How do you get rid of external hemorrhoids permanently?
In adults with external hemorrhoids, which treatment approaches (conservative measures, office procedures, or surgery) achieve long-term resolution without recurrence?
How people search for this, in their own words
- “how to get rid of external hemorrhoids permanently”
- “how to get rid of hemorrhoids permanently”
- “what gets rid of hemorrhoids permanently”
- “which medicine cure piles permanently”
- “how to get rid of external hemorrhoids permanently at home”
Evidence review in plain language · compiled 2026-11-17 · checked 2026-11-17 · next 2026-12-17 · automated review, how it works
What the evidence says
Bottom line
No treatment studied for external hemorrhoids—conservative care, in-office procedures, or surgery—has been shown to make them disappear permanently with no chance of return.
The studies that look directly at external hemorrhoids focus on painful, clotted ones (thrombosed external hemorrhoids), and compare surgical removal with non-surgical care, or surgery with in-office incision and drainage. Surgery was linked to fewer hemorrhoids coming back than conservative treatment, but recurrence still happened in both groups, and most follow-up was a year or less.
How well studied
Fairly well studied
A systematic review addresses this question, but the underlying trials are limited.
This question weighs several approaches rather than testing one treatment, so there is no single works-or-doesn't verdict. What can be shown is how well it has been studied.
- answer it directly
- 3answer it directly
- studies found
- 58studies found
- randomised trials
- 11randomised trials
- people studied
- 53,031people studied
- reviews of trials
- 12reviews of trials
- years covered
- 2008–2026years covered
What the research shows
Hemorrhoids not coming back (recurrence) at 12 months or longer
Surgery for thrombosed external hemorrhoids was linked to fewer recurrences than conservative treatment in two studies. One study comparing surgical excision with in-office thrombectomy found no significant difference in success, and in a study of elderly patients, excision had no recurrences while incision-drainage and medical treatment alone both had higher recurrence rates.[1,2,3,4]
Some evidence
Symptom relief (pain, swelling, bleeding)
In one small study of elderly patients (over 75) with thrombosed external hemorrhoids, symptoms went away fastest with in-office incision and drainage (about 1.58 days on average), slower with surgical removal (7.8 days), and slowest with medical treatment alone (11.8 days). A separate, broader review of hemorrhoid patients found surgery achieved more complete symptom resolution than conservative treatment, but it did not report how quickly pain itself improved with each approach.[1,2]
Too little evidence
Some evidence
Complication rate
A broader review of hemorrhoid patients found that surgery carries some specific post-operative complications not detailed in the abstract, while conservative treatment was described as safer though slower to relieve symptoms and more likely to recur. Separately, in elderly patients with thrombosed external hemorrhoids, bleeding was the most common side effect overall, occurring most often after in-office incision and drainage, less often after surgical removal, which had no major complications.[1,2]
Some evidence
Permanent cure from lifestyle measures or topical medicine alone
No study here tested fiber, creams, sitz baths, or other home measures on their own against surgery or office procedures to see whether they can permanently resolve external hemorrhoids. 'Conservative care' in these studies was treated as one group rather than broken into individual home remedies.
Not studied
What the studies found
- In adults with thrombosed external hemorrhoids, surgical removal led to fewer hemorrhoids coming back than non-surgical (conservative) care.[1,2]
- In-office incision and drainage relieved pain and swelling faster than either surgery or medical treatment alone, in a study of elderly patients with thrombosed external hemorrhoids.[1]
- When excision surgery was compared directly with in-office thrombectomy for thrombosed external hemorrhoids, thrombectomy showed a trend toward higher treatment success, though the difference did not reach statistical significance.[1]
Important limitations
- Some of the surgical studies behind this review (for example, comparisons of monopolar cautery ablation and laser hemorrhoidoplasty versus traditional surgery) enrolled patients using an internal hemorrhoid grading system such as grade II-III or grade II-IV disease, rather than specifically external hemorrhoids, so their findings may not transfer directly to external hemorrhoids.[1,2]
- Follow-up in the studies that do address external hemorrhoids directly is short—six months to about a year—so none can show whether any treatment prevents recurrence over many years, which is what 'permanently' would require.[1,2,3,4]
- Several of the directly relevant studies are retrospective or observational rather than randomised, so patient choice or clinician preference may have influenced which treatment people actually received.[1,2,3]
What kind of studies
- Retrospective20 · 34%
- Meta-analysis11 · 19%
- Randomised trial11 · 19%
- Prospective cohort7 · 12%
- Case series6 · 10%
- Narrative review2 · 3%
- Systematic review1 · 2%
The key studies
Alotaibi et al. 2026
Predicting the Unwelcome Return: Insights From a Cohort of Postoperative Haemorrhoid Patients
Surgery complications raised recurrence risk.RetrospectiveLow qualityRelated question
529 people2026
Recurrence happened in 4.3% of patients; those with complications after surgery or with external haemorrhoids were more likely to have earlier recurrence, though the link with external haemorrhoids was borderline and not statistically significant after adjustment
- Who was studied
- Adults who had elective surgery for haemorrhoids
- Main outcome
- Whether haemorrhoids came back (recurrence) after surgery, and how long until they did
- Quality
- This is a retrospective single-hospital study with only 23 recurrence events, so it can only suggest risk factors, not prove what cures external haemorrhoids permanently.
- Limitations
- Retrospective design, single centre, small number of recurrence events, and it studies risk factors for recurrence after surgery rather than comparing different treatment approaches for external haemorrhoids.
Taken word for word from the abstract
- population
This retrospective cohort study included patients who underwent elective haemorrhoid surgery between January 2021 and December 2023 at Dr. Soliman Fakeeh Hospital.
- primaryOutcome
This study aimed to identify the factors associated with haemorrhoid recurrence and recurrence-free survival following haemorrhoid surgery.
- result
A total of 529 patients were included, with a cumulative recurrence incidence of 4.3% (n = 23).
- result
postoperative complications remained independently associated with recurrence risk (hazard ratio [HR] 4.63, 95% confidence interval [CI]: 1.68-12.80, p = 0.003).
- result
The association between external haemorrhoids and recurrence risk demonstrated borderline significance (HR 2.55, 95% CI: 0.99-6.60, p = 0.053).
- n
A total of 529 patients were included
Ann Ital Chir · PMID 42610287 · Read it on PubMed ↗
Quan et al. 2025
Comparison of efficacy and safety between surgical and conservative treatments for hemorrhoids: a meta-analysis
Surgery clears symptoms faster, lower recurrence.Meta-analysisModerate qualityRelated question
760 people2025
Surgery led to more complete symptom resolution and less recurrence than conservative treatment, with faster pain relief early on but similar pain by 10 days; surgery also had some specific complications (incontinence, persistent pain, watery discharge) while rates of bleeding and urinary retention were similar between groups
- Who was studied
- adults with hemorrhoids, including some pregnant women with thrombosed external hemorrhoids
- What they received
- surgical treatment for hemorrhoids
- Compared with
- non-invasive conservative treatment for hemorrhoids
- Main outcome
- complete symptom resolution, pain scores, recurrence, and complications
- Quality
- it pools only seven studies with 760 patients total, and most are not limited specifically to external hemorrhoids, so results may not fully apply to that group.
- Limitations
- Small number of pooled studies (seven), population is general hemorrhoid patients rather than specifically external hemorrhoids, and some outcomes showed heterogeneity between studies.
Taken word for word from the abstract
- n
Seven studies, including 760 patients, were analyzed.
- population
Comparable patterns were observed in pregnant women with thrombosed external hemorrhoids.
- intervention
Surgery achieved higher rates of complete symptom resolution than conservative therapy
- comparator
Eligible studies compared surgical treatments with non-invasive conservative treatments in hemorrhoids.
- primaryOutcome
Surgery achieved higher rates of complete symptom resolution than conservative therapy (OR = 2.96, 95% CI: 1.66-5.28, p < 0.001).
- result
Surgical treatments provide superior symptom relief, faster recovery, and lower recurrence but with some specific post-treatment complications, while conservative treatments are safer and less invasive but with provides slower symptom relief and higher recurrence rates.
