored approach is mandatory.
- primaryOutcome
The vast majority of patients can be treated conservatively with excellent results in terms of quality of life.
- result
Sclerotherapy provides good control of symptoms at any stage of haemorrhoidal disease.
Zentralbl Chir · PMID 37267978 · Read it on PubMed ↗
Devi et al. 2023
Hemorrhoid Disease: A Review on Treatment, Clinical Research and Patent Data
No clear result reported.Narrative reviewVery low qualityRelated question
size not given2023
not reported numerically; review summarizes recent developments and studies without stating specific outcome results
- Who was studied
- people with hemorrhoid disease
- What they received
- newer drug molecules and treatments for hemorrhoids
- Main outcome
- safety, clinical efficacy, and marketed formulation effectiveness
- Quality
- This is a narrative review summarizing literature without presenting its own trial data or statistical results.
- Limitations
- Abstract does not report study design details, sample sizes, or specific outcome data; it is a general literature summary.
Taken word for word from the abstract
- population
Hemorrhoid disease (HD) is an anal-rectal ailment
- intervention
newer molecules to overcome hemorrhoids
- primaryOutcome
safety, clinical efficacy, and marketed formulation for the effective management of hemorrhoids
- result
This review article mainly focuses on the newer molecules to overcome hemorrhoids and also emphasizes various studies carried out in the past.
Infect Disord Drug Targets · PMID 37106517 · Read it on PubMed ↗
Laurain et al. 2023
French multicentre prospective evaluation of radiofrequency ablation in the management of haemorrhoidal disease
Fewer symptoms, including less bleeding.Prospective cohortLow quality
129 people3 months (with some outcomes to 1 year)
quality of life score dropped from 17.4/100 to 0/100, and bleeding reports fell from 84% to 21% of patients
- Who was studied
- adults with grade II-III hemorrhoids
- What they received
- radiofrequency ablation (Rafaelo) of hemorrhoids
- Main outcome
- quality of life score related to hemorrhoid disease at 3 months
- Quality
- This study had no comparison group and measured change before and after treatment in the same patients, so it can't rule out natural improvement over time.
- Limitations
- No control group; some patients required reoperation for relapse or complications; abstract does not report loss to follow-up.
Taken word for word from the abstract
- population
outpatients with grade II-III haemorrhoids
- intervention
RFA (Rafaelo©)
- n
A total of 129 patients (69% men, median age 49 years) were operated on in 16 French centres.
- primaryOutcome
Primary endpoint was the evolution of a quality-of-life score adapted to the haemorrhoid pathology (HEMO-FISS-QoL) 3 months after surgery.
- result
Median HEMO-FISS-QoL score dropped significantly from 17.4/100 to 0/100 (p < 0.0001) at 3 months.
- result
the rate of patients reporting bleeding (21% vs. 84%, p < 0.001)
Tech Coloproctol · PMID 37005961 · Read it on PubMed ↗
Ram et al. 2023
Laser hemorrhoidoplasty for II-IV grade hemorrhoids: should we treat them the same?
Laser surgery works, but grade IV risks more bleeding.RetrospectiveLow qualityRelated question
162 people2023
Most patients had symptom relief, but grade IV hemorrhoids had much higher rates of post-operative bleeding, readmission, and recurrence than grade II or III
- Who was studied
- patients with grade II-IV hemorrhoids
- What they received
- laser hemorrhoidoplasty surgery
- Compared with
- hemorrhoid grade groups compared to each other (grade II vs III vs IV)
- Main outcome
- post-operative symptom relief and complications, including bleeding, readmission, and reoperation
- Quality
- This is a retrospective study without a control group or randomization, so it cannot reliably prove cause and effect.
- Limitations
- Retrospective analysis; no comparison to other treatments or untreated hemorrhoids; the question concerns why hemorrhoids bleed and what stops it, while this abstract reports outcomes of a specific laser surgery technique.
Taken word for word from the abstract
- n
One hundred and sixty two patients that underwent laser hemorrhoidoplasty (LHP) were included.
- population
all patients who underwent LHP surgery between September 2018 and October 2021
- intervention
Laser Hemorrhoidoplasty (LHP) is a novel therapeutic option for hemorrhoids.
- comparator
Post-operative complication rate was significantly higher in patients with grade 4 hemorrhoids compared to grades 3 or 2
- primaryOutcome
we aimed to evaluate the post-operative outcomes of patients undergoing LHP surgery based on hemorrhoid grade
- result
Post-operative complication rate was significantly higher in patients with grade 4 hemorrhoids compared to grades 3 or 2, due to a higher rate of post-operative bleeding (31.6% vs. 6.5% and 6.7%, respectively; p = 0.004).
Updates Surg · PMID 36881287 · Read it on PubMed ↗
Saleem et al. 2023
Comparison Of Outcome Between Open Haemorrhoidectomy Versus Trans-Anal Doppler Guided Hemorrhoidal Artery Ligation With Recto-Anal Repair In 3rd And 4th Degree Haemorrhoids
Similar pain and bleeding; shorter hospital stay.Randomised trialLow qualityRelated question
70 people2023
no significant difference in post-op pain or bleeding, but shorter hospital stay with HAL RAR
- Who was studied
- adults with 3rd and 4th degree haemorrhoids undergoing surgery
- What they received
- Doppler guided hemorrhoidal artery ligation with recto-anal repair (HAL RAR)
- Compared with
- open haemorrhoidectomy
- Main outcome
- post-operative pain, bleeding, and hospital stay
- Quality
- small randomized trial of only 70 patients with no mention of blinding or how bleeding was measured
- Limitations
- small sample size; abstract does not mention blinding or long-term follow-up
Taken word for word from the abstract
- n
results of 70 patients of haemorrhoids
- population
3rd and 4th degree disease fulfilling the selection criteria
- intervention
Doppler guided haemorrhoidal artery ligation with rectoanal repair (HAL RAR) procedure
- comparator
open haemorrhoidectomy (OH)
- primaryOutcome
post-operative pain, bleeding and hospital stay
- result
There was no significant difference in mean post-op pain on day seven, and post-op bleeding, but there was significant difference in terms of mean hospital stay between the two groups.
J Ayub Med Coll Abbottabad · PMID 36849385 · Read it on PubMed ↗
Boerhave et al. 2023
The efficacy of laser haemorrhoidoplasty (LHP) in the treatment of symptomatic haemorrhoidal disease: An observational cohort study
High satisfaction, but bleeding often persisted.Prospective cohortLow quality
200 people6-7 weeks postoperatively; recurrence assessed within 1 year
Most patients were satisfied, but about a quarter still had bleeding afterward and over a quarter had hemorrhoids return within a year
- Who was studied
- Patients with symptomatic hemorrhoids (grades 1-4)
- What they received
- Laser hemorrhoidoplasty (LHP), a laser procedure that seals off blood vessels feeding the hemorrhoids
- Compared with
- None - single group, no comparison treatment
- Main outcome
- Patient satisfaction and/or complete recovery of symptoms (bleeding, pain, itching, soiling, prolapse)
- Quality
- This study only followed one group of patients without comparing them to another treatment, so it can't show whether the laser itself caused the improvement.
- Limitations
- No control or comparison group; single-center design; relies on patient-reported outcomes
Taken word for word from the abstract
- population
Patients who underwent treatment for symptomatic haemorrhoids (degrees 1-4)
- intervention
Laser haemorrhoidoplasty (LHP) is an emerging nonexcisional surgical procedure in which the arteriovenous flow of the haemorrhoidal plexus is interrupted through laser coagulation.
- comparator
A total of 200 patients (71% male, average age 51 years) were analysed.
- primaryOutcome
Primary outcomes were patient satisfaction and/or complete recovery of symptoms.
- result
Patient satisfaction regarding LHP treatment was reached in 155 (84,7%) patients. Postoperative blood loss was reported by 44 (24,0%) patients during time of evaluation.
- result
Recurrence of haemorrhoids within 1 year occurred in 50 (27,3%) patients.
- n
A total of 200 patients (71% male, average age 51 years) were analysed.
Colorectal Dis · PMID 36757069 · Read it on PubMed ↗
Bagla et al. 2023
Outcomes of Hemorrhoidal Artery Embolization from a Multidisciplinary Outpatient Interventional Center
Less bleeding and pain after embolization.RetrospectiveLow quality
134 people1 month
significant improvement in symptom scores, pain, bleeding, and quality of life at 1 month, with 93% clinical success
- Who was studied
- patients with symptomatic internal hemorrhoids that hadn't responded to other treatment
- What they received
- blocking the hemorrhoid blood vessels (embolization) using particles and coils
- Compared with
- before-and-after comparison, no control group
- Main outcome
- improvement in hemorrhoid symptoms, pain, bleeding score, and quality of life at 1 month
- Quality
- this was a retrospective study without a comparison group, only followed patients for one month, so it can't rule out natural improvement or placebo effect.
- Limitations
- retrospective design, no control group, very short follow-up of only 1 month
Taken word for word from the abstract
- n
Retrospective analysis of 134 patients
- population
symptomatic refractory internal hemorrhoids
- intervention
Branches of the superior rectal artery (SRA) or middle rectal artery supplying the corpus cavernosum recti were embolized with both spherical particles and microcoils.
- comparator
Standard-of-care evaluations were performed at baseline and the 1 month follow-up
- primaryOutcome
hemorrhoid-related pain (HRP) (0-10), hemorrhoid symptoms score (HSS) (5-20), quality of life (QoL) (0-4), French bleeding score (FBS) (0-9), and HG (0-4)
- result
There were significant improvements in all mean outcomes at 1 month: HSS (11-7.8; P < .01), HRP (4.1-1.3; P < .01), QoL (2.2-0.8; P < .01), FBS (4.4-2.2; P < .01), and HG (2.3-1.2; P < .05).
J Vasc Interv Radiol · PMID 36736822 · Read it on PubMed ↗
Falsarella et al. 2023
Embolization of the Superior Rectal Arteries versus Closed Hemorrhoidectomy (Ferguson Technique) in the Treatment of Hemorrhoidal Disease: A Randomized Clinical Trial
Similar bleeding relief, far less pain.Randomised trialLow quality
29 people12 months
Embolization caused far less pain and need for pain medication than surgery, and bleeding improved in most embolization patients (83.3%), but overall symptom frequency at 12 months was similar between the two treatments
- Who was studied
- adults with symptomatic hemorrhoid disease, grades 2 and 3
- What they received
- embolization of the superior rectal arteries
- Compared with
- closed surgical hemorrhoidectomy (Ferguson technique)
- Main outcome
- pain after the procedure and recurrence of hemorrhoid symptoms (including bleeding) over 12 months
- Quality
- This was a very small randomized trial (29 patients, 4 excluded) with short follow-up, so its findings could easily be due to chance or not apply broadly.
- Limitations
- Small sample size, 4 of 29 randomized patients excluded from analysis, and only 12 months of follow-up.
Taken word for word from the abstract
- population
33 patients with symptomatic hemorrhoidal disease Grades 2 and 3
- intervention
superior rectal artery embolization
- comparator
Ferguson closed hemorrhoidectomy surgical group
- n
33 patients with symptomatic hemorrhoidal disease Grades 2 and 3 who were randomly assigned to 2 different groups: the superior rectal artery embolization group (n = 15) and Ferguson closed hemorrhoidectomy surgical group (n = 14)
- result
The mean pain during the first bowel movement after the procedure was 6.08 ± 4.41 in the surgery group and 0 in the embolization group (P = .001).
- result
In the embolization group, the most prevalent preprocedural symptom was bleeding in 14 patients, with complete improvement in 12 (83.3%) patients.
- result
The frequency of symptoms (bleeding, pain, prolapse, and pruritus) was similar between the groups at 12 months (P = .691).
- primaryOutcome
Pain using the visual analog scale and the use of analgesics were evaluated 3 times daily during the first 7 days of the postoperative period. Recurrent symptoms and satisfaction with treatment were also evaluated in the subsequent first, third, sixth, and twelfth months.
- followUp
the subsequent first, third, sixth, and twelfth months
J Vasc Interv Radiol · PMID 36736690 · Read it on PubMed ↗
Symeonidis et al. 2022
Milligan-Morgan hemorrhoidectomy vs. hemorrhoid artery ligation and recto-anal repair: a comparative study
Better satisfaction with artery ligation for bleeding.RetrospectiveLow quality
116 people41 months
Overall recurrence rates were similar between the two techniques; in patients whose main symptom was bleeding, satisfaction was significantly higher with HAL-RAR, while in patients with pain, itching or discomfort, MM gave fewer recurrences and better satisfaction
- Who was studied
- adults with hemorrhoidal disease who underwent surgery
- What they received
- hemorrhoidal artery ligation and recto-anal repair (HAL-RAR)
- Compared with
- Milligan-Morgan (MM) hemorrhoidectomy
- Main outcome
- rate of hemorrhoid recurrence and patient satisfaction after surgery
- Quality
- This is a retrospective, non-randomized comparison with subgroup analyses and no blinding, so the findings are less reliable.
- Limitations
- Retrospective design, loss to follow-up of 8 patients, and comparisons were based on subgroup analyses by presenting symptom
Taken word for word from the abstract
- n
Of the remaining 116 patients
- population
patients submitted to HD surgery in our department
- intervention
hemorrhoidal artery ligation and rectoanal repair (HAL-RAR) technique
- comparator
Milligan-Morgan (MM) hemorrhoidectomy
- primaryOutcome
Primary end points were recurrence rates and patients' satisfaction rates.
- result
In the subgroup of patients with bleeding as the presenting symptom, patients satisfaction rates were significantly better (8.59 ± 1.88 vs. 6.45 ± 2.70-p 0.0013) in the HAL-RAR group.
- result
Patients with itching, pain or discomfort as the presenting symptoms of HD experienced statistically significantly lower recurrences (p 0.0354) and reported statistically significantly better satisfaction rates (6.72 ± 2.15 vs. 8.11 ± 1.99-p 0.0111) when submitted to MM.
- followUp
At a median follow up of 41 months (minimum 24 months-maximum 72 months)
BMC Surg · PMID 36474223 · Read it on PubMed ↗
Lohsiriwat et al. 2023
Recurrence Rates and Pharmacological Treatment for Hemorrhoidal Disease: A Systematic Review
Flavonoid treatment eased symptoms; recurrence data limited.Systematic reviewLow qualityRelated question
size not given2023
recurrence rates ranged from 0 to 56.5% after surgery or phlebotonics, with most studies reporting 20% or less, and micronized purified flavonoid fractions significantly improved main symptoms compared to other pharmacological treatments
- Who was studied
- adults with hemorrhoidal disease
- What they received
- pharmacological treatments (including micronized purified flavonoid fractions) and surgery for hemorrhoids
- Compared with
- other pharmacological treatments or different interventions for hemorrhoids
- Main outcome
- recurrence of hemorrhoidal disease and symptom improvement
- Quality
- The review combined many different real-world studies with inconsistent data collection and found no studies on recurrence after medical treatment, making the evidence patchy and hard to rely on.
- Limitations
- Consistent data were limited on the epidemiology of HD or HD recurrence; no RWE studies reporting recurrence in patients receiving systemic or topical treatments were identified.
Taken word for word from the abstract
- population
adults with HD
- intervention
micronized purified flavonoid fractions significantly improved the main symptoms of HD compared to other pharmacological treatments
- comparator
other pharmacological treatments
- primaryOutcome
evaluating the incidence, prevalence, or recurrence of HD
- result
Twenty-three RWE studies and one meta-analysis reported HD recurrence rates ranging from 0 to 56.5% following surgery or phlebotonics, with most (n = 19) reporting rates of 20% or less.
- result
micronized purified flavonoid fractions significantly improved the main symptoms of HD compared to other pharmacological treatments
- n
The SLR identified 44 eligible publications.
Adv Ther · PMID 36331754 · Read it on PubMed ↗
Gallo et al. 2023
Sclerotherapy with 3% polidocanol foam to treat second-degree haemorrhoidal disease: Three-year follow-up of a multicentre, single arm, IDEAL phase 2b trial
Bleeding stopped in most patients long-term.Case seriesLow quality
183 people3 year
Success rate was 95.6% (175/183) at 1 year, falling to 90.2% (165/183) at 3 years; recurrence of bleeding ranged from 12% to 28%
- Who was studied
- Patients aged 18-75 with symptomatic grade II hemorrhoid disease that had not responded to medical treatment
- What they received
- Sclerotherapy injection using 3% polidocanol foam
- Compared with
- None — single-arm study with no control group
- Main outcome
- Complete absence of bleeding episodes 7 days after treatment
- Quality
- This was a single-arm trial with no comparison group, so it cannot show whether the improvement was due to the treatment itself.
- Limitations
- Open label, single-arm design with no control group; some patients were converted to surgery and excluded from later symptom-free calculations.
Taken word for word from the abstract
- n
A total of 183 patients with II-degree HD
- population
aged between 18 and 75 years with symptomatic HD according to the Goligher classification and unresponsive to medical treatment
- intervention
underwent sclerotherapy with 3% polidocanol foam
- comparator
This was an open label, single-arm, phase 2b trial
- primaryOutcome
Successful treatment was defined as the complete absence of bleeding episodes after 7 days (T1) according to the bleeding score.
- result
The overall success rate ranged from 95.6% (175/183) at 1 year to 90.2% (165/183) after the final 3 year follow-up. The recurrence rate, based on the primary outcome, ranged from 12% (15/125) to 28% (35/125).
Colorectal Dis · PMID 36268758 · Read it on PubMed ↗
Cheng et al. 2022
Risk factors of delayed hemorrhage after LigaSure hemorrhoidectomy
Male sex, less surgeon experience raised bleeding risk.RetrospectiveLow qualityRelated question
437 people2022
male sex was an independent risk factor for delayed bleeding, and the bleeding rate dropped from about 10% to about 5% as the surgeon gained experience
- Who was studied
- patients with grade II to IV hemorrhoids who had hemorrhoidectomy using LigaSure devices
- What they received
- LigaSure hemorrhoidectomy, analyzed for factors linked to bleeding afterward
- Compared with
- earlier surgeon cases versus later, more experienced cases; male versus female patients
- Main outcome
- delayed bleeding after the hemorrhoidectomy surgery
- Quality
- this is a retrospective study from a single surgeon with only 22 bleeding events, so the risk-factor findings are not strong evidence.
- Limitations
- retrospective design, single surgeon, small number of bleeding events (22), no separate comparison group reported in this analysis
Taken word for word from the abstract
- n
included 437 consecutive patients with symptomatic grade II to IV hemorrhoids who received hemorrhoidectomy by LigaSure devices
- population
437 consecutive patients with symptomatic grade II to IV hemorrhoids who received hemorrhoidectomy by LigaSure devices
- intervention
hemorrhoidectomy by LigaSure devices
- comparator
The cumulative incidence was initially higher (about 10%) in the earlier cases and stabilized at around 5% with more cases.
- primaryOutcome
DPHB developed in 22 patients (5%).
- result
Multivariate analysis showed that the male sex was an independent risk factor for DPHB in patients who underwent hemorrhoidectomy with LigaSure devices.
- result
The cumulative incidence was initially higher (about 10%) in the earlier cases and stabilized at around 5% with more cases.
BMC Surg · PMID 36229826 · Read it on PubMed ↗
Panneau et al. 2022
Rectal Artery Embolization for Hemorrhoidal Disease: Anatomy, Evaluation, and Treatment Techniques
Embolization reported to improve bleeding.Narrative reviewVery low quality
size not given2022
Studies have shown improvement in symptoms and high technical success rates after treatment.
- Who was studied
- people with chronic hemorrhoid disease causing rectal bleeding
- What they received
- embolization of the rectal arteries (emborrhoid procedure)
- Compared with
- standard treatments such as diet/hygiene measures, medications, banding, or surgery
- Main outcome
- improvement in bleeding and other hemorrhoid symptoms
- Quality
- This is a general review describing technique and summarizing other studies rather than presenting its own controlled data.
- Limitations
- The abstract does not describe study design, sample sizes, or comparison groups for the 'published results' it mentions.
Taken word for word from the abstract
- population
Chronic hemorrhoidal disease is a common anorectal condition that leads to hemorrhoidal hyperplasia
- intervention
Embolization of the rectal arteries (ie, emborrhoid) has recently emerged as an effective treatment option
- comparator
The most standard treatment involves dietary and hygiene measures, use of phlebotonic drugs, and nonsurgical treatment such as infrared photocoagulation or elastic band ligation.
- primaryOutcome
Studies have shown improvement in symptoms and high technical success rates after treatment.
- result
Studies have shown improvement in symptoms and high technical success rates after treatment.
Radiographics · PMID 36190848 · Read it on PubMed ↗
Dean et al. 2023
The Impact of Antithrombotic Medications on Postoperative Bleeding Events Following Hemorrhoidectomy
More post-surgery bleeding on blood thinners.RetrospectiveLow qualityRelated question
1,152 people2023
patients on blood thinners had more postoperative bleeding events (5.92%) than those not on blood thinners (2.66%), about 2.3 times higher odds, but severe bleeding needing hospital admission or repeat procedure was not more common in the blood-thinner group
- Who was studied
- patients who had hemorrhoid removal or banding procedures
- What they received
- being on blood-thinning medications (anticoagulants/antiplatelets, including newer DOACs)
- Compared with
- not being on blood-thinning medications
- Main outcome
- bleeding complications after the procedure (postoperative bleeding events)
- Quality
- it is a retrospective chart review from one hospital, which cannot fully rule out other explanations for the difference seen
- Limitations
- retrospective single-institution design, possible confounding by indication, and it studies surgical bleeding risk rather than why hemorrhoids themselves bleed or how to stop that bleeding
Taken word for word from the abstract
- population
patients who had undergone a total of 1152 procedures, including hemorrhoid excision and ligation
- intervention
whether they were prescribed AT
- comparator
2.66% of patients not on ATs
- primaryOutcome
whether a PBE occurred
- result
PBE's were noted in 5.92% of patients on ATs, as opposed to 2.66% of patients not on ATs (P = .014.) The odds ratio of having a PBE when on ATs vs not on ATs is 2.3 (95% CI 1.21 to 4.38, P = .011).
- n
a total of 1152 procedures, including hemorrhoid excision and ligation
Am Surg · PMID 36048039 · Read it on PubMed ↗
Güemes-Quinto et al. 2022
Emergency surgical treatment for active bleeding and anemia in patients with hemorrhoidal disease
Emergency surgery used for severe bleeding.RetrospectiveVery low quality
53 people2022
most patients (92.5%) were treated with Ferguson hemorrhoidectomy, fewer with an advanced energy device or Milligan-Morgan technique, and the authors conclude emergency hemorrhoidectomy is the treatment of choice for severe active bleeding
- Who was studied
- patients with hemorrhoid disease who had active bleeding and anemia needing emergency surgery
- What they received
- emergency hemorrhoid surgery (mainly the Ferguson hemorrhoidectomy technique)
- Compared with
- no comparison group reported; different surgical techniques were compared only in frequency of use
- Main outcome
- description of which surgical technique was used to treat active bleeding and anemia from hemorrhoids
- Quality
- this is a retrospective, descriptive case series with no comparison group, so it cannot show whether surgery actually stopped bleeding better than any alternative.
- Limitations
- retrospective design, no control group, no reported outcomes after surgery such as rebleeding or healing rates
Taken word for word from the abstract
- n
Fifty-three (10.3%) patients met the criteria for presenting active hemorrhoidal bleeding at the time of review and clinical and biochemical data of anemia.
- population
patients with hemorrhoidal disease (HD), anemia, and active bleeding in need of urgent surgery
- intervention
The treatment received in 92.5% of the cases was hemorrhoidectomy with the Ferguson technique
- comparator
in 5.7% (3), a hemorrhoidectomy was performed with an advanced energy device, and 1.9% (1) underwent the Milligan-Morgan technique
- primaryOutcome
The purpose of the study is to describe the clinical and surgical characteristics of patients with hemorrhoidal disease (HD), anemia, and active bleeding in need of urgent surgery.
- result
Emergency hemorrhoidectomy is the treatment of choice for patients with severe active bleeding from HD.
Cir Cir · PMID 35944106 · Read it on PubMed ↗
Fu et al. 2022
Efficacy and safety of micronized purified flavonoid fractions for the treatment of postoperative hemorrhoid complications: A systematic review and meta-analysis
Less post-surgery bleeding and pain.Meta-analysisModerate qualityRelated question
2,335 people2022
MPFF reduced bleeding rate, pain score and edema score and improved clinical efficacy, without clear effect on adverse reactions
- Who was studied
- patients recovering from hemorrhoid surgery
- What they received
- micronized purified flavonoid fractions (MPFF)
- Main outcome
- post-surgery bleeding, pain, swelling and overall clinical improvement
- Quality
- It pools 22 randomized trials with over 2000 patients, but the abstract notes small sample sizes limited the ability to define a standard dose, so confidence is only moderate.
- Limitations
- Small sample size prevented establishing a standardized treatment regimen; heterogeneity addressed only via subgroup and sensitivity analysis.
Taken word for word from the abstract
- n
A total of 22 RCTs, including 2,335 participants were included in the analysis.
- population
treating postoperative hemorrhoid complications
- intervention
Micronized purified flavonoid fractions (MPFF) have been shown to improve hemorrhoid symptoms.
- primaryOutcome
MPFF improved the clinical efficacy of post-hemorrhoidectomy and reduced the bleeding rate, pain score, and edema score
- result
MPFF improved the clinical efficacy of post-hemorrhoidectomy and reduced the bleeding rate, pain score, and edema score, although no substantial effect on adverse reactions was reported.
- limitations
due to the small sample size, the standardized treatment regimen of MPFF could not be obtained; therefore, further research is warranted.
Phytomedicine · PMID 35752073 · Read it on PubMed ↗
Yu et al. 2022
Modified rubber band ligation for treatment of grade II/III hemorrhoids: clinical efficacy and safety evaluation-a retrospective study
Fewer bleeding and recurrence cases.RetrospectiveLow quality
274 people3 months
modified technique had no delayed bleeding cases and lower recurrence rate than conventional banding
- Who was studied
- patients with grade II or III internal hemorrhoids
- What they received
- modified rubber band ligation
- Compared with
- conventional rubber band ligation
- Main outcome
- delayed bleeding and recurrence after treatment
- Quality
- This was a retrospective study comparing two groups without randomization, so other differences between patients could explain the results.
- Limitations
- Retrospective design, not randomized, single center, authors call for larger studies with different design to confirm results
Taken word for word from the abstract
- n
A total of 274 patients were enrolled, including 149 patients treated with modified RBL and 125 treated with conventional RBL.
- population
consecutive patients with grade II or III internal hemorrhoids treated with RBL
- intervention
modified RBL
- comparator
conventional RBL
- primaryOutcome
Postoperative minor complications such as pain, swelling, anal edema, prolapse recurrence and major complications like DB were retrospectively reviewed.
- result
Five cases of postoperative DB have been observed in the conventional RBL group, compared to none in the modified ones, with a significant difference (P < 0.05).
- result
8 cases in the modified RBL group experienced a recurrence rate of 5.4%, whereas 17 patients in the conventional RBL group experienced a recurrence rate of 13.6%. The difference was statistically significant (P < 0.05).