BMC Gastroenterol · PMID 40596934 · Read it on PubMed ↗
Martins et al. 2026
Operative versus nonoperative treatment of thrombosed external hemorrhoids: a systematic review and meta-analysis
Surgery lowers recurrence versus conservative care.Meta-analysisModerate quality
851 people2026
Surgery had lower recurrence than conservative treatment, but no difference in bleeding risk between groups
- Who was studied
- Adults with thrombosed external hemorrhoids
- What they received
- Surgical treatment (excision surgery)
- Compared with
- Conservative (nonoperative) management
- Main outcome
- Recurrence of hemorrhoids and bleeding complications
- Quality
- This pools six trials with over 800 patients, but there was moderate-to-substantial variation between studies (I2 up to 60%) and the abstract does not describe how good the individual trials were.
- Limitations
- Heterogeneity between studies (I2 = 54% for recurrence, 60% for bleeding); no detail on study quality or blinding; subgroup comparisons of excision approaches showed no differences.
Taken word for word from the abstract
- population
clinical trials comparing surgery with conservative treatment in thrombosed external hemorrhoids
- intervention
Surgical treatment was associated with a lower risk of recurrence compared to conservative management
- comparator
compared to conservative management
- primaryOutcome
Surgical treatment was associated with a lower risk of recurrence compared to conservative management (RR 0.49; 95% CI 0.26-0.91; P < 0.05; I2 = 54%)
- result
there were no significant differences in the risk of bleeding between the groups (RR 0.96; 95% CI 0.27-3.44; P = 0.95; I2 = 60%)
- n
We included six studies with a total of 851 patients, of whom 390 (45.8%) underwent surgical treatment.
Updates Surg · PMID 40576944 · Read it on PubMed ↗
Yalcinkaya et al. 2023
Local excision versus thrombectomy in thrombosed external hemorrhoids: a multicenter, prospective, observational study
In-office thrombectomy may work slightly better than excision.Prospective cohortLow quality
96 people6 months
Thrombectomy had higher success (86.8%) than local excision (67.2%), though not statistically significant; thrombectomy showed better quality-of-life and continence scores at follow-up
- Who was studied
- Adults with thrombosed external hemorrhoids
- What they received
- Local excision (surgical removal)
- Compared with
- In-office thrombectomy (incision/drainage of clot)
- Main outcome
- Treatment success at 1 month, plus symptom scores and quality of life at 6 months
- Quality
- This is a non-randomized observational study comparing two procedures without random assignment, so differences between groups could be due to factors other than the treatment itself.
- Limitations
- Observational (not randomized) design, short follow-up (6 months), success rate difference between groups did not reach statistical significance (p=0.054), and the paper notes guidelines in this area rely on expert opinion rather than high-quality evidence.
Taken word for word from the abstract
- population
thrombosed external hemorrhoids (TEH)
- intervention
local excision (LE)
- comparator
thrombectomy (incision)
- primaryOutcome
Surgical success was assessed at 1 month.
- result
Success was relatively higher in the thrombectomy group (86.8%) compared to the LE group (67.2%) (p = 0.054).
- result
SHS scores (6 months) and Wexner scores (all time points) were significantly better in the thrombectomy group.
- n
A total of 96 patients (58 LE, 38 thrombectomy) were included.
BMC Surg · PMID 37563701 · Read it on PubMed ↗
Luo et al. 2023
Comparision of Ligasure hemorrhoidectomy and conservative treatment for thrombosed external hemorrhoids (TEH) in pregnancy
Surgery cured it, less recurrenceRetrospectiveLow quality
94 peopleNot clearly stated beyond post-treatment days 1 and 7 and recurrence assessment period
Surgery gave faster pain relief, quicker return to normal activity, lower recurrence (8.57% vs 30.43%), and higher satisfaction than conservative treatment, with no increased risk to mother or baby
- Who was studied
- Pregnant women hospitalized for thrombosed external hemorrhoids
- What they received
- Ligasure hemorrhoidectomy (surgical removal)
- Compared with
- Conservative (non-surgical) treatment
- Main outcome
- Symptom relief, recurrence, and patient satisfaction
- Quality
- This is a retrospective, single-center study where patients chose their own treatment, so differences between groups could be due to patient choice rather than the treatment itself.
- Limitations
- Retrospective design, small number of patients, data from only one center, and treatment assignment was based on patient preference rather than randomization.
Taken word for word from the abstract
- population
94 pregnant patients hospitalized for thrombosed external hemorrhoids from September 2020 to December 2021
- intervention
Ligasure hemorrhoidectomy treatment or conservative treatment according to the patient's wishes
- comparator
Ligasure hemorrhoidectomy treatment or conservative treatment according to the patient's wishes
- primaryOutcome
Symptom relief, recurrence and satisfaction of thrombosed external hemorrhoids in pregnancy with different interventions
- result
Time to return to normal activities was shorter in surgical group than in conservative group (6.51 vs. 13.52 days, P < 0.001).
- result
Recurrence rate was significantly lower in surgical group (8.57% vs. 30.43%, P = 0.017).
- result
The patient satisfaction scores were significantly higher in surgical group than in conservative group (Z = - 2.979, P = 0.003).
- n
94 pregnant patients hospitalized for thrombosed external hemorrhoids from September 2020 to December 2021
BMC Surg · PMID 36658522 · Read it on PubMed ↗
Eberspacher et al. 2020
External hemorrhoidal thrombosis in the elderly patients: conservative and surgical management
Surgery gave the most lasting cure.RetrospectiveLow qualityRelated question
87 people12.3 months
Symptoms cleared fastest with immediate incision and draining of the clot (1.58 days), slower with surgical removal of the hemorrhoid (7.8 days), and slowest with medical treatment alone (11.8 days). Recurrence was similar and fairly high for medical treatment and incision (19.4% and 16.1%) but no recurrences occurred after surgical excision. Bleeding was the main side effect, most common after incision, less common after surgery, which had no major complications.
- Who was studied
- elderly patients (over 75) with a painful blood clot in an external hemorrhoid (external hemorrhoidal thrombosis)
- Main outcome
- how fast symptoms went away, bleeding, recurrence, and major complications
- Quality
- Patients chose their own treatment rather than being randomly assigned, the sample was small, and it only looked at elderly patients, so the comparison between treatments is weak.
- Limitations
- Non-randomized, treatment groups self-selected by patients, small numbers per group, and the population was limited to people over 75 with acute thrombosed hemorrhoids rather than external hemorrhoids in general.
Taken word for word from the abstract
- population
87 patients aged >75 years who were visited and treated for this condition in our clinic
- primaryOutcome
We analyzed immediate pain relief and time of remission of symptoms, bleeding, recurrences and major complications.
- result
The Group A presented a remission of symptoms in 11.8 days, Group B in 1.58 ad Group C in 7.8 days. The recurrence rate was very similar for the first two options (19.4% and 16.1%) and lower in the excision group (no recurrence during follow-up). Bleeding is the common adverse event observed with a high frequency in the immediate incision and evacuation of thrombus, less common in hemorrhoidectomy, that did not present major complication.
- n
We have considered 87 patients aged >75 years
- followUp
The mean follow-up was 12.3 months.
Minerva Chir · PMID 30600960 · Read it on PubMed ↗
What actually helps, on this site
More about the condition:
All 58 studiesEvery study that answered the question, with its design, size and result.
The other 52 studiesEverything else the search returned, including anything retracted.
Benek et al. 2026
Monopolar Cautery Ablation as a Minimally Invasive Treatment Option for Grade II-III Hemorrhoidal Disease
Faster recovery, but more recurrenceRetrospectiveLow qualityRelated question
61 peopleat least one year
Monopolar cautery ablation had shorter surgery time, less pain medicine needed, faster return to daily activities, and higher satisfaction than excisional hemorrhoidectomy, but had 3 recurrences versus 0 recurrences with excisional hemorrhoidectomy (difference not statistically significant)
- Who was studied
- Adults with grade II-III hemorrhoid disease needing surgery
- What they received
- Monopolar cautery ablation (a minimally invasive surgical technique)
- Compared with
- Excisional hemorrhoidectomy (traditional surgical removal)
- Main outcome
- Operative time, pain, recovery time, satisfaction, and recurrence after surgery
- Quality
- This is a retrospective, non-randomized comparison of only 61 patients with grade II-III disease followed for just one year, so the findings are not strong evidence and may not generalize.
- Limitations
- Retrospective design, relatively short follow-up period, and the authors state findings should be interpreted cautiously; study addresses grade II-III hemorrhoidal disease generally, not specifically external hemorrhoids.