BMC Surg · PMID 35725452 · Read it on PubMed ↗
Neves et al. 2023
3% polidocanol foam sclerotherapy versus hemorrhoidal artery ligation with recto anal repair in hemorrhoidal disease grades II-III: a randomized, pilot trial
Foam injection worked better, fewer complications.Randomised trialLow quality
46 people8 weeks
complete success was higher with sclerotherapy (91.7% vs 68.2%) and fewer complications (25% vs 68.2%)
- Who was studied
- patients with grade II-III hemorrhoids
- What they received
- polidocanol foam sclerotherapy (injection treatment)
- Compared with
- doppler-guided hemorrhoidal artery ligation with recto-anal repair (surgical procedure)
- Main outcome
- treatment success based on symptom and bleeding scores
- Quality
- This was a small pilot trial with only 46 patients, which limits confidence in the results.
- Limitations
- small pilot trial size
Taken word for word from the abstract
- n
Forty-six patients were allocated either to SP (n=22) or HAL-RAR (n=24).
- population
patients with HD grades II and III
- intervention
Polidocanol foam sclerotherapy (SP)
- comparator
doppler-guided hemorrhoidal artery ligation with recto-anal repair (HAL-RAR)
- primaryOutcome
Therapeutic success (Sodergren's and bleeding scores) was the primary outcome.
- result
Complete success was higher in the SP group (91.7% vs. 68.2%, p=0.045) and SP patients had less complications (25% vs. 68.2%, p=0.003).
- followUp
Efficacy and safety outcomes were evaluated during the 8 weeks after surgery or the final SP session.
Rev Esp Enferm Dig · PMID 35638762 · Read it on PubMed ↗
Nguyenhuy et al. 2022
Clinical Outcomes Following Rectal Artery Embolisation for the Treatment of Internal Haemorrhoids: A Systematic Review and Meta-Analysis
Less bleeding and pain after embolisation.Meta-analysisLow quality
381 people2022
bleeding scores, pain scores, and quality of life all improved after embolisation, though hemorrhoid grade slightly worsened and clinical success was only 82%
- Who was studied
- adults with internal hemorrhoids causing bleeding and other symptoms
- What they received
- rectal artery embolisation (blocking the blood supply to hemorrhoids)
- Main outcome
- bleeding score, pain score, quality of life score, and prolapse grade
- Quality
- it pools small, mostly uncontrolled studies without a comparison group, so improvement could be due to other factors rather than the procedure itself.
- Limitations
- studies lacked control groups, procedural details varied widely, and clinical efficacy was lower than technical success
Taken word for word from the abstract
- n
Thirteen eligible studies were identified including 381 patients.
- population
Haemorrhoidal disease (HD) is a common anorectal disorder which can substantially impair quality of life.
- intervention
Rectal artery embolisation (RAE) is a recently described technique for the management of HD
- primaryOutcome
Primary outcomes were: French bleeding score (FBS), Visual analogue scale (VAS) for pain, general quality of life (QoL) score, and the Goligher prolapse score (GPS).
- result
Rectal artery embolisation was associated with improvements in the FBS (mean difference [MD] 2.66; 95% confidence interval [CI] 2.10-3.23), VAS (MD 1.92; 95% CI 1.58-2.27) and QoL (MD 1.41; 95% CI 1.20-3.80), although the grade of internal haemerrhoids increased with uncertain clinical significance (MD 0.30; 95% CI 0.23-0.36).
- result
Technical success was achieved in almost all procedures (99%; 95% CI 94-100%) however clinical efficacy was lower (82%; 95% CI 73-89%).
Cardiovasc Intervent Radiol · PMID 35551442 · Read it on PubMed ↗
Gallo et al. 2022
A multicentre, open-label, single-arm phase II trial of the efficacy and safety of sclerotherapy using 3% polidocanol foam to treat second-degree haemorrhoids (SCLEROFOAM)
Stopped bleeding in most patients.Case seriesLow quality
183 people1 year
68.3% had bleeding completely stop at one week, rising to 95.6% success at one year after repeat sessions
- Who was studied
- patients with second-degree bleeding hemorrhoids
- What they received
- sclerotherapy injection with 3% polidocanol foam
- Compared with
- none (single-arm, before-after comparison)
- Main outcome
- complete stopping of hemorrhoid bleeding one week after treatment
- Quality
- This was a single-arm study with no comparison group, so it can't rule out that patients would have improved anyway.
- Limitations
- Open-label, single-arm design with no control group; some patients needed repeat sessions.
Taken word for word from the abstract
- n
There were 183 patients
- population
patients with 2nd-degree haemorrhoids
- intervention
The aim of the present study was to evaluate the efficacy and safety of 3% polidocanol foam for treating 2nd-degree haemorrhoids.
- comparator
A multicentre, open-label, single-arm, phase 2 trial
- primaryOutcome
The primary outcome was to establish the success rate after one sclerotherapy session in terms of complete resolution of bleeding episodes one week after the injection.
- result
Complete resolution of bleeding was reached in 125/183 patients (68.3%) at 1 week and the recurrence rate was 12% (15/125).
- result
The overall 1-year success rate was 95.6% (175/183).
Tech Coloproctol · PMID 35334004 · Read it on PubMed ↗
Salgueiro et al. 2022
Polidocanol foam sclerotherapy in the treatment of hemorrhoidal disease in patients with bleeding disorders: a multicenter, prospective, cohort study
Sclerotherapy worked equally well despite bleeding disorders.Prospective cohortLow quality
228 people1-year follow-up period
No significant differences between the two groups were observed for therapeutic success, recurrence, or complication rate.
- Who was studied
- Adults with symptomatic internal hemorrhoids (grades I-III), some with bleeding disorders and some without
- What they received
- Polidocanol foam sclerotherapy (PFS)
- Compared with
- Patients without bleeding disorders receiving the same sclerotherapy treatment
- Main outcome
- Treatment success and hemorrhoid recurrence over 1 year, plus safety complications
- Quality
- This was a non-randomized, uncontrolled cohort study comparing two patient subgroups rather than testing the treatment against a placebo or alternative, so it cannot prove the treatment itself works, only that it performs similarly in both groups.
- Limitations
- No control group without treatment; not randomized; subgroup comparison only
Taken word for word from the abstract
- n
We included 228 patients (group A: 155, group B: 73; male/female: 114/114; mean age: 59.4 ± 15.9 years).
- population
patients with (group B) and without (group A) BD, with symptomatic internal HD grades I-III over an 18-month period
- intervention
All patients were treated with PFS.
- comparator
compare the efficacy and safety of PFS in the treatment of HD in patients with and without BD
- primaryOutcome
Efficacy outcomes included therapeutic success and HD recurrence during a 1-year follow-up period.
- result
No significant differences between the two groups were observed for therapeutic success, recurrence, or complication rate.
- followUp
during a 1-year follow-up period
Tech Coloproctol · PMID 35217937 · Read it on PubMed ↗
Popovtsev et al. 2021
[Hemorrhoidal artery ligation without Doppler navigation in surgical treatment of hemorrhoidal disease]
No benefit of Doppler guidance over palpation.Randomised trialModerate qualityRelated question
120 people8.3±2.1 and 8.1±1.9 months
no significant difference between Doppler-guided and non-Doppler ligation in bleeding recurrence, prolapse, pain, or complications
- Who was studied
- patients with stage II-III hemorrhoids
- What they received
- hemorrhoidal artery ligation without Doppler ultrasound guidance (using palpation)
- Compared with
- hemorrhoidal artery ligation with Doppler ultrasound guidance
- Main outcome
- recurrence of bleeding, prolapse, and pain after surgery
- Quality
- it was a randomized trial but single-center with modest size and short follow-up of under a year.
- Limitations
- short follow-up period (about 8 months) and single-center design
Taken word for word from the abstract
- n
The study included 120 patients: group A - Doppler-guided ligation (n=60) and group B - ligation without ultrasound (n=60).
- population
surgical treatment of hemorrhoidal disease (GD) stage II-III
- intervention
group B - ligation without ultrasound (n=60)
- comparator
group A - Doppler-guided ligation (n=60)
- primaryOutcome
Intermittent bleeding was observed in 5 (8.3%) and 3 (5%) patients, respectively (p=0.71). Periodic hemorrhoid prolapse (GP) occurred in 6 (10%) and 4 (6.6%) respondents, respectively (p=0.74).
- result
There are no significant advantages of Doppler-guided HA ligation compared to palpation regarding incidence of hemorrhoid prolapse (p=0.74) and hemorrhoidal bleeding (p=0.71).
- followUp
Mean follow-up period was 8.3±2.1 and 8.1±1.9 months, respectively (p=0.96).
Khirurgiia (Mosk) · PMID 34941209 · Read it on PubMed ↗
Wang et al. 2021
Comparison of different embolic particles for superior rectal arterial embolization of chronic hemorrhoidal bleeding: gelfoam versus microparticle
Both particle types worked equally well.RetrospectiveLow qualityRelated question
41 peoplerange 6-15 months
no significant difference in bleeding-free rate between gelfoam (87.0%) and microparticle (88.9%) groups
- Who was studied
- patients with recurring internal hemorrhoid bleeding and chronic anemia
- What they received
- artery-blocking procedure (embolization) using coils plus gelfoam particles
- Compared with
- artery-blocking procedure (embolization) using coils plus microparticles
- Main outcome
- percentage of patients without further rectal bleeding
- Quality
- small retrospective study comparing two similar treatments without a no-treatment comparison, so it can't show whether embolization itself works, only that two particle types work similarly.
- Limitations
- retrospective design, small sample size, short follow-up
Taken word for word from the abstract
- n
A total of 41 patients (27 males) with symptomatic hemorrhoids were included in the study
- population
Patients with recurrent episodes of internal hemorrhoidal bleeding and chronic anemia treated by SRAE
- intervention
embolization with coils (2-3 mm) + gelfoam particles at 350-560 μm (Group A, n = 23)
- comparator
embolization with coils (2-3 mm) + microparticles at 300-500 μm (Group B, n = 18)
- primaryOutcome
preliminary clinical efficacy (percentage of patients without hematochezia)
- result
the preliminary clinical efficacy (87.0% vs 88.9%) showed no significant difference between the 2 groups (p = 0.098)
- followUp
follow-up period (range 6-15 months)
BMC Gastroenterol · PMID 34906095 · Read it on PubMed ↗
Song et al. 2022
Outcome of a modified Park's submucosal hemorrhoidectomy versus Milligan-Morgan for grade III-IV circumferential prolapsed hemorrhoids
No difference in bleeding, fewer recurrencesRandomised trialModerate qualityRelated question
186 people24 months
no significant group differences in postoperative bleeding, intraoperative blood loss, or development of anal stenosis, but the cumulative relapse-free rate was substantially higher in the MPSH group
- Who was studied
- patients with grade III or IV circumferential prolapsed hemorrhoids
- What they received
- modified Park's submucosal hemorrhoidectomy (MPSH)
- Compared with
- Milligan-Morgan hemorrhoidectomy (MMH)
- Main outcome
- postoperative pain, bleeding, and recurrence of hemorrhoids after surgery
- Quality
- It was a randomized trial with a reasonable sample size and long follow-up, but details on blinding and generalizability are limited.
- Limitations
- Additional clinical studies are needed to validate these conclusions.
Taken word for word from the abstract
- n
A total of 186 consecutive patients with grade III or IV CPH were enrolled.
- population
patients with grade III or IV CPH
- intervention
modified Park's submucosal over Milligan-Morgan hemorrhoidectomy (MMH)
- comparator
Milligan-Morgan hemorrhoidectomy (MMH)
- primaryOutcome
postoperative bleeding, intraoperative blood loss, or development of anal stenosis
- result
There were no significant group differences in postoperative bleeding, intraoperative blood loss, or development of anal stenosis (P > 0.05). However, the cumulative relapse-free rate was substantially higher in the MPSH group (P < 0.05).
Asian J Surg · PMID 34840045 · Read it on PubMed ↗
Feyen et al. 2022
Embolization of Hemorrhoidal Arteries: A Novel Endovascular Therapy Option for the Treatment of Hemorrhoidal Disease
Artery-blocking may reduce bleeding, unproven.Narrative reviewVery low qualityRelated question
size not given2022
embolization was described as safe and effective at controlling symptoms, particularly bleeding
- Who was studied
- people with hemorrhoids, including some who cannot have surgery
- What they received
- blocking the hemorrhoidal arteries (embolization)
- Compared with
- open surgery or no mention of a direct comparator
- Main outcome
- symptom control and safety, especially for bleeding
- Quality
- this is a narrative literature review without original patient data or a controlled comparison, so it can't reliably show the treatment works.
- Limitations
- not a systematic or statistical review; based on a selective PubMed search; no patient numbers or study details given
Taken word for word from the abstract
- population
patients with contraindications for open surgery
- intervention
embolization of the hemorrhoidal arteries
- comparator
Treatment options range from dietary measures to open surgery.
- primaryOutcome
allows efficient symptom control even in patients with contraindications for open surgery
- result
The treatment of bleeding hemorrhoids seems to be particularly effective.
- result
Embolization of hemorrhoidal arteries is a safe treatment
Rofo · PMID 34794188 · Read it on PubMed ↗
Huang et al. 2021
A NEW MIXED SURGICAL TREATMENT FOR GRADES III AND IV HEMORRHOIDS: MODIFIED SELECTIVE HEMORRHOIDECTOMY COMBINED WITH COMPLETE ANAL EPITHELIAL RETENTION
Mixed surgical results, no clear winner.Randomised trialModerate qualityRelated question
200 peoplesix months
The new technique caused more bleeding and pain during surgery, but led to less anal stenosis, a larger anal canal diameter, better continence scores, no relapses at 6 months (vs 4 in the other group), and higher patient satisfaction, while operation time was longer than the standard surgery.
- Who was studied
- adults with grade III and IV hemorrhoids
- What they received
- modified tissue-selecting stapler surgery with complete anal canal epithelium preservation
- Compared with
- Milligan-Morgan hemorrhoidectomy
- Main outcome
- differences in surgical outcomes between the two techniques, including bleeding, pain, anal stenosis, incontinence and recurrence
- Quality
- It was a randomized trial, but nearly a third of enrolled patients were missing from the final analysis and follow-up was only six months, which weakens confidence in the findings.
- Limitations
- 31 of 200 enrolled patients were not included in the final analysis (loss unexplained), follow-up was limited to six months, and the abstract does not mention blinding of outcome assessors.
Taken word for word from the abstract
- population
enrolling 200 patients with grade III and IV hemorrhoids
- intervention
the modified tissue-selecting therapy stapler combined with complete anal canal preservation surgery
- comparator
The control received Milligan-Morgan surgery
- n
enrolling 200 patients with grade III and IV hemorrhoids
- primaryOutcome
All patients were followed for six months to evaluate the treatment differences.
- result
The average operation time of the control group was significantly lower than that of the observation, while the bleeding volume was significantly lower in control group.
- result
Digital incidence of anal stenosis in the observation group was significantly lower than in control; the same occurred with residual anal margins.
- result
In final six months follow-up, the observation group did not experience any relapse and four cases were found among controls.
- followUp
All patients were followed for six months to evaluate the treatment differences.
Arq Bras Cir Dig · PMID 34669884 · Read it on PubMed ↗
Porwal et al. 2021
Polyherbal formulation Anoac‑H suppresses the expression of RANTES and VEGF for the management of bleeding hemorrhoids and fistula
Reduced inflammation markers in tissue samples.Laboratory studyVery low qualityRelated question
size not given2021
Anoac-H reduced cell migration and lowered RANTES and VEGF expression and inflammation in treated tissues compared to untreated ones
- Who was studied
- fibroblast and immune cells (RAW 264.7), and human hemorrhoid and fistula tissue samples
- What they received
- Anoac-H polyherbal formulation
- Compared with
- untreated cells and tissues
- Main outcome
- expression of RANTES and VEGF proteins linked to inflammation and blood vessel growth
- Quality
- This is a laboratory study on cells and tissue samples, not a clinical trial measuring bleeding or patient outcomes.
- Limitations
- Abstract does not report number of patients or tissue samples, no clinical bleeding outcome measured, findings based on in vitro and ex vivo tissue analysis only.
Taken word for word from the abstract
- population
this formulation reduces the migration of mesenchymal (fibroblasts) and immune (RAW 264.7) cells
- population
treated human hemorrhoid and fistula tissues as compared to untreated ones
- intervention
polyherbal formulation Anoac‑H
- comparator
treated human hemorrhoid and fistula tissues as compared to untreated ones
- primaryOutcome
Anoac‑H suppresses the expression of regulated upon activation, normal T cell expressed and presumably secreted (RANTES) and VEGF in fibroblasts and macrophages
- result
inflammation, as well as the expression of RANTES and VEGF, were significantly reduced in treated human hemorrhoid and fistula tissues as compared to untreated ones, confirming the in vitro results
Mol Med Rep · PMID 34414451 · Read it on PubMed ↗
Trigui et al. 2022
Laser utility in the treatment of hemorrhoidal pathology: a review of literature
Laser treatment less painful, less bleeding than surgerySystematic reviewLow qualityRelated question
1,179 people2022
Laser treatment showed less pain, less bleeding, shorter operative time, and higher satisfaction than surgery
- Who was studied
- adults with hemorrhoids, ages 18 to 74
- What they received
- laser treatment (HeLP or LHP procedures)
- Compared with
- surgical treatment of hemorrhoids
- Main outcome
- postoperative pain, disease downgrading, bleeding, satisfaction, and operative duration
- Quality
- This review pooled mostly small comparative studies without statistical meta-analysis and excluded retrospective data, so the evidence is not strong enough to be fully confident.
- Limitations
- Retrospective studies and case reports were excluded; abstract notes 'more rigorous studies will be needed to better evaluate this technique'
Taken word for word from the abstract
- n
The total number of patients was 1179 including 1059 patients treated with laser and 120 treated surgically within the context of comparative studies.
- population
The age of the patients varies between 18 and 74 years old.
- intervention
We selected 11 studies both techniques HeLP (hemorrhoid laser procedure) and LHP (laser hemorrhoidoplasty procedure).
- comparator
HeLP laser treatment was significantly superior to surgical treatment
- primaryOutcome
postoperative pain (p < 0.001), hemorrhoidal disease downgrading (p < 0.001), and postoperative satisfaction (p < 0.001)
- result
LHP laser treatment was significantly superior to surgical treatment in terms of operative duration (p < 0.00001), intraoperative bleeding (p < 0.00001), postoperative pain at H12 and H24 (p < 0.00001 and p = 0.0003), and postoperative bleeding rate (p < 0.001).
Lasers Med Sci · PMID 34331606 · Read it on PubMed ↗
Wlodarczyk et al. 2021
LigaSure™ haemorrhoidectomy and the risk of postoperative bleeding
No difference in post-surgery bleeding risk.RetrospectiveLow qualityRelated question
127 people30 days
similar rates of postoperative bleeding visits between LigaSure and Ferguson groups (20% vs. 11%, not statistically significant), and LigaSure use was not independently associated with bleeding risk
- Who was studied
- patients who had surgery to remove hemorrhoids
- What they received
- LigaSure (electro-surgical device) hemorrhoidectomy
- Compared with
- Ferguson (closed) hemorrhoidectomy
- Main outcome
- rate of postoperative bleeding (ER visits, transfusions, readmissions within 30 days)
- Quality
- This was a small retrospective single-hospital study, so it can't reliably rule out differences between the two surgery types.
- Limitations
- Retrospective cohort design, single academic hospital, relatively small sample size
Taken word for word from the abstract
- n
Sixty-one FH and 66 LH patients were identified.
- population
evaluating patients who received FH or LH
- intervention
LigaSure™ is an electro-surgical device that has increasingly been utilized in haemorrhoid surgery
- comparator
Ferguson (closed) haemorrhoidectomy (FH)
- primaryOutcome
postoperative emergency department visit for pain or bleeding within 30 days and resulting transfusion requirement, and rates of readmission and interventions within 30 days
- result
The LH group and FH group had similar rates of postoperative emergency department visits (29% vs. 23%, P = 0.454), as well as visits for bleeding (20% vs. 11%, P = 0.204).
- result
Use of LH was not independently associated with postoperative bleeding risk (OR 1.89, 95% CI 0.70-5.11).
Colorectal Dis · PMID 34252247 · Read it on PubMed ↗
Palumbo et al. 2021
Colour Doppler-guided Haemorrhoidal Artery Ligation: a possible evolution of Transanal Haemorrhoidal Dearterialisation
New technique fewer recurrences, same bleeding control.RetrospectiveLow qualityRelated question
408 peopleone-year follow-up
no significant differences in pain, bleeding, or satisfaction between the two techniques, but recurrence was significantly higher with the standard method
- Who was studied
- patients with grade III-IV haemorrhoids
- What they received
- Colour Doppler-Guided Haemorrhoidal Artery Ligation (ligating the arteries under direct ultrasound vision)
- Compared with
- standard Doppler-Guided Haemorrhoidal Artery Ligation
- Main outcome
- post-operative pain, early complications (including bleeding), patient satisfaction, and recurrence rate
- Quality
- This was a non-randomized comparison of two surgical techniques without blinding, so differences could be due to bias rather than the treatment itself.
- Limitations
- No randomization or blinding described; comparison focuses on surgical technique differences rather than directly explaining bleeding mechanism.
Taken word for word from the abstract
- n
183 patients treated with standard Doppler-Guided Haemorrhoidal Artery Ligation were statistically compared with 225 patients dealt with Colour Doppler-Guided Haemorrhoidal Artery Ligation.
- population
patients with III-IV grade haemorrhoids
- intervention
Colour Doppler-Guided Haemorrhoidal Artery Ligation
- comparator
standard Doppler-Guided Haemorrhoidal Artery Ligation
- primaryOutcome
No significant differences between the two groups, in terms of post-operative pain, early complications (bleeding, urinary retention, incontinence) or patient satisfaction, were demonstrated.
- result
Recurrence rate was significantly higher in patients treated with stan-dard DG-HAL.
- followUp
No late complications (after one-year follow-up) were registered in both groups.
Clin Ter · PMID 34247216 · Read it on PubMed ↗
Stecca et al. 2021
Superior Rectal Artery Embolization for Symptomatic Grades 2 and 3 Hemorrhoidal Disease: 6-Month Follow-up among 43 Patients
Less bleeding, better quality of life.Prospective cohortLow quality
43 people6 months
bleeding score significantly reduced in Grade 3 patients, and quality of life improved significantly in both groups
- Who was studied
- adults with symptomatic Grade 2 or 3 hemorrhoids
- What they received
- blocking the blood supply to hemorrhoids via superior rectal artery embolization
- Compared with
- no comparison group; before-and-after same patients
- Main outcome
- change in bleeding score, prolapse, pain, and quality of life
- Quality
- this was a small single-group study without a comparison group, so it can't rule out improvement happening on its own.
- Limitations
- no control group, small sample size, only 6 months of follow-up
Taken word for word from the abstract
- n
43 patients (24 men and 19 women; mean age, 52 years [18-77 years])
- population
symptomatic Grades 2 and 3 hemorrhoidal disease
- intervention
superior rectal artery embolization
- comparator
Clinical success was assessed at 7 days, 1 month, and 6 months of follow-up by updating the clinical scores.
- primaryOutcome
anamnestic questionnaire and disease scores, including French bleeding, Goligher prolapse, visual analog scale for pain, and quality of life
- result
The reduction in the French bleeding score (global and single entity) in Grade 3 prolapse was statistically significant (P = .001). Improvement in the quality of life was significant in both groups (P < .05).
J Vasc Interv Radiol · PMID 34166805 · Read it on PubMed ↗
Rabelo et al. 2021
Benefits of flavonoid and metronidazole use after excisional hemorrhoidectomy: a randomized double-blind clinical trial
Flavonoids cut post-surgery pain and bleeding.Randomised trialLow qualityRelated question
68 people30 days
Flavonoids reduced pain in all periods and reduced bleeding between week 1 and week 2 after surgery; combining flavonoids with metronidazole helped pain even more in the first two weeks
- Who was studied
- patients who had surgical removal of hemorrhoids (excisional hemorrhoidectomy)
- What they received
- flavonoids and/or metronidazole taken after surgery
- Compared with
- placebo
- Main outcome
- pain, bleeding, swelling, itching and straining after surgery
- Quality
- Small study with only 17 patients per group, so the results may not be reliable.
- Limitations
- Small sample size (17 per group); studies post-surgical bleeding rather than bleeding from untreated hemorrhoids.
Taken word for word from the abstract
- n
Sixty-eight patients underwent excisional hemorrhoidectomy and were randomized into 4 groups of 17 patients each
- population
patients undergoing excisional hemorrhoidectomy
- intervention
receive double-placebo (G1), metronidazole plus placebo (G2), flavonoids plus placebo (G3) or metronidazole plus flavonoids (G4) in the postoperative period
- comparator
double-placebo (G1)
- primaryOutcome
Postoperative pain, bleeding, edema, pruritus and tenesmus were evaluated
- result
Flavonoid use was also associated with decreased bleeding (G3, p = 0.031 and G4, p = 0.016) between the first and second postoperative weeks
- result
There was less severe pain in all postoperative periods in the groups using flavonoids (G3 and G4, both p < 0.0001)
Tech Coloproctol · PMID 34057643 · Read it on PubMed ↗
Sobrado et al. 2021
A NEW APPROACH FOR HEMORRHOID DISEASE: SELECTIVE DEARTERIALIZATION AND MUCOPEXY WITHOUT DOPPLER GUIDANCE
Bleeding and prolapse controlled after surgery.Case seriesLow quality
20 people13 months
all patients achieved control of prolapse and bleeding, with some postoperative complications and no recurrences after follow-up
- Who was studied
- patients with grade II and III hemorrhoids
- What they received
- selective dearterialization and mucopexy of the symptomatic hemorrhoid without Doppler guidance
- Compared with
- none (single-arm case series)
- Main outcome
- control of prolapse and bleeding, postoperative complications, recurrence
- Quality
- small uncontrolled case series of only 20 patients with no comparison group, so the result could be due to natural healing or bias rather than the procedure.
- Limitations
- small sample size, no control group, single-arm design
Taken word for word from the abstract
- n
Twenty consecutive patients with grade II and III hemorrhoids
- population
Twenty consecutive patients with grade II and III hemorrhoids were treated with this new approach
- intervention
selective dearterialization and mucopexy at the symptomatic hemorrhoid only, without Doppler guidance
- comparator
METHODS: Twenty consecutive patients with grade II and III hemorrhoids were treated with this new approach and were evaluated for postoperative complications and recurrence.
- primaryOutcome
evaluate if selective dearterialization and mucopexy at the symptomatic hemorrhoid only, without Doppler guidance, achieves adequate control of the prolapse and bleeding
- result
Control of prolapse and bleeding was achieved in all patients (n=20).
- followUp
After a mean follow-up of 13 months no recurrences were diagnosed.
Arq Bras Cir Dig · PMID 34008704 · Read it on PubMed ↗
Makris et al. 2021
Catheter-Directed Hemorrhoidal Dearterialization Technique for the Management of Hemorrhoids: A Meta-Analysis of the Clinical Evidence
Less bleeding after artery-blocking procedure.Meta-analysisLow quality
362 people12.1 months
Bleeding scores significantly improved after treatment, with 78.9% average clinical success, but rebleeding was more common with coils alone (21.5%) than coils plus particles (10.05%)
- Who was studied
- patients with bleeding hemorrhoids (grades I-III, chronic bleeding)
- What they received
- catheter-directed hemorrhoidal artery embolization (dearterialization), with coils alone or coils plus particles
- Compared with
- before vs after treatment comparison; also coils-only vs coils-and-particles subgroups
- Main outcome
- reduction in bleeding score and clinical success/rebleeding after the procedure
- Quality
- This pools small, mostly uncontrolled studies without a true comparison group, so the benefit seen could be due to the procedure itself or to other factors.