Taken word for word from the abstract
- population
61 patients who underwent surgery for symptomatic grade II-III hemorrhoidal disease between January 2022 and December 2023
- intervention
monopolar cautery ablation (MPCA)
- comparator
excisional hemorrhoidectomy (EH)
- primaryOutcome
operative time, postoperative pain scores (at the 12th hour, postoperative days 1, 7, and 14), duration of analgesic use, patient satisfaction, time to return to daily activities, postoperative complications, and recurrence rates
- result
Operative time and postoperative analgesic requirements were significantly lower in the MPCA group (both p < 0.001). The time to return to daily activities was significantly shorter in the MPCA group, while patient satisfaction was significantly higher (both p < 0.001).
- result
No recurrences were detected in the EH group, whereas three recurrences were observed in the MPCA group (p = 0.102).
- n
This retrospective study included 61 patients
Ann Ital Chir · PMID 42755308 · Read it on PubMed ↗
Pompeu et al. 2026
Laser Hemorrhoidoplasty versus Excisional Hemorrhoidectomy: The Recovery-Durability Tradeoff in Hemorrhoid Surgery-A Systematic Review of Randomized Trials
Laser surgery: easier recovery, unclear long-term cureMeta-analysisLow qualityRelated question
1,099 people2026
Laser hemorrhoidoplasty caused less pain, shorter operative time, less blood loss, shorter hospital stay, and faster return to activities, plus lower rates of bleeding, urinary retention, and anal narrowing than excisional hemorrhoidectomy, but long-term durability was uncertain due to limited follow-up.
- Who was studied
- patients having surgery for hemorrhoids (from 15 randomized trials comparing two surgical methods)
- What they received
- laser hemorrhoidoplasty (diode laser procedure)
- Compared with
- conventional excisional hemorrhoidectomy (standard surgical removal)
- Main outcome
- recovery measures (pain, operative time, hospital stay, return to activity) and complication rates after surgery
- Quality
- The review itself states the evidence is of low to very low certainty, with several outcomes underpowered and limited follow-up for long-term results.
- Limitations
- Evidence rated low to very low certainty; several outcomes remained underpowered; limited follow-up restricts interpretation of long-term outcomes; abstract does not specify that patients had external (versus internal) hemorrhoids.
Taken word for word from the abstract
- n
Fifteen RCTs involving 1099 patients were included.
- population
Randomized controlled trials (RCTs) comparing diode laser hemorrhoidoplasty with conventional hemorrhoidectomy were included.
- intervention
Laser hemorrhoidoplasty was associated with reduced postoperative pain on day 1
- comparator
Randomized controlled trials (RCTs) comparing diode laser hemorrhoidoplasty with conventional hemorrhoidectomy were included.
- primaryOutcome
This study evaluates the tradeoff between short-term recovery and long-term durability to inform patient-centered decision-making.
- result
Laser hemorrhoidoplasty was associated with reduced postoperative pain on day 1 (MD -2.02; 95% CI -2.83 to -1.20) and day 7 (MD -2.13; 95% CI -3.06 to -1.20), shorter duration of analgesic use (MD -2.72 days), operative time (MD -12.49 min), intraoperative blood loss (MD -21.63 mL), hospital stay (MD -0.63 days), and earlier return to daily activities (MD -10.78 days). It was also associated with lower rates of postoperative bleeding (RR 0.35), urinary retention (RR 0.29), and anal stenosis (RR 0.12).
- result
Laser hemorrhoidoplasty offers improved short-term recovery but with uncertain long-term durability.
Am Surg · PMID 42503488 · Read it on PubMed ↗
Zamlout et al. 2026
Laser hemorrhoidoplasty versus LigaSure hemorrhoidectomy for grade II-IV hemorrhoidal disease: a systematic review and meta-analysis
Laser less painful; standard surgery fewer recurrencesMeta-analysisVery low qualityRelated question
461 people2026
Laser hemorrhoidoplasty caused less pain, faster return to activity, shorter operation and hospital stay, but LigaSure hemorrhoidectomy had a lower recurrence rate
- Who was studied
- adults with grade II-IV hemorrhoids
- What they received
- laser hemorrhoidoplasty
- Compared with
- LigaSure hemorrhoidectomy
- Main outcome
- postoperative pain, time to return to routine activities, and recurrence
- Quality
- The authors themselves rate the certainty of evidence as very low, based on only five studies and 461 patients with risk-of-bias concerns.
- Limitations
- Only five studies with 461 total patients; certainty of evidence rated very low by the authors; further high-quality randomized trials called for.
Taken word for word from the abstract
- population
We included all eligible studies involving adults with grade II-IV hemorrhoids.
- n
Data from 461 patients (213 LHP, 248 LigH) across five studies were analyzed.
- intervention
laser hemorrhoidoplasty (LHP)
- comparator
LigaSure hemorrhoidectomy (LigH)
- primaryOutcome
Primary outcomes included postoperative pain, time to return to routine activities, and recurrence.
- result
Patients in the LHP group reported significantly lower pain scores on postoperative day 1 (MD: - 1.61 points; p = 0.025), earlier return to routine activities (MD: -5.75 days; p = 0.0002), shorter operative time (MD: -6.5 min; p = 0.002), and shorter hospital stay (MD: -0.3 days; p < 0.0001) compared to the LigH group. Conversely, LigH demonstrated a significantly lower risk of recurrence (RD: 0.12; 95% CI: [0.05, 0.19]).
- qualityWhy
The certainty of evidence is very low.
BMC Surg · PMID 42374341 · Read it on PubMed ↗
Yin et al. 2026
Preliminary Results of Open Excisional Hemorrhoidectomy Combined With 3% Polidocanol Foam Sclerotherapy in Patients With Grade IV Hemorrhoidal Disease: A Randomized Controlled Open-Label Single-Center Study
Faster recovery when sclerotherapy added to surgeryRandomised trialLow qualityRelated question
36 people1 to 2 months
Adding sclerotherapy to surgery let patients return to normal activities about 5.78 days sooner, with less post-operative bleeding and less need for pain medicine; symptom scores were better at 1-2 months; patient satisfaction was similar between groups
- Who was studied
- Adults aged 18 to 75 with grade IV hemorrhoidal disease
- What they received
- Standard surgical hemorrhoid removal (Milligan-Morgan hemorrhoidectomy) plus polidocanol foam sclerotherapy
- Compared with
- Standard surgical hemorrhoid removal (Milligan-Morgan hemorrhoidectomy) alone
- Main outcome
- Time to return to normal daily activities and work
- Quality
- Very small trial (36 patients) at a single hospital, not blinded, with short follow-up, so the findings are not very reliable.
- Limitations
- Small sample size, nonblinded, single-center design, and short follow-up period.
Taken word for word from the abstract
- population
Thirty-six patients aged 18 to 75 years with grade IV hemorrhoidal disease were enrolled and randomized equally to 2 groups.
- intervention
The experimental group underwent Milligan-Morgan hemorrhoidectomy combined with 3% polidocanol foam sclerotherapy
- comparator
the control group underwent Milligan-Morgan hemorrhoidectomy with no additional therapy
- primaryOutcome
The primary outcome was the time to return to daily activities.
- result
The experimental group demonstrated a mean 5.78-day earlier return to normal activities and work than the control group (mean ± SD: 19.28 ± 8.35 vs 25.06 ± 7.85 days; 95% CI, -11.27 to -0.29 days; p = 0.04), reduced postoperative bleeding (0-3 scale; estimate -0.45; 95% CI, -0.72 to -0.16; p = 0.002), lower analgesic use (0-3 scale; estimate -0.38; 95% CI, -0.66 to -0.09; p = 0.009), and improved symptom scores at 1 to 2 months (Z -2.52 and -2.11, p < 0.05). Median satisfaction scores were 10 versus 9.5 ( p = 0.12).
- n
Thirty-six patients aged 18 to 75 years with grade IV hemorrhoidal disease were enrolled and randomized equally to 2 groups.
Dis Colon Rectum · PMID 41603644 · Read it on PubMed ↗
Hua et al. 2025
Transverse incision with longitudinal ligation procedure: Innovation, pitfalls, and clinical perspectives
New surgery may heal faster short-termNarrative reviewVery low qualityRelated question
size not given2025
A study by Song et al found TILL to be better than the traditional Milligan-Morgan hemorrhoidectomy for short-term results, showing less pain, quicker healing, and lower risk of anal stenosis.