- Limitations
- The authors call this 'preliminary clinical evidence' and say standardization of technique and higher level evidence are still needed to compare with surgical options.
Taken word for word from the abstract
- n
Fourteen studies (n = 362) were identified.
- population
patients with grades I-III hemorrhoids and chronic bleeding
- intervention
catheter-directed hemorrhoidal dearterialization technique for the management of hemorrhoidal bleeding
- comparator
when the coils-only group was compared with the coils and particles group
- primaryOutcome
A statistically significant reduction in the french bleeding score before and after embolization was noted (P = .004).
- result
the average rebleeding rate was 21.5% (n = 111; SD, 18.2; range, 0%-44%) versus 10.05% (N = 108; SD, 4.8; range, 5%-15.7%), respectively (P < .0001)
- result
The mean technical success was 97.8% (SD, 3.5), and the mean clinical success was 78.9% (SD, 10.5).
- limitations
The current preliminary clinical evidence suggests that catheter-directed hemorrhoidal dearterialization is an effective and safe procedure
- followUp
The mean maximum follow-up duration was 12.1 months
J Vasc Interv Radiol · PMID 33971251 · Read it on PubMed ↗
Karkalemis et al. 2021
Safety and effectiveness of hemorrhoidal artery ligation using the HAL-RAR technique for hemorrhoidal disease
Most patients improved after surgery.RetrospectiveLow qualityRelated question
105 people12 months
most patients had symptoms resolve, with low complication and recurrence rates at 12 months
- Who was studied
- adults with grade II (not helped by non-surgical treatment), III, or IV hemorrhoids
- What they received
- hemorrhoidal artery ligation with rectoanal repair (HAL-RAR) surgery
- Compared with
- none - single group followed over time
- Main outcome
- symptom resolution, pain, complications, and recurrence after surgery
- Quality
- this was a retrospective study of one treatment with no comparison group, so it can't show whether another approach would have worked as well or better.
- Limitations
- retrospective design, no control group, and the authors note long-term follow-up is lacking
Taken word for word from the abstract
- n
A total of 105 patients (60 men, 45 women) underwent HAL-RAR.
- population
patients who underwent HAL-RAR for grade II, resistant to conservative treatment, and grades III and IV hemorrhoidal disease
- intervention
hemorrhoidal artery ligation with rectoanal repair (HAL-RAR)
- comparator
Retrospective study from January 2010 to November 2019 of patients who underwent HAL-RAR
- primaryOutcome
Demographics, degree of disease, hospital stay, postoperative pain, complications, and recurrence were recorded.
- result
At 12 months, 92.4% of patients experienced complete resolution of symptoms, 2 patients intermittent bleeding, and 2 recurrence.
- limitations
Long-term follow-up is lacking and would better establish the results of this technique.
Langenbecks Arch Surg · PMID 33959805 · Read it on PubMed ↗
Godeberge et al. 2021
Micronized purified flavonoid fraction in the treatment of hemorrhoidal disease
Less bleeding and pain, faster recovery.Narrative reviewLow quality
size not given2021
MPFF reduced symptoms like bleeding and pain, shortened hospital stay, and may prevent recurrence
- Who was studied
- adults with hemorrhoidal disease, including those having surgery
- What they received
- micronized purified flavonoid fraction (MPFF), a venoactive drug
- Compared with
- standard care without MPFF (used as postoperative adjunct)
- Main outcome
- hemorrhoid symptoms such as bleeding, pain, discomfort, discharge, itching, and postoperative recovery measures
- Quality
- This is a narrative review summarizing prior studies without presenting numbers, statistics, or study-by-study details, so it's hard to judge how strong the evidence really is.
- Limitations
- The abstract gives no information on study designs, sample sizes, statistical results, or how studies were selected, so the strength and consistency of evidence can't be assessed.
Taken word for word from the abstract
- population
Hemorrhoidal disease (HD) is common in adults.
- population
In patients undergoing surgery, postoperative adjunct MPFF consistently reduces pain, bleeding duration and use of analgesia.
- intervention
Venoactive drugs such as micronized purified flavonoid fraction (MPFF) are widely used
- comparator
postoperative adjunct MPFF consistently reduces pain, bleeding duration and use of analgesia.
- primaryOutcome
In acute HD, MPFF can reduce HD symptoms such as bleeding, pain, anal discomfort, anal discharge and pruritus.
- result
MPFF reduces the duration of hospital stay following surgery, facilitating a return to normal activity and improving quality of life.
- result
MPFF may also prevent HD recurrence.
J Comp Eff Res · PMID 33928786 · Read it on PubMed ↗
Landolfi et al. 2022
Long-Term Outcomes of Sectorial Longitudinal Augmented Prolapsectomy for Asymmetric Muco-hemorrhoidal Prolapse: An Observational Study of 433 Consecutive Patients
Surgery reduced recurrence but risked bleeding.RetrospectiveLow qualityRelated question
433 people2022
low rates of symptom recurrence and prolapse recurrence, but some patients needed emergency reoperation for bleeding after surgery
- Who was studied
- patients with grade III-IV hemorrhoids and asymmetric mucosal prolapse
- What they received
- sectorial longitudinal augmented prolapsectomy (SLAP) surgery, one or two columns
- Compared with
- before vs after surgery (no control group)
- Main outcome
- recurrence of hemorrhoid symptoms, prolapse, and rectal narrowing
- Quality
- This was a retrospective observational study without a comparison group, so it cannot reliably prove the surgery caused the improvement.
- Limitations
- Retrospective design, no control/comparator group, and some patients required emergency surgery for post-operative bleeding.
Taken word for word from the abstract
- n
We enrolled 433 patients (277 SLAP1 and 156 SLAP2).
- population
Patients affected by III-IV-degree symptomatic HD with asymmetric mucosal prolapse undergone SLAP
- intervention
sectorial longitudinal augmented prolapsectomy (SLAP), a technique dedicated to asymmetric prolapse
- comparator
The severity of hemorrhoid symptoms and fecal continence status were evaluated before and after surgery.
- primaryOutcome
Mean outcome was evaluation of medium-long-term outcomes as the occurrence of recurrence and anal or rectal stenosis.
- result
Hemorrhoidal symptoms recurrence was reported in 9 patients undergone SLAP1 and 4 patients undergone SLAP2, while prolapse recurrence occurred, respectively, in 4 and 2 patients.
- result
An emergency reintervention for postoperative bleeding occurred in 13 cases undergone SLAP1 and in 5 patients treated with SLAP2.
Surg Innov · PMID 33830810 · Read it on PubMed ↗
Mehdi et al. 2021
Efficacy and safety of Hemoheal cream in patients with hemorrhoids: a randomized double-blind placebo controlled clinical trial
Less bleeding and pain with creamRandomised trialLow quality
52 people3 weeks
After 3 weeks, bleeding, anal irritation, pain and swelling sense were significantly improved with the cream compared to placebo, but anal itching and defecation discomfort were not significantly different
- Who was studied
- patients with symptomatic hemorrhoids
- What they received
- Hemoheal cream (herbal preparation with Allium ampeloprasum, Commiphora mukul, Sesamum indicum oil)
- Compared with
- placebo cream
- Main outcome
- severity of anal irritation, bleeding, itching, pain, defecation discomfort, swelling, and overall subjective improvement
- Quality
- Small trial of only 52 patients with short follow-up, so the results may not be reliable or lasting.
- Limitations
- Small sample size, short 3-week duration, one adverse event reported (rash at application site)
Taken word for word from the abstract
- n
Fifty-two patients with symptomatic hemorrhoids were randomized to receive hemoheal cream or placebo for 3 weeks.
- population
Fifty-two patients with symptomatic hemorrhoids
- intervention
Hemoheal cream consists of aqueous extract of Allium ampeloprasum L., Commiphora mukul (Hook. Ex Stocks) Engl and the oil of Sesamum indicum L.
- comparator
receive hemoheal cream or placebo for 3 weeks
- primaryOutcome
evaluated before and after the intervention in terms of the severity of anal irritation, bleeding, anal itching, pain, defecation discomfort and swelling sense, and overall subjective improvement (%)
- result
after 3 weeks of treatment, distribution of anal irritation, bleeding, pain as well as swelling sense were significantly different (P < 0.05), while the analysis showed no significant differences between two groups for anal itching and defecation discomfort (P > 0.05)
J Tradit Chin Med · PMID 33825411 · Read it on PubMed ↗
Yu et al. 2021
Clinical study of use of large C suture in procedure for prolapse and hemorrhoids for treatment of mixed hemorrhoids
Low bleeding after this surgery technique.RetrospectiveLow qualityRelated question
126 people6 months
none of the patients developed stricture at the join, but two patients had bleeding from it afterward
- Who was studied
- patients with grade III or IV mixed hemorrhoids
- What they received
- a large C suture used during a hemorrhoid surgery called PPH (procedure for prolapse and hemorrhoids)
- Compared with
- no comparison group (single-arm retrospective study)
- Main outcome
- rates of narrowing of the surgical join and bleeding from it after surgery
- Quality
- This was a retrospective study of one group of patients with no comparison group, so it can't show whether this technique works better than other methods.
- Limitations
- Retrospective design, no control group, and it studies a surgical technique's complications rather than why hemorrhoids bleed or how to stop that bleeding directly.
Taken word for word from the abstract
- n
The study population comprised 126 patients
- population
Patients with mixed hemorrhoids (grade III or IV)
- intervention
a large C suture during PPH
- comparator
this retrospective study
- primaryOutcome
The incidences of anastomotic stenosis and anastomotic hemorrhage after the operation were observed.
- result
None of the patients with mixed hemorrhoids developed anastomotic stenosis, although two patients developed secondary anastomotic bleeding.
J Int Med Res · PMID 33682485 · Read it on PubMed ↗
Jeong et al. 2021
Analysis of risk factors for delayed bleeding after semi-closed hemorrhoidectomy
Identifies risk factors for bleeding after surgery.RetrospectiveLow qualityRelated question
1,645 people2021
1.5% of patients had delayed bleeding; male sex, drinking history, more than four hemorrhoid piles, and laxative use raised the risk
- Who was studied
- patients with symptomatic grade II to IV hemorrhoids undergoing surgery
- What they received
- semi-closed hemorrhoidectomy with submucosal feeding vessel ligation
- Compared with
- none (risk factor analysis within same procedure group)
- Main outcome
- delayed bleeding after hemorrhoid surgery
- Quality
- This is a retrospective study of one surgical technique without a comparison group, so it can identify risk factors but not prove what prevents bleeding.
- Limitations
- Retrospective design, single center, no comparator group, and does not directly address what stops bleeding once it occurs.
Taken word for word from the abstract
- n
This retrospective study enrolled a total of 1645 consecutive patients with symptomatic grade II to IV hemorrhoids who underwent a semi-closed procedure
- population
1645 consecutive patients with symptomatic grade II to IV hemorrhoids who underwent a semi-closed procedure at the Seoul Songdo Hospital
- intervention
All patients underwent a semi-closed procedure with submucosal feeding vessel ligation
- primaryOutcome
The aim of this study was to determine the incidence of delayed post-hemorrhoidectomy bleeding (DPHB) after hemorrhoidectomy using a semi-closed procedure.
- result
Multivariate analysis showed that male sex, drinking history, more than four hemorrhoid piles, and laxative agents were independent risk factors for DPHB.
- comparator
This retrospective study enrolled a total of 1645 consecutive patients with symptomatic grade II to IV hemorrhoids who underwent a semi-closed procedure
Int J Colorectal Dis · PMID 33661360 · Read it on PubMed ↗
De Schepper et al. 2021
Belgian consensus guideline on the management of hemorrhoidal disease
Guideline, not direct bleeding evidence.GuidelineLow qualityRelated question
size not given2021
treatment should be matched to severity; conventional hemorrhoidectomy was said to be the most effective option overall
- Who was studied
- people with hemorrhoids
- What they received
- fiber supplements, venotropic drugs, infrared coagulation, rubber band ligation, or surgery
- Compared with
- different treatments compared to each other across severity grades
- Main outcome
- control of hemorrhoid symptoms and prolapse
- Quality
- this is an expert consensus guideline summarizing existing literature rather than a new study with its own data on bleeding.
- Limitations
- abstract does not describe the studies underlying the recommendations, their quality, or specific results for bleeding control
Taken word for word from the abstract
- population
Hemorrhoidal disease is a common problem that arises when hemorrhoidal structures become engorged and/or prolapse through the anal canal.
- intervention
conservative treatment should consist of fiber supplements and can include a short course of venotropics. Instrumental treatment can be added case by case : infrared coagulation or rubber band ligation when prolapse is more prominent. For prolapsing hemorrhoids, surgery can be indicated for refractory cases.
- comparator
Every treatment for symptomatic hemorrhoids should be tailored to patient profile and expectations.
- primaryOutcome
symptoms can arise
- result
Conventional hemorrhoidectomy is the most efficacious intervention for all grades of hemorrhoids and is the only choice for non-reducible prolapsing hemorrhoids.
Acta Gastroenterol Belg · PMID 33639701 · Read it on PubMed ↗
Puia et al. 2021
Stapled Hemorrhoidopexy: Technique and Long Term Results
Few complications, high patient satisfaction.Case seriesLow qualityRelated question
35 people6 (1-9) years
A single patient needed reoperation for a staple line bleeding, two patients had a thrombosis of internal hemorrhoids and in one patient a small prolapse was diagnosed at 3 months follow-up; global satisfaction rate was 94%.