- Who was studied
- adults with circumferential prolapsed hemorrhoids
- What they received
- transverse incision with longitudinal ligation (TILL) surgery
- Compared with
- traditional Milligan-Morgan hemorrhoidectomy
- Main outcome
- short-term pain, healing time, and risk of anal narrowing after surgery
- Quality
- This is a commentary letter about another single-center retrospective study with a small number of patients and short follow-up, so it cannot show whether the new surgery gives a permanent cure.
- Limitations
- The letter itself states the referenced study was retrospective, single-center, had a small sample size, and short follow-up, which limits assessment of long-term outcomes like recurrence; also the condition studied is circumferential prolapsed hemorrhoids, not specifically external hemorrhoids.
Taken word for word from the abstract
- population
a new method for treating circumferential prolapsed hemorrhoids
- intervention
The transverse incision with longitudinal ligation (TILL) procedure
- comparator
the traditional Milligan-Morgan hemorrhoidectomy
- primaryOutcome
showing less pain, quicker healing, and lower risk of anal stenosis
- result
A study by Song et al found TILL to be better than the traditional Milligan-Morgan hemorrhoidectomy for short-term results, showing less pain, quicker healing, and lower risk of anal stenosis.
World J Gastroenterol · PMID 41480327 · Read it on PubMed ↗
Pletner et al. 2025
[Results of topical application of autologous regenerative products in hemorrhoidectomy]
Faster healing, same early pain.Prospective cohortLow qualityRelated question
90 peoplelong-term post-operative period (exact duration not specified)
Regenerative products sped up wound healing and improved long-term quality of life, but did not reduce pain in the early days after surgery
- Who was studied
- Adults with stage II-IV hemorrhoidal disease having surgical hemorrhoid removal
- What they received
- Topical application of autologous regenerative products (platelet-rich plasma or stromal vascular fraction) to the surgical wound after hemorrhoidectomy
- Compared with
- Standard hemorrhoidectomy without regenerative products
- Main outcome
- Wound healing rate, pain level, and quality of life after surgery
- Quality
- Small single-center study without clear randomization or blinding, and it tests an add-on to surgery rather than comparing ways to remove hemorrhoids.
- Limitations
- No explicit mention of randomization or blinding; includes mixed stage II-IV hemorrhoidal disease rather than specifically external hemorrhoids; subjective quality-of-life and pain measures.
Taken word for word from the abstract
- n
The study included 90 patients with stage II-IV HD who underwent hemorrhoidectomy using LigaSure apparatus.
- population
patients with stage II-IV HD who underwent hemorrhoidectomy using LigaSure apparatus
- intervention
Subjects of the 1st study group were administered with PRP to the postoperative wounds after the surgery, patients of the 2nd study group - with SVF.
- comparator
In the control group, autologous regenerative agents were not administered.
- primaryOutcome
To study the effect of topical application of platelet-rich autoplasma (PRP) and stromal vascular fraction (SVF) on wound healing rate, pain syndrome level and quality of life (QL) of patients after HE.
- result
The use of autologous regenerative products after HE accelerates the dynamics of the wound process and improves the quality of life of patients in the long-term post-operative period without affecting the level of pain syndrome in the first days after surgery.
Khirurgiia (Mosk) · PMID 41287172 · Read it on PubMed ↗
di Schiano di Visconte 2025
Laser Hemorrhoidoplasty: Procedure, Outcomes and Future Directions
Laser helps early disease, surgery better for advancedNarrative reviewVery low qualityRelated question
size not given2025
LHP showed clear benefits for early-grade (grade II-III) disease but had higher recurrence in Grade IV disease, where excisional methods remained superior for long-term symptom resolution
- Who was studied
- adults with hemorrhoidal disease of varying grades (not specifically external hemorrhoids)
- What they received
- laser hemorrhoidoplasty (LHP)
- Compared with
- traditional excisional surgical methods
- Main outcome
- efficacy, safety, and long-term outcomes (including recurrence and symptom resolution) across hemorrhoid grades
- Quality
- this is a narrative review without stated systematic methodology, sample sizes, or specific focus on external hemorrhoids, so it carries little weight for this exact question
- Limitations
- The abstract does not report study numbers, specifically whether hemorrhoids were external, or details of methodology; it discusses hemorrhoidal disease graded II-IV, a classification system typically used for internal/prolapsing hemorrhoids rather than external hemorrhoids specifically.
Taken word for word from the abstract
- population
the treatment of hemorrhoidal disease (HD), offering advantages such as reduced postoperative pain, shorter recovery time, and improved patient satisfaction compared with traditional surgical methods
- intervention
Laser hemorrhoidoplasty (LHP) has emerged as a minimally invasive technique for the treatment of hemorrhoidal disease (HD)
- comparator
excisional methods remain superior for managing advanced HD, particularly in terms of long-term symptom resolution
- primaryOutcome
This study critically evaluated the efficacy, safety, and long-term outcomes of LHP across different grades of hemorrhoids.
- result
Although LHP demonstrates clear benefits in the management of early-grade hemorrhoids, particularly grades II and III, its limitations are more apparent in advanced cases.
- result
higher recurrence rates, especially for Grade IV HD, remain a clinical limitation
- result
excisional methods remain superior for managing advanced HD, particularly in terms of long-term symptom resolution
ANZ J Surg · PMID 40586452 · Read it on PubMed ↗
Long et al. 2025
Milligan-Morgan hemorrhoidectomy combined with rubber band ligation and polidocanol foam sclerotherapy for the management of grade III/IV hemorrhoids: a retrospective study
Combined surgery: less recurrence, more satisfaction.RetrospectiveLow qualityRelated question
255 people12 months
The combined procedure had a lower 12-month recurrence rate (0.78% vs 7.09%), higher patient satisfaction (91.41% vs 81.10%), less pain after surgery, fewer complications (urinary retention, delayed bleeding, anal stenosis), and faster wound healing than hemorrhoidectomy alone; there was no difference in hemorrhoid severity score between groups.
- Who was studied
- adults with grade III or IV hemorrhoids (a classification usually used for internal hemorrhoids, not specifically external hemorrhoids)
- What they received
- Milligan-Morgan hemorrhoidectomy surgery combined with rubber band ligation and polidocanol foam sclerotherapy
- Compared with
- Milligan-Morgan hemorrhoidectomy surgery alone
- Main outcome
- recurrence rate, hemorrhoid severity score, and patient satisfaction 12 months after surgery
- Quality
- This is a single-center retrospective study without randomization, so differences between groups could be due to factors other than the treatment itself.
- Limitations
- Retrospective design, single center, not randomized, and the population is defined by internal hemorrhoid grading (grade III/IV) rather than specifically external hemorrhoids.
Taken word for word from the abstract
- population
A total of 255 patients with grade III/IV hemorrhoids who underwent MMH + RBL + PFS (n = 128) or MMH (n = 127) between May 2022 and June 2023 were included in the study.
- intervention
MMH + RBL + PFS
- comparator
MMH (n = 127)
- primaryOutcome
The primary outcomes included recurrence rates, hemorrhoid severity score (HSS), and patient satisfaction 12 months after surgery.
- result
the recurrence rate was lower in the MMH + RBL + PFS group (0.78%) than in the MMH group (7.09%) (p < 0.05). The patient satisfaction score was higher in the MMH + RBL + PFS group (91.41%) than in the MMH group (81.10%) (p < 0.05), and there was no significant difference in the HSS between the two groups (p > 0.05).
- n
A total of 255 patients with grade III/IV hemorrhoids who underwent MMH + RBL + PFS (n = 128) or MMH (n = 127)
BMC Gastroenterol · PMID 40346473 · Read it on PubMed ↗
Gravante et al. 2025
Assessment of long-term outcomes following Milligan-Morgan hemorrhoidectomy with Doppler transperineal ultrasound and endoscopy: a pilot study
Imaging shows recurrence signs in some after surgeryProspective cohortLow qualityRelated question
23 people26 months (range 14-48)
65.2% of patients had a persistent Doppler vascular pattern, which was linked to endoscopic signs of recurrence, while its absence predicted no internal recurrence in all cases
- Who was studied
- adults who had surgical removal of hemorrhoids (Milligan-Morgan hemorrhoidectomy) for advanced hemorrhoidal disease
- What they received
- Milligan-Morgan surgical hemorrhoidectomy
- Compared with
- none (single group followed after surgery, no comparison treatment)
- Main outcome
- long-term ultrasound and endoscopic findings after surgery and how they relate to residual symptoms and recurrence
- Quality
- this is a small pilot study of only 23 patients with no comparison group, so it mainly tests an imaging method rather than proving a cure.