- Who was studied
- patients with symptomatic second- and third-degree hemorrhoids
- What they received
- stapled hemorrhoidopexy (Longo operation) using a PPH03 stapler
- Quality
- It is a small retrospective single-arm case series with no comparison group, so the results can't be fully trusted.
- Limitations
- Retrospective data collection, small sample of 35 patients, no comparator group.
Taken word for word from the abstract
- n
The data of 35 patients with symptomatic second- and third-degree hemorrhoids
- population
35 patients with symptomatic second- and third-degree hemorrhoids
- intervention
stapled hemorrhoidopexy using a PPH03 stapler
- result
A single patient needed reoperation for a staple line bleeding, two patients had a thrombosis of internal hemorrhoids and in one patient a small prolapse was diagnosed at 3 months follow-up
- result
Global satisfaction rate was 94%.
- followUp
Patients were followed-up for 6 (1-9) years.
Chirurgia (Bucur) · PMID 33638331 · Read it on PubMed ↗
Studniarek et al. 2021
Evaluation of a Minimally Invasive Bipolar Coagulation System for the Treatment of Grade I and II Internal Hemorrhoids
Fewer symptoms, including bleeding, after treatment.Case seriesLow quality
35 people14 days
symptom scores dropped from an average of 5.5 to 1.4 after treatment, with low pain levels
- Who was studied
- adults with chronic symptomatic grade I and II internal hemorrhoids who failed conservative treatment
- What they received
- bipolar coagulation (hemorrhoid energy therapy) applied in a single office visit
- Compared with
- none (no comparison group; pre- vs post-treatment scores)
- Main outcome
- change in hemorrhoid symptom score and safety/complications
- Quality
- This was a small, single-center study with no comparison group, so it can't show whether the improvement was due to the treatment itself.
- Limitations
- lack of comparative groups, single-center design, and small cohort of patients
Taken word for word from the abstract
- n
A total of 35 patients were enrolled.
- population
Patients over the age of 18 years with chronic, symptomatic grade I and II internal hemorrhoids who failed 2 weeks of conservative therapy
- intervention
Hemorrhoid energy therapy was administered in clinic, and 2 postprocedure visits were completed.
- comparator
The limitations include lack of comparative groups, single-center design, and small cohort of patients.
- primaryOutcome
The primary end point was to evaluate the effect of hemorrhoid energy therapy on hemorrhoid symptoms and its safety.
- result
After the procedure, patient hemorrhoid symptom scores decreased from mean 5.5 to 1.4.
- followUp
decreased to <1.0 after 14 days
Dis Colon Rectum · PMID 33496474 · Read it on PubMed ↗
Lisi et al. 2021
Sclerotherapy with 3% polidocanol foam for third- and fourth-degree hemorrhoids as "bridge treatment" during the COVID-19 pandemic in Italy
Bleeding and itching stopped.Case seriesVery low quality
10 people2021
all patients had resolution of bleeding and pruritus with low pain scores
- Who was studied
- patients with third- and fourth-degree hemorrhoids
- What they received
- sclerotherapy injection with 3% polidocanol foam
- Compared with
- no comparator, used as a temporary bridge treatment before surgery
- Main outcome
- resolution of hemorrhoid bleeding and itching
- Quality
- This was a tiny, uncontrolled case series of only 10 patients with no comparison group, so it can't reliably show the treatment caused the improvement.
- Limitations
- Very small sample size, no control group, described as preliminary experience, and performed only as an interim measure during pandemic restrictions.
Taken word for word from the abstract
- n
We decided to treated 10 urgent cases
- population
III- and IV-degree hemorrhoids
- intervention
3% polidocanol foam
- comparator
"bridge treatment"
- primaryOutcome
resolution of bleeding and pruritus
- result
all patients had resolution of bleeding and pruritus with a mean VAS of 1 (range, 0-1)
Int J Colorectal Dis · PMID 33452908 · Read it on PubMed ↗
Giamundo et al. 2022
Doppler-guided hemorrhoidal dearterialization with laser (HeLP): indications and clinical outcome in the long-term. Results of a multicenter trial
Bleeding and symptoms improved long-term.Prospective cohortLow quality
284 people2-year
89.9% of patients had resolution of symptoms, with significant improvement in bleeding, pain, and quality of life
- Who was studied
- patients with hemorrhoids suffering from bleeding, pain and recurrent symptoms
- What they received
- Doppler-guided laser closure of the arteries feeding the hemorrhoids (HeLP procedure)
- Compared with
- none (before-after comparison within same patients)
- Main outcome
- resolution of hemorrhoid symptoms (including bleeding) at 2 years
- Quality
- This was a single-arm study without a comparison group, so improvement cannot be clearly attributed to the laser procedure itself.
- Limitations
- No control group; some patients lost to follow-up; failure more common in constipated patients and those with higher-grade hemorrhoids.
Taken word for word from the abstract
- n
Two-hundred-eighty-four patients (183 males, 101 females; mean age: 47.5 years) were included in the trial
- population
Primary endpoint was resolution of symptoms
- intervention
Doppler-guided hemorrhoidal laser procedure consists of sutureless closure of terminal branches of the superior hemorrhoidal artery by laser energy
- comparator
Clinical results of patients treated with this procedure were analyzed at the completion of 2-year follow-up
- primaryOutcome
Primary endpoint was resolution of symptoms
- result
Analysis of 276 patients who completed the 2-year follow-up showed an overall resolution of symptoms in 89.9% (248/276) of patients. Statistically significant improvement of quality of life, pain reduction, bleeding and frequency of acute symptoms were reported.
Surg Endosc · PMID 33415419 · Read it on PubMed ↗
Drissi et al. 2021
Evaluation of the efficacy and morbidity of radiofrequency thermocoagulation in the treatment of hemorrhoidal disease
Mostly good results, some complications.RetrospectiveLow qualityRelated question
74 people3 months
more than 93% had satisfactory anatomical and functional results at 3 months, but 24.3% had a postoperative complication and 2.7% needed repeat surgery
- Who was studied
- patients with grade II to IV hemorrhoidal disease (mostly grade III)
- What they received
- radiofrequency thermocoagulation of hemorrhoids
- Compared with
- none (single-group before/after outcomes)
- Main outcome
- anatomical and functional result and postoperative complications at 3 months
- Quality
- This was a retrospective study of one group with no comparison treatment, so it's hard to know how much benefit came from the procedure itself.
- Limitations
- Retrospective, single-arm design with no control group; only short follow-up of three months reported.
Taken word for word from the abstract
- population
patients undergoing radiofrequency thermocoagulation for grade II to IV hemorrhoidal disease between December 2017 and December 2019
- intervention
radiofrequency thermocoagulation of hemorrhoids
- n
Seventy-four patients, with a mean age of 53 years, underwent operation during the study period
- primaryOutcome
the anatomical and functional result was satisfactory in more than 93% of patients
- result
At three months following surgery, the anatomical and functional result was satisfactory in more than 93% of patients.
- result
Eighteen (24.3%) patients developed a postoperative complication within 30 days, of whom two (2.7%) required revisional surgery
- comparator
Data from successive patients undergoing radiofrequency thermocoagulation for grade II to IV hemorrhoidal disease between December 2017 and December 2019 were retrospectively collated.
J Visc Surg · PMID 33199263 · Read it on PubMed ↗
Didelot et al. 2021
Radiofrequency thermocoagulation of haemorrhoidal bundles, an alternative technique for the management of internal haemorrhoids
Bleeding and prolapse much reduced.Case seriesLow quality
39 people15 months
bleeding dropped from 7/10 to 1/10 and stopped completely in 62% of patients; prolapse grade improved
- Who was studied
- patients with internal hemorrhoids
- What they received
- radiofrequency thermocoagulation (RFT) of hemorrhoidal tissue
- Compared with
- before-and-after comparison (no control group)
- Main outcome
- bleeding severity and prolapse grade
- Quality
- This is a small, uncontrolled study of only 39 patients with no comparison group, so improvement could be due to other factors.
- Limitations
- No control group; small sample size; single-center experience.
Taken word for word from the abstract
- n
39 patients (26 males, mean age 51 [22-77]) were interviewed after an RFT intervention
- population
42 outpatients were operated for internal haemorrhoids using RFT
- intervention
Radiofrequency thermocoagulation (RFT)
- comparator
Assessment was performed prior to the intervention and during follow-up
- primaryOutcome
bleeding, improvement, and satisfaction using a verbal analogical scale
- result
bleeding drastically decreased from 7/10 to 1/10 (p < 0.0001) and entirely stopped in 62% of patients
- followUp
After a mean follow-up of 15 months
Int J Colorectal Dis · PMID 33111967 · Read it on PubMed ↗
Zenger et al. 2021
A new technique of doppler dearterialization for hemorrhoidal disease: arterial detection ligation (ADL)
Fewer complications, most satisfied.RetrospectiveLow qualityRelated question
75 people1 year
most patients recovered without serious problems, pain scores fell over time, few had recurrence, and most were satisfied at 1 year
- Who was studied
- patients with symptomatic grade 2 or 3 hemorrhoids
- What they received
- arterial detection ligation (ADL), a Doppler-guided technique to find and tie off hemorrhoidal arteries at the right depth
- Compared with
- no comparator group; single-arm case series
- Main outcome
- complications, recurrence, and patient satisfaction after surgery
- Quality
- this is a small, single-arm retrospective study without a comparison group, so it cannot show how ADL stacks up against other treatments.
- Limitations
- retrospective design, no control group, small sample size, short-to-moderate follow-up
Taken word for word from the abstract
- n
A total of 75 patients were included in the study
- population
patients with symptomatic grades 2 or 3 HD
- intervention
the arterial detection ligation (ADL) technique, designed to find arteries at time-appropriate depth for ligating
- comparator
We analyzed the clinical characteristics, postoperative complications, recurrence, and patient satisfaction of the patients treated with ADL.
- primaryOutcome
We analyzed the clinical characteristics, postoperative complications, recurrence, and patient satisfaction of the patients treated with ADL.
- result
At the 1-year follow-up, three patients (4%) had a recurrence and the satisfaction rate was 86.7% (n = 65).
- result
ADL is an effective technique for treating HD, generally as an outpatient procedure, without serious morbidity.
Surg Today · PMID 33098443 · Read it on PubMed ↗
Stratta et al. 2021
Conservative Treatment of Hemorrhoidal Disease
Lifestyle and drug treatments may help, evidence weak.Narrative reviewVery low quality
size not given2021
Conservative treatment is effective in managing the majority of patients complaining of early stages of the disease.
- Who was studied
- people with hemorrhoidal disease, mostly early stages
- What they received
- conservative treatments: diet/lifestyle changes, oral phlebotonic drugs, topical medications
- Main outcome
- control of hemorrhoid symptoms including bleeding
- Quality
- It is a narrative review based mostly on uncontrolled case series with very few randomized trials, so it cannot reliably show what works.
- Limitations
- very few randomized controlled trials have been carried out and most of the studies are uncontrolled case series
Taken word for word from the abstract
- population
patients complaining of early stages of the disease
- intervention
Dietary and lifestyle modifications are the first therapeutic step necessary to achieve a regular defecation with soft stool whereas oral phlebotonic drugs can help to control symptoms.
- intervention
The use of topical medications, particularly during the acute phase or in the post-operative period can also be beneficial for all patients complaining of HD.
- primaryOutcome
Conservative treatment is effective in managing the majority of patients complaining of early stages of the disease.
- result
Conservative treatment is effective in managing the majority of patients complaining of early stages of the disease.
- limitations
very few randomized controlled trials have been carried out and most of the studies are uncontrolled case series
Rev Recent Clin Trials · PMID 33087033 · Read it on PubMed ↗
Cunha et al. 2020
Anorectal diseases in patients with Antiphospholipid syndrome: a cross-sectional study
Bleeding not linked to blood thinner dose.Case seriesVery low qualityRelated question
41 people2020
41.4% had hemorrhoids, mostly internal; 29.4% of those with hemorrhoids had anal bleeding, which was not related to warfarin dose; constipation was linked to more hemorrhoids
- Who was studied
- women with antiphospholipid syndrome (APS) undergoing proctological examination
- What they received
- proctological examination to detect hemorrhoids and anorectal disease
- Compared with
- APS patients without hemorrhoid disease
- Main outcome
- frequency of hemorrhoid disease and its complications, including bleeding, in APS patients
- Quality
- This is a small, uncontrolled descriptive study of only 41 patients with no comparison to non-APS patients or any treatment tested.
- Limitations
- Small sample size, all female APS patients only, cross-sectional design without a non-APS control group, no treatment compared.
Taken word for word from the abstract
- n
Forty-one APS patients agreed to undergo proctological examination.
- population
patients who fulfilled APS criteria to undergo proctological examination
- intervention
patients who fulfilled APS criteria to undergo proctological examination
- comparator
patients were divided in two groups, based on the presence of HD, and compared regarding different clinical manifestations and antiphospholipid profile
- primaryOutcome
to evaluate frequency of HD and describe its complications rates in antiphospholipid syndrome APS patients
- result
Seventeen (41.4%) patients were diagnosed with HD
- result
Five out of 17 patients (29.4%) reported anal bleeding, but it did not correlate with warfarin dose (p = 0.949).
- result
constipation remained as an important risk factor (OR 3.92,CI95% 1.03-14.2,p = 0.037)
Adv Rheumatol · PMID 33028422 · Read it on PubMed ↗
Rho et al. 2021
Ligasure Hemorrhoidectomy: Updates on Complications After an 18-Year Experience
Surgery had very low bleeding rate.RetrospectiveLow qualityRelated question
1,454 people2021
0.3% of patients had postoperative bleeding, with low rates of other complications overall
- Who was studied
- patients with grade III and IV hemorrhoids
- What they received
- LigaSure hemorrhoidectomy (surgical removal using energy device)
- Main outcome
- rate of post-operative complications including bleeding, length of stay, operating time, and return to work
- Quality
- This is a single-center, retrospective, descriptive study without a comparison group, so it can only describe outcomes of this surgery, not prove what causes or stops hemorrhoid bleeding.