- Limitations
- small pilot sample, no control group, and the study examines internal recurrence patterns via imaging rather than directly evaluating external hemorrhoid cure or symptom resolution
Taken word for word from the abstract
- population
patients who underwent Milligan-Morgan hemorrhoidectomy
- intervention
Milligan-Morgan hemorrhoidectomy (MM)
- comparator
A consecutive series of MM patients treated between February 2020 and December 2023 were contacted
- primaryOutcome
Outcome measures consisted of the description of Doppler TPUS modifications following MM, and their relationship with clinical and endoscopic findings.
- result
Fifteen patients had a Doppler vascular pattern (65.2%), eight patients a scattered pattern (34.8%). No correlation was present between residual symptoms and the Doppler vascular pattern (p = 0.089). The vascular pattern was associated with endoscopic signs of recurrences (p = 0.003), and its absence was able to predict the lack of internal recurrences in all patients (100%).
- n
Twenty-three patients were available for the analysis at 26 months of follow-up (range 14-48).
Int J Colorectal Dis · PMID 40310510 · Read it on PubMed ↗
van Oostendorp et al. 2025
Comparison of Rubber Band Ligation and Hemorrhoidectomy in Patients With Symptomatic Hemorrhoids Grade III: A Multicenter, Open-Label, Randomized Controlled Noninferiority Trial
Surgery better long-term; banding faster recoveryRandomised trialLow qualityRelated question
87 people12 months
Hemorrhoidectomy gave better quality of life and far fewer recurrences than banding, while banding caused less pain and faster return to work
- Who was studied
- adults with symptomatic grade III (internal) hemorrhoids
- What they received
- rubber band ligation
- Compared with
- hemorrhoidectomy (surgical removal)
- Main outcome
- quality of life and recurrence rate at 12 months
- Quality
- The trial was stopped early for lack of funding, leaving a small sample and limited power to detect differences reliably.
- Limitations
- Early termination due to funding constraints, small sample size, limited statistical power, recruitment hindered by patient preferences and COVID-19
Taken word for word from the abstract
- population
Patients (aged 18 years or older) with symptomatic grade III (Goligher) hemorrhoids were included in this study.
- intervention
Randomized 1:1 to rubber band ligation or hemorrhoidectomy, with up to 2 banding sessions allowed.
- comparator
Hemorrhoidectomy is the criterion standard, but rubber band ligation offers a less invasive outpatient alternative.
- primaryOutcome
Primary outcomes included 12-month health-related quality of life and recurrence rate.
- result
Recurrence rate was worse in the rubber band ligation group (47.5% vs 6.1%), with an absolute risk difference of 41% (95% CI, 24%-59%).
- result
Pain scores after hemorrhoidectomy were higher during the first week (visual analogue scale 4 vs 1; p = 0.002).
- result
Rubber band ligation group returned to work sooner (1 vs 9 days; p = 0.021).
- n
Eighty-seven patients were randomly assigned (47 rubber band ligation vs 40 hemorrhoidectomy).
Dis Colon Rectum · PMID 39952268 · Read it on PubMed ↗
Jin et al. 2025
The prevalence of incontinence after excisional hemorrhoidectomy and stapled hemorrhoidopexy: A systematic review and meta-analysis
Low, similar incontinence risk for both surgeriesMeta-analysisModerate qualityRelated question
31,132 peopleearly (<3 months) and late (≥3 months)
no significant difference in incontinence risk between the two surgical approaches, with overall rates of 5.32% early and 2.48% late incontinence in randomized trials
- Who was studied
- adults having surgery for symptomatic hemorrhoids (not specified as external only)
- What they received
- excisional hemorrhoidectomy
- Compared with
- stapled hemorrhoidopexy
- Main outcome
- rate of fecal incontinence after surgery (early <3 months and late ≥3 months)
- Quality
- it pools many trials and large numbers of patients but the abstract notes considerable heterogeneity from differing definitions and reporting of incontinence across studies
- Limitations
- substantial heterogeneity across studies in how incontinence was assessed and reported; population not restricted to external hemorrhoids
Taken word for word from the abstract
- n
68 randomized controlled trials with 8,445 participants and 71 observational studies with 22,687 participants
- population
treating symptomatic hemorrhoids
- intervention
Excisional hemorrhoidectomy
- comparator
stapled hemorrhoidopexy
- primaryOutcome
Primary outcomes included early (<3 months) and late (≥3 months) fecal incontinence.
- result
There was no significant difference in the risk of incontinence or other postoperative complications between stapled hemorrhoidopexy and excisional hemorrhoidectomy, both in randomized controlled trials and nonrandomized controlled trials.
- result
Early incontinence rates were 5.32% in randomized controlled trials (95% confidence interval, 2.74-8.51%)
- result
Late incontinence rates were 2.48% in randomized controlled trials (95% confidence interval, 1.09-4.25%)
Surgery · PMID 39854786 · Read it on PubMed ↗
Jee et al. 2024
Conventional Excisional Haemorrhoidectomy versus Transanal Haemorrhoidal Dearterialization for Haemorrhoids: A Systematic Review and Meta-Analysis
Surgery cured more, but slower recoveryMeta-analysisModerate qualityRelated question
465 people2024
Excisional surgery had lower recurrence than THD, but patients took about two weeks longer to return to normal activity; complication rates were similar between the two
- Who was studied
- adults having surgery for hemorrhoids (not specified as external-only)
- What they received
- conventional excisional haemorrhoidectomy (full surgical removal)
- Compared with
- transanal haemorrhoidal dearterialization (THD, a less invasive procedure)
- Main outcome
- hemorrhoids coming back (recurrence)
- Quality
- This pools 6 randomized trials totaling 465 patients, which is a reasonable evidence base, but the recurrence difference had a wide confidence interval (just barely significant) and the abstract does not specify whether hemorrhoids were external, internal, or mixed.
- Limitations
- Only 6 RCTs included; recurrence result had a wide confidence interval (1.03-7.38) suggesting uncertainty; abstract does not specify external vs internal hemorrhoids, so it may not isolate the population in question.
Taken word for word from the abstract
- n
A total of 6 RCTs encompassing 465 patients were captured.
- population
There were 142 (59%) males in the CEH group and 129 (54%) in the THD group.
- intervention
conventional excisional haemorrhoidectomy (CEH)
- comparator
transanal haemorrhoidal dearterialization (THD)
- primaryOutcome
The primary objective was recurrence.
- result
THD had a higher recurrence rate (odds ratio = 2.76, 95% confidence interval [CI] = 1.03-7.38, p = 0.04) albeit a shorter return to baseline compared to CEH (mean difference = -14.05 days, 95% CI = -20.38 to -7.72, p < 0.0001).
Dig Surg · PMID 39084191 · Read it on PubMed ↗
Chen et al. 2024
Clinical outcomes of laser hemorrhoidoplasty with feeding vessels suture ligation: a retrospective study in a single center
Less pain than standard surgery.RetrospectiveLow qualityRelated question
323 people2024
The laser group had less pain after surgery and before discharge, and lower rates of urinary retention compared to traditional surgery; recurrence data were collected but not reported in the results given
- Who was studied
- adults with grade II-III hemorrhoids (internal hemorrhoid grading system)
- What they received
- laser hemorrhoidoplasty with suture ligation of feeding vessels
- Compared with
- Milligan-Morgan hemorrhoidectomy (traditional surgery)
- Main outcome
- postoperative pain, discomfort, recurrence, and complications
- Quality
- It is a retrospective, single-center comparison without randomization, so differences between groups could be due to patient selection rather than the treatment itself.
- Limitations
- Retrospective design, single center, no randomization, and the abstract does not report recurrence outcomes despite stating they were collected.
Taken word for word from the abstract
- population
patients with symptomatic grade II-III hemorrhoids
- intervention
laser hemorrhoidoplasty with feeding vessel suture ligation
- comparator
Milligan-Morgan hemorrhoidectomy
- primaryOutcome
postoperative pain, discomfort after discharge, hemorrhoid recurrence, and any complications were collected
- result
the LHP group exhibited superior performance compared to traditional surgery at postoperative 4 h, before discharge, and during the first and second outpatient visits, with statistically significant differences. Additionally, the LHP group had a lower rate of urinary retention and experienced significantly less pain
- n
The study included 323 patients, with 173 undergoing laser hemorrhoidoplasty (LHP) and 150 undergoing Milligan-Morgan hemorrhoidectomy.
Tech Coloproctol · PMID 38955875 · Read it on PubMed ↗
Cheng et al. 2024
Diode laser hemorrhoidoplasty versus conventional Milligan-Morgan and Ferguson hemorrhoidectomy for symptomatic hemorrhoids: Meta-analysis
Laser surgery: less bleeding and pain, same recurrence.Meta-analysisModerate qualityRelated question
1,196 people2024
Laser surgery caused less blood loss, less post-op bleeding, shorter operation time, less pain on day 1, and less anal narrowing than conventional surgery, but rates of incontinence, urinary retention, and hemorrhoid coming back again were similar between the two.
- Who was studied
- adults with symptomatic hemorrhoids undergoing surgical removal
- What they received
- diode laser hemorrhoidoplasty
- Compared with
- conventional hemorrhoidectomy (Milligan-Morgan and Ferguson techniques)
- Main outcome
- amount of bleeding during surgery and after surgery
- Quality
- It pools 17 trials with over a thousand patients, but the hemorrhoids are not specified as external, and the abstract does not separately report blinding or overall risk of bias for all included trials beyond mentioning a subgroup with low risk of bias.
- Limitations
- The abstract does not specify whether patients had external, internal, or mixed hemorrhoids, and does not report long-term follow-up duration for recurrence.
Taken word for word from the abstract
- population
Conventional hemorrhoidectomy is the mainstay of treatment for symptomatic haemorrhoids
- n
we included 17 trials with 1196 patients, of whom 596 (49.8 %) underwent laser hemorrhoidoplasty and 600 (50.2 %) underwent conventional hemorrhoidectomy
- intervention
laser hemorrhoidoplasty
- comparator
conventional hemorrhoidectomies, including Milligan-Morgan and Ferguson techniques
- primaryOutcome
The primary outcomes were operative blood loss and postoperative haemorrhage
- result
we found that laser hemorrhoidoplasty showed benefits in operative blood loss (weighted mean difference [WMD]: -16.43 ml, 95 % confidence interval [CI]: -23.82 to -9.04), postoperative hemorrhage/bleeding (odds ratio [OR]: 0.16, 95 % CI: 0.10 to 0.28), operative time (WMD: -12.42 min, 95 % CI: -14.56 to -10.28), postoperative pain score on day 1 (WMD: -2.50, 95 % CI: -3.13 to -1.88), and anal stenosis (OR: 0.14, 95 % CI: 0.03 to 0.65) in comparison with conventional hemorrhoidectomy
- result
incidence of fecal/flatus incontinence, urinary retention and hemorrhoid recurrence were not significantly different between the 2 groups
Asian J Surg · PMID 38762410 · Read it on PubMed ↗
Nada et al. 2024
Comparison between stapled hemorrhoidopexy and harmonic scalpel hemorrhoidectomy in the management of third- and fourth-degree piles: a randomized clinical trial
Harmonic scalpel surgery, fewer recurrences than stapling.Randomised trialLow qualityRelated question
70 people1 year
Harmonic scalpel surgery had less bleeding and far fewer recurrences at 1 year (2.9% vs 20%) and higher satisfaction, though stapling was faster and had less pain in the first 2 weeks.
- Who was studied
- adults with grade III and grade IV piles (internal hemorrhoids with prolapse)
- What they received
- harmonic scalpel hemorrhoidectomy (surgical removal using an ultrasonic cutting device)
- Compared with
- stapled hemorrhoidopexy (stapling device procedure)
- Main outcome
- procedure time, pain, patient satisfaction, wound infection, bleeding, incontinence, and recurrence within 1 year
- Quality
- Single-center, single-blind trial with modest size (70 patients) and multiple outcomes tested, raising the chance some differences are due to chance.
- Limitations
- Single-center, single-blind design; population is grade III/IV piles (internal hemorrhoids with prolapse), not specifically external hemorrhoids; some reported differences (e.g. wound infection) were not statistically significant.
Taken word for word from the abstract
- population
50 (68.75%) male and 20 (31.25%) female patients with third- and fourth-degree piles
- intervention
group II underwent HSH
- comparator
Group I underwent SH
- primaryOutcome
regarding the time of the procedure, postoperative pain, patient satisfaction, wound infection, bleeding, incontinence, and recurrence within 1 year
- result
There were 7 (20%) cases of recurrence at the 1‑year follow-up in group I and 1 (2.9%) case in group II (p = 0.024)
- result
Postoperative bleeding occurred in 4 (11.4%) patients in group I in the form of spotting after defecation only during the first postoperative month; no bleeding was detected in group II (p = 0.039)
- result
In group II there was significant improvement in pain after 2 weeks, with higher patient satisfaction
- n
50 (68.75%) male and 20 (31.25%) female patients
Chirurgie (Heidelb) · PMID 38157069 · Read it on PubMed ↗
Long et al. 2023
Milligan-Morgan hemorrhoidectomy combined with non-doppler hemorrhoidal artery ligation for the treatment of grade III/IV hemorrhoids: a single centre retrospective study
Added artery ligation cut pain and recurrence.RetrospectiveLow qualityRelated question
115 people12 months after surgery
the combined procedure caused less pain, less bleeding, less swelling, less urinary retention, lower recurrence at 12 months, and higher satisfaction than surgery alone
- Who was studied
- adults with grade III or IV hemorrhoids (an internal hemorrhoid staging system, not specifically defined as external hemorrhoids)
- What they received
- surgical removal (Milligan-Morgan hemorrhoidectomy) combined with non-Doppler ligation of the hemorrhoid blood vessels
- Compared with
- surgical removal (Milligan-Morgan hemorrhoidectomy) alone
- Main outcome
- post-surgery pain, bleeding, swelling, recurrence, and patient satisfaction
- Quality
- it is a retrospective, single-centre comparison of two surgical techniques without randomization, so other differences between the patient groups could explain the results.
- Limitations
- retrospective design, single centre, not randomized, and patients had grade III/IV hemorrhoids rather than being specifically characterized as external hemorrhoids.
Taken word for word from the abstract
- n
115 patients with grade III/IV hemorrhoids
- population
115 patients with grade III/IV hemorrhoids
- intervention
MMH combined with non-Doppler hemorrhoidal artery ligation (MMH + ND-HAL)
- comparator
the remaining 62 patients received MMH
- primaryOutcome
postoperative visual analog scale (VAS) for pain, analgesic consumption, postoperative bleeding, perianal incision edema, urinary retention, anal stenosis, anal incontinence incidence, recurrence rate (prolapse or bleeding), and patient satisfaction
- result
the recurrence rate (prolapse or bleeding) was lower in the MMH + ND-HAL group than in the MMH group (P < 0.05), and satisfaction was higher in the MMH + ND-HAL group than in the MMH group (P < 0.05)
BMC Gastroenterol · PMID 37653473 · Read it on PubMed ↗
Liu et al. 2024
Role of antibiotics in Milligan-Morgan hemorrhoidectomy for Grade III to IV Hemorrhoids: A randomized clinical trial
Surgery worked; antibiotics added no benefit.Randomised trialModerate qualityRelated question
150 people1 year
no significant difference between antibiotic and no-antibiotic groups in pain, defecation time, wound edema, bleeding, urinary retention, or infection markers; recurrence after surgery was 1.4% at 1 year
- Who was studied
- adults with grade III to IV prolapsing hemorrhoids having Milligan-Morgan surgical hemorrhoid removal
- What they received
- intravenous antibiotics (cefoxitin) given before and/or after surgery
- Compared with
- no antibiotics
- Main outcome
- post-surgery pain, complications, infection markers, and 1-year recurrence
- Quality
- it is a randomized trial but only 50 patients per group and it studies antibiotic use rather than comparing different ways to remove hemorrhoids, and the hemorrhoids studied are internal/prolapsing grade III-IV rather than specifically external hemorrhoids.