- Limitations
- No control group, retrospective design, single center, and the study focuses on surgical complication rates rather than the mechanism of hemorrhoid bleeding or non-surgical ways to stop it.
Taken word for word from the abstract
- n
1454 consecutive patients, treated with LH for grade III and IV hemorrhoids, were analyzed
- population
1454 consecutive patients, treated with LH for grade III and IV hemorrhoids, were analyzed
- intervention
LigaSureTM hemorrhoidectomy (LH)
- primaryOutcome
The study aims to evaluate the outcomes of LigaSureTM hemorrhoidectomy (LH) analyzing main post-operative complications rate, length of stay, operating time, and time to return to work.
- result
0.3%-of patients experienced postoperative bleeding and only one required reoperation.
Rev Recent Clin Trials · PMID 33023436 · Read it on PubMed ↗
Hussain et al. 2020
Experience with Haemorrhoidal artery ligation under direct vision at a tertiary care hospital: A case series
Surgery relieved hemorrhoid symptoms.Case seriesLow qualityRelated question
70 people6 months
all patients were pain free and symptom free at follow-up, with high satisfaction and low recurrence
- Who was studied
- patients with symptomatic hemorrhoids
- What they received
- surgical tying off of the hemorrhoidal artery under direct vision plus recto anal repair
- Compared with
- none
- Main outcome
- pain, symptoms, and patient satisfaction after surgery
- Quality
- This was a small case series with no comparison group, so it cannot show whether the procedure works better than other treatments.
- Limitations
- No control group; single case series design; cannot establish cause of bleeding or compare to other treatments.
Taken word for word from the abstract
- n
a case series of 70 patients
- population
management of symptomatic haemorrhoids
- intervention
Haemorrhoidal Artery Ligation (HAL) and Recto Anal Repair (RAR)
- comparator
Ligation of superior haemorrhoidal artery was done under direct vision following manual palpation.
- primaryOutcome
At 1 month follow up, all 70 (100%) patients were pain free.
- result
70 (100%) patients were asymptomatic and 45 (64%) highly satisfied with their surgery at 3 months. This increased to 53 (75%) at 6 months.
J Pak Med Assoc · PMID 32810115 · Read it on PubMed ↗
Han et al. 2021
Superior rectal artery embolization for bleeding internal hemorrhoids
Artery-blocking procedure stopped most bleeding.RetrospectiveLow quality
32 peopleat least 1 year
Bleeding resolved in 84.4% of patients; 5 needed other treatment; some had temporary pain, fever, or rebleeding that was later controlled with repeat embolization
- Who was studied
- Patients with stage II and III internal hemorrhoids causing chronic bleeding
- What they received
- Blocking the artery feeding the hemorrhoids (superior rectal artery embolization) using sponge particles and coils
- Compared with
- No comparison group; outcomes tracked before/after procedure
- Main outcome
- Whether bleeding stopped and complications occurred
- Quality
- Small retrospective study with no comparison group, so it can't prove the procedure itself caused the improvement.
- Limitations
- Retrospective design, no control group, small sample size
Taken word for word from the abstract
- n
There were 32 patients (18 males, mean age 52 ± 12 years, range: 22-78 years)
- population
Patients with stage II and stage III internal hemorrhoids, treated by interventional embolization of the SRA
- intervention
Superselective SRA branch embolization was performed using gelatin sponge particles (350-560 μm) and metallic coils (2-3 mm).
- comparator
retrospectively evaluated
- primaryOutcome
The surgical efficacy, postoperative complications and follow-up outcomes were observed.
- result
Embolization was successful in all patients, and bleeding symptoms resolved in 27 (84.4%) patients.
- followUp
All patients were followed up for at least 1 year.
Tech Coloproctol · PMID 32712932 · Read it on PubMed ↗
Dönmez et al. 2020
From nutrition to medicine: Assessing hemorrhoid healing activity of Solanum melongena L. via in vivo experimental models and its major chemicals
Eggplant extract healed hemorrhoids in rats.Animal studyVery low qualityRelated question
size not given2020
eggplant extract showed greater healing effect than controls and the commercial product, and reduced capillary permeability increase
- Who was studied
- rats with chemically induced hemorrhoids (anal area treated with croton oil)
- What they received
- methanolic extract of eggplant (Solanum melongena) calyxes
- Compared with
- untreated controls and commercial Pilex tablet/cream
- Main outcome
- healing of hemorrhoid tissue (histological and biochemical measures) and capillary permeability
- Quality
- This is an animal experiment, not a human study, so it cannot show whether this works for people with hemorrhoids.
- Limitations
- Study abstract does not report number of animals used, and findings are from an animal model not humans; does not explain bleeding mechanism directly.
Taken word for word from the abstract
- population
Hemorrhoid, which was induced by applying croton oil to the anal area of the rats.
- intervention
In vivo anti-hemorrhoidal activity of the methanolic extract prepared from eggplant was evaluated by experimental hemorrhoid model
- comparator
The healing potential was comparatively assessed with a reference Pilex® tablet and cream.
- primaryOutcome
Histological and biochemical analysis demonstrated that eggplant extract is highly effective against hemorrhoid in comparison to the controls and the commercial preparation.
- result
Histological and biochemical analysis demonstrated that eggplant extract is highly effective against hemorrhoid in comparison to the controls and the commercial preparation. In addition, the methanolic extract demonstrated significant inhibitory effect on acetic acid-induced increase in capillary permeability.
J Ethnopharmacol · PMID 32687958 · Read it on PubMed ↗
Hidalgo-Grau et al. 2020
Prospective Randomized Study on Stapled Anopexy Height and Its Influence on Recurrence for Hemorrhoidal Disease Treatment
No difference in hemorrhoid recurrence.Randomised trialModerate qualityRelated question
119 people11.05 ± 1.6 years
No difference in recurrence between the two staple heights, but the lower staple line group needed more stitches to control bleeding during surgery
- Who was studied
- patients with symptomatic third- and fourth-grade hemorrhoids
- What they received
- stapled anopexy with staple line height of 4.5 cm from the anal verge
- Compared with
- stapled anopexy with staple line height of 6 cm from the anal verge
- Main outcome
- recurrence rate and postoperative disturbances after stapled anopexy
- Quality
- It is a randomized, double-blind trial with long follow-up but is small and from a single surgical unit.
- Limitations
- Small sample size; single-center study; focuses on surgical technique variation rather than direct comparison of bleeding-control treatments.
Taken word for word from the abstract
- n
119 patients with the diagnosis of symptomatic third- and fourth-grade hemorrhoids were included.
- population
119 patients with the diagnosis of symptomatic third- and fourth-grade hemorrhoids were included.
- intervention
SA was performed with two different SLH: group A, 4.5 cm (58 patients) and group B, 6 cm (61 patients) from the external anal verge.
- comparator
group B, 6 cm (61 patients) from the external anal verge.
- primaryOutcome
To know the influence of the stapled line height (SLH) in the recurrence rate and the postoperative disturbances in stapled anopexy (SA) for the treatment of hemorrhoids.
- result
The patients of group A needed a significantly higher number of stitches for intraoperative bleeding control along the stapled line.
- result
At the follow-up, persistence of symptomatology was 10.41% in group A and 10.71% in group B, without statistically significance.
World J Surg · PMID 32647985 · Read it on PubMed ↗
Chiaretti et al. 2020
Comparison of Centella with Flavonoids for Treatment of Symptoms in Hemorrhoidal Disease and After Surgical Intervention: A Randomized Clinical Trial
Flavonoids stopped bleeding faster.Randomised trialLow quality
195 peopleup to day 42
bleeding stopped sooner and irritation scores were lower with flavonoids or Centella than with routine treatment alone, both before and after surgery
- Who was studied
- people with hemorrhoidal disease, including some after hemorrhoid surgery or with hemorrhoidal blood clots
- What they received
- phlebotonic drugs (flavonoids or Centella) added to standard treatment
- Compared with
- routine treatment alone (control group)
- Main outcome
- time until bleeding stopped and anal irritation score
- Quality
- It was described as randomized but the abstract gives no details on blinding, allocation concealment, or how multiple subgroups and surgery were handled, so the comparison is hard to fully trust.
- Limitations
- No mention of blinding or concealment; patients were split into several different subgroups (medical and surgical) with uneven group sizes.
Taken word for word from the abstract
- n
evaluated to reduce time-to-stop bleeding and anal irritation in 130 patients who complained of hemorrhoidal disease (HD); bleeding and pain after hemorrhoidectomy (31 patients) and hemorrhoidal thrombosis (34 patients)
- population
130 patients who complained of hemorrhoidal disease (HD); bleeding and pain after hemorrhoidectomy (31 patients) and hemorrhoidal thrombosis (34 patients)
- intervention
The treated group (both conservative and surgical) was divided into two subgroups: one treated with flavonoids (Group A, n = 73), the other with Centella (Group B, n = 66).
- comparator
Sixty patients were randomized to receive the routine treatment (both conservative and surgical) (control Group C).
- primaryOutcome
Time-to-stop bleeding was checked at baseline and checkups (0 up to day 42).
- result
The HD median time-to-stop bleeding was 2 weeks for Groups A and B; 3 weeks for Group C.
- result
As for operated hemorrhoids, the time-to-stop bleeding was 3 and 4 weeks in Groups A and B and 5 in Group C.
- followUp
Time-to-stop bleeding was checked at baseline and checkups (0 up to day 42).
Sci Rep · PMID 32409760 · Read it on PubMed ↗
Moussa et al. 2020
Mid-Term Results of Superior Rectal Artery and Coils for Hemorrhoidal Embolization with Particles Bleeding
No difference between embolization methods.RetrospectiveLow quality
38 people2020
no significant difference in clinical success between particles-plus-coils and coils-alone groups
- Who was studied
- patients with chronic hemorrhoidal bleeding
- What they received
- artery embolization using particles plus coils
- Compared with
- artery embolization using coils alone
- Main outcome
- improvement in bleeding severity score without complications
- Quality
- small retrospective matched-pairs study without randomization, limiting confidence in comparing the two embolization methods.
- Limitations
- Retrospective design, small sample size after matching, no randomization.
Taken word for word from the abstract
- n
the final study population was 38 patients (19 study group and 19 controls)
- population
patients undergoing embolization for chronic hemorrhoidal bleeding
- intervention
embolization of the superior rectal arteries in patients with hemorrhoidal bleeding using particles and coils
- comparator
versus coils only
- primaryOutcome
Clinical success was defined as an improvement of > 2 points in the Paris bleeding severity score, without complications.
- result
Clinical success did not differ significantly between the two populations: 63% for control group and 68% for the study group (p = 0.790).
Cardiovasc Intervent Radiol · PMID 32342155 · Read it on PubMed ↗
Giurazza et al. 2020
Emborrhoid in patients with portal hypertension and chronic hemorrhoidal bleeding: preliminary results in five cases with a new coiling release fashion "Spaghetti technique"
Fewer bleeding symptoms after artery-blocking procedure.Case seriesVery low qualityRelated question
5 people3 months
all arteries were successfully blocked, no complications, and 4 of 5 patients improved clinically with stable or improved blood counts
- Who was studied
- patients with liver cirrhosis causing portal hypertension and chronic anemia from internal hemorrhoid bleeding
- What they received
- embolization of hemorrhoidal arteries using coils released in a stretched 'Spaghetti technique'
- Compared with
- none (no comparison group)
- Main outcome
- successful blocking of the bleeding artery, symptom improvement, and hemoglobin levels at 3 months
- Quality
- this is a tiny uncontrolled case series of only five patients with no comparison group, so it cannot reliably show the treatment works.
- Limitations
- very small sample size, no control group, short follow-up, and patients had a specific cause of bleeding (portal hypertension) rather than typical hemorrhoids
Taken word for word from the abstract
- n
Five patients with chronic anemia due to internal hemorrhoidal bleeding and cirrhotic portal hypertension were treated.
- population
patients affected by cirrhotic portal hypertension
- population
Five patients with chronic anemia due to internal hemorrhoidal bleeding and cirrhotic portal hypertension were treated.
- intervention
Embolizations were performed with fibered coils, oversized, released stretched and not packed.
- intervention
a novel customized technique of coils release, named "Spaghetti technique,"
- comparator
Five patients with chronic anemia due to internal hemorrhoidal bleeding and cirrhotic portal hypertension were treated.
- primaryOutcome
Clinics and hemoglobin values were evaluated to objectively assess clinical conditions up to 3 months follow-up.
- result
Technical success, intended as occlusion of all superior hemorrhoidal artery branches, was 100%.
- result
At 3-month follow-up, clinical improvement was obtained in four of the five patients; hemoglobin values improved or remained stable in the whole sample.
Radiol Med · PMID 32306200 · Read it on PubMed ↗
Titov et al. 2020
[Submucosal laser ablation of internal hemorrhoids]
Laser ablation effective for hemorrhoidsSystematic reviewLow qualityRelated question
size not given12 months
procedure was effective in 91.1-100% of cases at 6 months and 87.5-100% at 12 months, with some bleeding and other complications
- Who was studied
- people with grade 2-3 internal hemorrhoids
- What they received
- submucosal laser ablation (SLT) of hemorrhoids
- Quality
- this is a review of small prospective trials without a comparison group, so it cannot reliably confirm the treatment works better than alternatives.
- Limitations
- abstract notes absence of clear recommendations on laser parameters, indications, and lack of long-term outcome data
Taken word for word from the abstract
- population
SLT was predominantly used in the treatment of hemorrhoids grade 2-3.