- Limitations
- Small group sizes (about 50 per arm); population is grade III/IV prolapsing hemorrhoids (mixed internal/external), not specifically external hemorrhoids; focus is on antibiotic prophylaxis, not on comparing removal approaches.
Taken word for word from the abstract
- population
patients undergoing Milligan Morgan hemorrhoidectomy (MMH) in a tertiary hospital for grade III/IV hemorrhoids
- intervention
group B received 2 g I/V Cefoxitin Sodium before the induction of anesthesia, and group C received 2 g I/V Cefoxitin Sodium before the induction of anesthesia and 6 h after operation
- comparator
Group A did not receive any prophylactic antibiotic
- primaryOutcome
compare the safety and long-term clinical efficacy of using intravenous antibiotics in Milligan Morgan hemorrhoidectomy for Grade III to IV Prolapsing Hemorrhoids
- result
there was no significant difference among the first defecation time, wound edema, bleeding, urinary retention after surgery (p> 0.05)
- result
the rate of recurrence of hemorrhoids follow-up for 1 year was 1.4%
- n
A total of 150 consecutive patients undergoing Milligan Morgan hemorrhoidectomy (MMH)
Asian J Surg · PMID 37451888 · Read it on PubMed ↗
Trenti et al. 2023
Transanal Hemorrhoidal Dearterialization With Mucopexy Versus Vessel-Sealing Device Hemorrhoidectomy for Grade III to IV Hemorrhoids: Long-term Outcomes From the THDLIGA Randomized Controlled Trial
Similar long-term recurrence, no clear winnerRandomised trialModerate qualityRelated question
80 people2 years
no significant difference in symptom recurrence between the two procedures at 2 years
- Who was studied
- adults with grade III to IV hemorrhoids (internal hemorrhoid grading system)
- What they received
- transanal hemorrhoidal dearterialization with mucopexy
- Compared with
- vessel-sealing device hemorrhoidectomy
- Main outcome
- hemorrhoid symptom recurrence at 2 years, measured by questionnaire
- Quality
- it was a multicenter randomized trial, but patients were lost to follow-up, there was no stratification by hemorrhoid grade, and the study was not statistically powered for this long-term endpoint.
- Limitations
- Lack of stratification for hemorrhoid grade and power calculation based on the main outcome trial but not on the end point of this long-term study.
Taken word for word from the abstract
- population
Patients ≥18 years of age with grade III to IV hemorrhoids were included in the study.
- intervention
transanal hemorrhoidal dearterialization (n = 39)
- comparator
vessel-sealing device hemorrhoidectomy (n = 41)
- primaryOutcome
The primary outcome was hemorrhoid symptom recurrence assessed by a specific questionnaire 2 years postoperatively.
- result
The differences between mean baseline and mean 2-year score in the 2 groups were similar (-11.0, SD 3.8 vs -12.5, SD 3.6; p = 0.080).
- n
Five of the 80 patients included in the study were lost to follow-up.
- followUp
assessed by a specific questionnaire 2 years postoperatively
Dis Colon Rectum · PMID 35239526 · Read it on PubMed ↗
Zhang et al. 2022
LigaSure hemorrhoidectomy versus the procedure for prolapse and hemorrhoids: A meta-analysis of randomized controlled trials
Fewer recurrences, faster surgery with LigaSureMeta-analysisModerate qualityRelated question
397 people2022
LigaSure had a lower recurrence rate and shorter operating time than PPH, but no significant difference in pain, time off work, or complications
- Who was studied
- adults having surgery for symptomatic hemorrhoids (not specified as external only)
- What they received
- LigaSure hemorrhoidectomy (a sealing/cutting surgical device)
- Compared with
- PPH, the stapling procedure for prolapse and hemorrhoids
- Main outcome
- recurrence rate, operating time, pain after surgery, and complications
- Quality
- it pools 5 randomized trials but only 397 patients total, uses older studies, and reports only short-term outcomes
- Limitations
- small number of trials and patients, no long-term follow-up, population is hemorrhoids generally rather than specifically external hemorrhoids, and PPH is designed for prolapsing/internal hemorrhoids rather than external ones
Taken word for word from the abstract
- n
A total of 5 studies involving 397 participants were included in this review.
- intervention
LigaSure hemorrhoidectomy
- comparator
the procedure for prolapse and hemorrhoids (PPH)
- primaryOutcome
This review aimed to evaluate and compare their short-term outcomes.
- result
the LigaSure procedure was associated with significantly lower recurrence rate [relative risk (RR) = 0.21, 95% confidence interval (CI): 0.06 to 0.72, P = .01] and significantly shorter operating time [mean difference (MD) = -6.39, 95% CI: -7.68 to -5.10, P < .001]. The analysis showed no significant difference in postoperative pain between the two techniques (MD = 0.55, 95% CI: -0.15 to 1.25, P = .12] or in time off work or away from normal activity
- population
LigaSure hemorrhoidectomy and the procedure for prolapse and hemorrhoids (PPH) are both relatively new treatments for managing symptomatic hemorrhoids.
Medicine (Baltimore) · PMID 35060505 · Read it on PubMed ↗
Abe et al. 2022
Long-term Outcomes of Aluminum Potassium Sulfate and Tannic Acid Sclerotherapy for Prolapsed Hemorrhoids: A Single-Center, Observational Study
Recurrence rises a lot over years.RetrospectiveLow qualityRelated question
1,180 people9 years
Recurrence climbed steadily over time (7.4% at 3 years, 27.2% at 6 years, 47.5% at 9 years), while serious complications were uncommon (fever, rectal ulcer, stricture, or abscess in under 2% each)
- Who was studied
- Adults with prolapsed (internal) hemorrhoids, grades II to IV
- What they received
- Injection sclerotherapy using aluminum potassium sulfate and tannic acid
- Main outcome
- Hemorrhoid recurrence and complications over time
- Quality
- This was a retrospective, single-center study with no comparison group, and fewer patients kept returning for follow-up after 3 years, so later recurrence numbers are less reliable.
- Limitations
- Retrospective, nonrandomized, single-center design; follow-up visits after 3 years were optional and attendance declined over time.
Taken word for word from the abstract
- n
In total, 1180 patients with grade II to IV hemorrhoids treated with injection sclerotherapy were enrolled.
- population
In total, 1180 patients with grade II to IV hemorrhoids treated with injection sclerotherapy were enrolled.
- intervention
Sclerotherapy using aluminum potassium sulfate and tannic acid offers reasonable long-term results and is associated with low complication rates.
- primaryOutcome
Efficacy measures included cumulative recurrence rates and postoperative complications.
- result
Recurrence rates at 3, 6, and 9 years were 7.4%, 27.2%, and 47.5%.
- result
Postoperative complications included fever ≥38°C in 16 (1.4%) patients, rectal ulcer in 10 (0.9%) patients, rectal stricture in 5 (0.4%) patients, and perianal abscess in 4 (0.3%) patients.
Dis Colon Rectum · PMID 34990425 · Read it on PubMed ↗
Yardimci 2021
Less postoperative pain and more frequent recurrence: Can this dilemma caused by the stapled haemorrhoidopexy procedure be avoided?
Mixed results with added proceduresRetrospectiveLow qualityRelated question
106 people15 days (pain); longer-term follow-up for recurrence not specified
Recurrence rate was 13.2% overall and differed significantly between subgroups; pain scores decreased significantly only in the group with Grade III disease treated with stapling alone; satisfaction did not differ significantly between groups
- Who was studied
- Adults with Grade III-IV hemorrhoids (internal, some with external prolapse)
- What they received
- Stapled hemorrhoidopexy with additional repair procedures
- Compared with
- Stapled hemorrhoidopexy alone
- Main outcome
- Pain scores, wound healing, patient satisfaction, and recurrence rate
- Quality
- Small, non-randomized comparison of subgroups undergoing different combinations of procedures, so it cannot reliably show which approach is better.
- Limitations
- Not randomized; subgroups based on hemorrhoid grade and surgeon choice of additional interventions; no comparison to non-surgical treatments; focus is on internal (Grade III-IV) hemorrhoids rather than external hemorrhoids specifically.
Taken word for word from the abstract
- population
A total of 106 patients with Grade III-IV haemorrhoids diagnosed between 2016 and 2018 were included.
- intervention
The aim of our study was to investigate whether the above-mentioned problems could be prevented by performing additional interventions (AIs) during SH.
- comparator
We compared SH with and without AIs in terms of pain, wound-healing time, patient satisfaction and recurrence.