- intervention
submucosal laser ablation of internal hemorrhoids (SLT)
- result
Efficacy of procedure was 91.1-100% after 6 months and 87.5-100% after 12 months.
- result
Intra- and postoperative complications included intraoperative bleeding (8.4%), perianal and external piles edema (8.2%), postoperative bleeding (2.7%), urinary retention (1.2%), anal fistula (0.6%), perianal abscess (0.14%).
- followUp
after 12 months
- limitations
further researches are required considering the absence of clear recommendations on laser beam parameters, indications for procedure and data on long-term outcomes
Khirurgiia (Mosk) · PMID 32271744 · Read it on PubMed ↗
Salusso et al. 2021
Management of Hemorrhoidal Disease in Special Conditions: A Word of Caution
Conservative treatment preferred; surgery reserved for severe cases.Narrative reviewVery low qualityRelated question
size not given2021
conservative medical treatment is recommended as first-line in most special conditions, with surgery reserved for selected or urgent cases; bleeding hemorrhoids can be treated with hemorrhoidectomy when other treatments fail, but caution is urged due to risk of serious complications
- Who was studied
- people with hemorrhoids who also have special conditions like inflammatory bowel disease, pregnancy, immunosuppression, bleeding disorders, liver disease with portal hypertension, or prior pelvic radiotherapy
- What they received
- various hemorrhoid treatments including medical therapy, outpatient procedures, and surgery (including hemorrhoidectomy)
- Compared with
- different treatment approaches compared across these special patient subgroups
- Main outcome
- which treatment approach works best and is safest for hemorrhoids in these special patient groups
- Quality
- this is a narrative review of 'research and online contents' rather than a systematic search, and it repeatedly states there is very limited or insufficient data for these patient groups.
- Limitations
- The abstract itself states there is very limited data, a paucity of literature, and no consensus on best treatment for several of these subgroups.
Taken word for word from the abstract
- population
Inflammatory Bowel Diseases (IBD), pregnancy, immunosuppression, coagulopathy, cirrhosis with portal hypertension, and proctitis after radiotherapy, challenge hemorrhoids management and the outcomes
- intervention
The first-line treatment is the conservative medical approach associated with the treatment of the primary disease.
- comparator
Patients in pregnancy can be effectively treated with medical therapy, reserving surgical intervention in highly selected and urgent cases.
- primaryOutcome
There are very limited data about the outcomes of hemorrhoids treatment in these subgroups of patients.
- result
Bleeding hemorrhoids can be treated with hemorrhoidectomy when they do not respond to other treatments.
- result
In case of portal hypertension and cirrhosis, a 'conservative treatment' is recommended.
- qualityWhy
International literature is very scant about the treatment of patients affected by hemorrhoids in particular situations.
Rev Recent Clin Trials · PMID 32250231 · Read it on PubMed ↗
Giamundo 2021
Hemorrhoidal Laser Procedure (HeLP) and Hemorrhoidal Laser Procedure + Mucopexy (HeLPexx) and Other Emerging Technologies
Laser artery closure may ease bleeding.Narrative reviewVery low quality
size not given2021
described as helping resolve symptoms, especially bleeding, when combined with mucopexy for prolapse
- Who was studied
- people with symptomatic hemorrhoids
- What they received
- laser closure of the artery branches feeding the hemorrhoids (HeLP), sometimes combined with stitching to lift prolapsed tissue (HeLPexx)
- Compared with
- not specified in the abstract
- Main outcome
- relief of hemorrhoid symptoms, including bleeding
- Quality
- this is a descriptive overview of procedures without any patient numbers, comparison group, or measured outcomes.
- Limitations
- No study data, numbers, or controlled comparisons are given; the abstract only describes how the procedures work and when they are used.
Taken word for word from the abstract
- population
patients suffering from symptomatic hemorrhoids
- intervention
The procedure consists of the closure of the terminal branches of the superior rectal artery approximately 2-3 cm above the dentate line by means of laser shots originated by a diode laser platform.
- comparator
'HeLP' is indicated in patients with symptomatic hemorrhoids where conservative treatment failed
- primaryOutcome
securing a long-term resolution of symptoms
- result
The addition of mucopexy to laser treatment (HeLPexx) contributes to the overall resolution of symptoms when mucosal prolapse is an issue.
- result
Emborrhoid is another novel, 'hi-tech' form of selective dearterialization used in selected cases of hemorrhoids where the main symptom is bleeding.
Rev Recent Clin Trials · PMID 32250230 · Read it on PubMed ↗
Amaturo et al. 2020
Treatment of haemorrhoidal disease with micronized purified flavonoid fraction and sucralfate ointment
Less pain, itching, swelling; bleeding not reportedCase seriesVery low qualityRelated question
3 people2020
good results in terms of pain and itching control and in edema reduction
- Who was studied
- people with hemorrhoidal disease (swollen rectal veins)
- What they received
- combined oral MPFF (flavonoid) tablet plus a sucralfate‑and‑herbal rectal ointment
- Main outcome
- control of pain, itching and swelling
- Quality
- This is a tiny report of only three patients with no control group, so it cannot reliably show the treatment works.
- Limitations
- Only three patients were described, with no comparison group and no mention of bleeding outcomes.
Taken word for word from the abstract
- n
Our experience with three cases treated with combined use of MPFF and a topical medical device
- population
Hemorrhoidal disease is a very common disease characterized by the presence of a mucous prolapse of the rectum and by varicosis of the hemorrhoidal plexus.
- intervention
combined use of MPFF and a topical medical device in the form of rectal ointment, composed by sucralfate and herbal (calendula, witch hazel leaf (hamamelis), chamomile) extracts
- primaryOutcome
has shown good results in terms of pain and itching control and in edema reduction
- result
has shown good results in terms of pain and itching control and in edema reduction
Acta Biomed · PMID 32191669 · Read it on PubMed ↗
Sena et al. 2021
Excisional Haemorrhoidectomy: Where Are We?
Surgery works best for severe cases.Narrative reviewLow qualityRelated question
size not given2021
excisional hemorrhoidectomy techniques are the most effective treatment for grade III and IV hemorrhoids
- Who was studied
- people with hemorrhoids (anal cushion enlargement/prolapse)
- What they received
- excisional hemorrhoidectomy surgery (Milligan and Morgan, Parks, Ferguson, Whitehead techniques)
- Compared with
- conservative (non-surgical) treatments
- Main outcome
- effectiveness of treatment for hemorrhoidal disease
- Quality
- this is a narrative review describing surgical techniques without original data, numbers, or statistical comparison.
- Limitations
- abstract gives no study numbers, methodology, or data on bleeding specifically; it is a general review of surgical techniques, not a controlled comparison.
Taken word for word from the abstract
- population
Haemorrhoidal disease (HD) is defined as the symptomatic enlargement and/or distal displacement of anal cushions
- intervention
such as Milligan and Morgan, Parks, Ferguson and Whitehead technique
- comparator
Despite significant improvements in conservative treatments
- primaryOutcome
excisional haemorrhoidectomy techniques are the most effective treatment for III- and IV degree
- result
excisional haemorrhoidectomy techniques are the most effective treatment for III- and IV degree
Rev Recent Clin Trials · PMID 32189597 · Read it on PubMed ↗
Moggia et al. 2021
Do We Have Another Option to Treat Bleeding Hemorrhoids? The Emborrhoid Technique: Experience in 16 Patients
Artery-blocking procedure reduced hemorrhoid bleeding, no complications.Case seriesLow quality
16 people12 months
bleeding improved with better quality of life in 14 of 16 patients, no complications up to 12 months
- Who was studied
- patients with chronic rectal bleeding caused by hemorrhoids
- What they received
- embolization (blocking) of the superior rectal arteries using coils
- Compared with
- none (single-group outcome study)
- Main outcome
- reduction in rectal bleeding and quality of life, plus safety/complications
- Quality
- very small, uncontrolled study with no comparison group, so results could be due to chance or natural improvement.
- Limitations
- Small sample of only 16 patients, no control group, described by authors as preliminary.
Taken word for word from the abstract
- n
a total of 16 patients
- population
16 patients with chronic rectal bleeding due to hemorrhoids
- intervention
super-selective embolization of the superior rectal arteries
- comparator
embolization of superior rectal arteries with coils to treat severe bleeding due to hemorrhoids
- primaryOutcome
The reduction of rectal bleeding with improvement of the quality of life
- result
The reduction of rectal bleeding with improvement of the quality of life was obtained in 14 patients (87.5%).
- result
No post-procedural and short-term complications were observed at maximum follow up (12 months).
- followUp
maximum follow up (12 months)
Rev Recent Clin Trials · PMID 32167429 · Read it on PubMed ↗
How we searchedThe exact query, the date it ran, and what came back — so you can run it yourself.
- Searched
- PubMed · ClinicalTrials.gov · Crossref on 2026-10-13
- The exact search — paste this into PubMed to repeat it
Hemorrhoids[Mesh] AND (Hemorrhage[Mesh] OR bleeding[tiab] OR hematochezia[tiab]) AND (therapy[Mesh] OR treatment[tiab] OR ligation[tiab] OR sclerotherapy[tiab] OR hemorrhoidectomy[tiab] OR "infrared coagulation"[tiab] OR fiber[tiab])- PubMed expanded that to:
"hemorrhoids"[MeSH Terms] AND ("hemorrhage"[MeSH Terms] OR "bleeding"[Title/Abstract] OR "hematochezia"[Title/Abstract]) AND ("therapeutics"[MeSH Terms] OR "treatment"[Title/Abstract] OR "ligation"[Title/Abstract] OR "sclerotherapy"[Title/Abstract] OR "hemorrhoidectomy"[Title/Abstract] OR "infrared coagulation"[Title/Abstract] OR "fiber"[Title/Abstract]) - What came back
- 1016 records found · 200 read · 140 answered the question
- Included
- Human, animal or laboratory studies reporting an outcome relevant to the question
- Excluded
- Records about a different condition or intervention
- Records reporting no outcome
- Retracted publications, which are listed but excluded from every count
- Limits
- Details were read from abstracts, not full papers, so anything reported only in a paper's methods section is not captured here.
- Fields were read from abstracts, not full text, so detail reported only in a paper's methods section is not captured.
- Evidence strength is adapted from the GRADE framework. It is not a GRADE assessment and was not produced by a GRADE panel.
Automated evidence review — PubMed, ClinicalTrials.gov, Crossref. Search strategy, grading rules and the checks that must pass before anything publishes were written by Allen Kamrava, MD, MBA, FACS, FASCRS, colon & rectal surgery, Beverly Hills. The pages themselves are compiled by software running that method and are not read one by one before publication — saying otherwise would be the one claim here that could not be checked.
- 1016records came back from the search
- 200were read
- 140actually answered the question
Risks and safetyReported side effects and who should be careful.
- Rubber band ligation can rarely cause serious delayed bleeding, even needing emergency treatment, days after the procedure.
- People taking blood-thinning medication had higher rates of bleeding complications after hemorrhoid procedures, though severe bleeding needing hospital admission was not more common.
- Surgical removal of hemorrhoids caused more pain, bleeding and urinary retention than less invasive office procedures in a large comparison across many trials.
Why people try thisThe reasoning behind the question — not a claim that it works.
- Seeing blood in the toilet or on tissue is frightening, so people want it to stop right away.
- Surgery sounds painful and inconvenient, so many look for creams, diet changes, or in-office treatments first.
- Hemorrhoid creams and suppositories are sold over the counter and heavily marketed as a quick fix.
- Some people hope diet and fiber alone will solve it without having to see a doctor about a sensitive problem.
Common questionsShort answers, drawn from the same studies.
- Why is my hemorrhoid bleeding?
- Hemorrhoids are swollen blood vessels in and around the anus, and their surface can wear thin or tear, especially as stool passes over them. The studies in this review test ways to stop that bleeding rather than explain the biology behind it, so the exact mechanism wasn't directly studied here.
- Can internal hemorrhoids bleed?
- Yes. Many of the studies in this review specifically treated internal hemorrhoids where bleeding was the main symptom, including grade I through grade IV disease, and measured whether that bleeding stopped after treatment.
- How long do internal hemorrhoids bleed?
- This varies and isn't firmly pinned down by the evidence. In one trial, injection sclerotherapy stopped bleeding in about 6 in 10 people after one session and about 9 in 10 after a second session within a few months; other studies saw improvement within one to four weeks of starting treatment. Ongoing bleeding should be checked by a doctor rather than waited out.
- How do I stop internal hemorrhoids from bleeding?
- In these studies, office-based treatments such as rubber band ligation and sclerotherapy injections stopped or reduced bleeding in most people treated, and oral vein-supporting medicines (flavonoids) also reduced bleeding compared with placebo or routine care. Surgery was used for more severe cases and controlled bleeding well, but came with more pain and its own bleeding risk.
- When should I see a doctor about hemorrhoid bleeding?
- Rectal bleeding can come from causes other than hemorrhoids, so it's worth getting checked, especially if it's heavy, persistent, painful, or you're over 45 or feel dizzy or unusually tired. The studies here only looked at people whose bleeding had already been confirmed to be from hemorrhoids.
This is information, not advice
This page summarises published research. It cannot tell you what is happening in your own body, and evidence changes. If something is bleeding, painful, or new, it is worth being looked at — that is a different question from the one on this page, and a better one to bring to a consultation.
Contact the officeAutomated evidence review — PubMed, ClinicalTrials.gov, Crossref. Search strategy, grading rules and the checks that must pass before anything publishes were written by Allen Kamrava, MD, MBA, FACS, FASCRS, colon & rectal surgery, Beverly Hills. The pages themselves are compiled by software running that method and are not read one by one before publication — saying otherwise would be the one claim here that could not be checked.