- primaryOutcome
We compared SH with and without AIs in terms of pain, wound-healing time, patient satisfaction and recurrence.
- result
The overall recurrence rate was 13.2% and the difference among subgroups was significant (P = .023).
- result
Subgroup 1 (Grade III; SH alone) showed significant decreases in the visual analogue scale pain scores on days 1 and 15 (P = .004), but no significant decreases were found in subgroups 2-4 (P = .839, P = .092, and P = .781, respectively).
- n
A total of 106 patients with Grade III-IV haemorrhoids diagnosed between 2016 and 2018 were included.
Int J Clin Pract · PMID 34637188 · Read it on PubMed ↗
Feo et al. 2023
Open Hemorrhoidectomy With Ligasure™ Under Local or Spinal Anesthesia: A Comparative Study
Surgical removal worked, no recurrence seenRetrospectiveLow qualityRelated question
62 peoplelong-term follow-up
No recurrences were seen and no differences in pain, complications, reoperation rate or satisfaction between local and spinal anesthesia groups at long-term follow-up
- Who was studied
- adults with grade III or IV hemorrhoids
- What they received
- surgical removal of hemorrhoids (open hemorrhoidectomy with LigaSure device)
- Main outcome
- pain, complications, reoperation, recurrence and patient satisfaction after surgery
- Quality
- Small, non-randomized comparison of only 62 patients with internal (grade III/IV) hemorrhoids, not specifically external hemorrhoids, comparing anesthesia type rather than treatment approaches.
- Limitations
- Small sample size, not randomized, groups defined by setting (clinic vs operating room) rather than by treatment type, and population is graded by internal hemorrhoid (Goligher) classification rather than external hemorrhoids.
Taken word for word from the abstract
- n
Sixty-two patients with grade III or IV hemorrhoids underwent open hemorrhoidectomy with LigaSure™ between 2018 and 2020.
- population
Sixty-two patients with grade III or IV hemorrhoids underwent open hemorrhoidectomy with LigaSure™ between 2018 and 2020.
- intervention
open hemorrhoidectomy with LigaSure™
- primaryOutcome
No significant differences were observed in postoperative pain score (P = .85), perioperative complications (P = .51), and reoperation rate (P = .96).
- result
No recurrences and no differences in patients' satisfaction degree (P = .76) were documented at long-term follow-up in both study groups.
Am Surg · PMID 34382441 · Read it on PubMed ↗
Yu et al. 2021
Efficacy of Ruiyun procedure for hemorrhoids combined simplified Milligan-Morgan hemorrhoidectomy with dentate line-sparing in treating grade III/IV hemorrhoids: a retrospective study
Fewer complications, faster healing, lower recurrence.RetrospectiveLow qualityRelated question
452 people12 months
No significant difference in cure rate between the two surgeries; recurrence at 12 months was lower with the combined RPH+sMMH technique (3.0%) than with standard MMH (7.8%); wound healing and return to work were faster, pain was less, and complication rate was lower (8.6% vs 16.3%) with RPH+sMMH
- Who was studied
- Adults with grade III or IV hemorrhoids (internal hemorrhoids with prolapse, combined with external hemorrhoids)
- What they received
- Combined surgical technique: Ruiyun procedure for hemorrhoids plus a simplified Milligan-Morgan hemorrhoidectomy, sparing the dentate line (RPH + sMMH)
- Compared with
- Standard Milligan-Morgan hemorrhoidectomy (MMH)
- Main outcome
- Cure rate 3 months after surgery, and recurrence rate within 12 months after surgery
- Quality
- This was a retrospective, non-randomized comparison of two surgical techniques at one hospital, so differences between groups may not be due to the surgery alone.
- Limitations
- Retrospective design without randomization, single center, and the population includes combined internal and external hemorrhoids (grade III/IV) rather than external hemorrhoids specifically.
Taken word for word from the abstract
- population
Total 452 patients with hemorrhoids of grade III/IV were retrospectively reviewed
- intervention
Ruiyun procedure for hemorrhoids combined simplified Milligan-Morgan hemorrhoidectomy with dentate line-sparing (RPH + sMMH)
- comparator
208 cases in MMH group
- primaryOutcome
The primary efficacy outcome was rate of curative at 3 month after operation, and the recurrence rate within 12 months post operation.
- result
There was no statistically significant difference between the two groups in the curative rate. The recurrence rate after 12 months post operation in the RPH + sMMH (3.0%) was significantly lower than the sMMH group (7.8%) (P = 0.032).
- result
The total rate of patients with postoperative complications in the RPH + sMMH group (8.6%) was significant lower than the MMH group (16.3%) (P = 0.012).
- n
Total 452 patients with hemorrhoids of grade III/IV were retrospectively reviewed
- followUp
recurrence rate within 12 months post operation
BMC Surg · PMID 34016101 · Read it on PubMed ↗
Rho et al. 2021
Ligasure Hemorrhoidectomy: Updates on Complications After an 18-Year Experience
Surgery, low complication rate, some recurrenceCase seriesLow qualityRelated question
1,454 people2021
early complications in 2.1%, late complications in 5.8% (including anal stenosis 3.6%), long-term complications in 5.3% with recurrence in 4.8% of patients
- Who was studied
- adults with grade III and IV hemorrhoids (internal hemorrhoid grading)
- What they received
- surgical removal of hemorrhoids using an energy device (LigaSure hemorrhoidectomy)
- Main outcome
- rate of complications after surgery, pain, time in hospital, time to return to work
- Quality
- this is a single-center case series with no comparison group, so it cannot show whether this surgery works better than other options.
- Limitations
- no comparator group, single center, and the hemorrhoids treated were graded III/IV (an internal hemorrhoid staging system) rather than being specifically described as external hemorrhoids
Taken word for word from the abstract
- population
1454 consecutive patients, treated with LH for grade III and IV hemorrhoids, were analyzed
- intervention
LigaSureTM hemorrhoidectomy (LH)
- n
1454 consecutive patients
- primaryOutcome
analyzing main post-operative complications rate, length of stay, operating time, and time to return to work
- result
Early complications rate was 2.1%
- result
Late complications rate was 5.8%
- result
The long term complications rate was 5.3%: anal fistula, soiling, perianal abscess, and recurrence were identified in 0.2%, 0.1%, 0.3%, and 4.8% of patients, respectively
Rev Recent Clin Trials · PMID 33023436 · Read it on PubMed ↗
Eberspacher et al. 2020
Caiman Versus LigaSure Hemorrhoidectomy: Postoperative Pain, Early Complications, Long-Term Follow-up, and Costs
Two surgical devices, similar resultsRetrospectiveLow qualityRelated question
70 people12 months
no statistically significant differences between Caiman and LigaSure in operative time, pain scores at 1 day and 1 week, or bleeding
- Who was studied
- adults undergoing surgical hemorrhoid removal (hemorrhoidectomy), not specified as external hemorrhoids only
- What they received
- hemorrhoidectomy using the Caiman radiofrequency sealing device
- Compared with
- hemorrhoidectomy using the LigaSure radiofrequency sealing device
- Main outcome
- operative time, postoperative pain, bleeding and complications after surgery
- Quality
- this was a non-randomized comparison using a historical control group with only 35 patients per group, so it cannot reliably rule out differences between the two surgical methods.
- Limitations
- non-randomized design with historical controls, small sample size, and no clear statement that participants had external (rather than internal or mixed) hemorrhoids
Taken word for word from the abstract
- population
A total of 35 patients were enrolled in this study between January 2015 and December 2017
- intervention
35 (Group A: Caiman) patients
- comparator
35 control patients (Group B) from our historical cohort, treated with LigaSure
- primaryOutcome
intraoperative (operative time, number of piles removed, necessity of stiches or ligation), immediate postoperative (pain, bleeding within 4 weeks, incontinence, soiling within 4 weeks, healing time of anal wounds, return to working activities)
- result
There were no statistically significant differences between the 2 groups in analyzed intraoperative data: operative time (Group A 35 minutes vs Group B 33 minutes; P = .198) and stitches used.
- result
Postoperative data were comparable too, in particular pain (Group A 1 day Visual Analog Score = 6.25 vs Group B = 5.4, P = .178; Group A 1 week Visual Analog Score = 2.7 vs Group B = 1.14, P = .22) and bleeding (Group A = 2 vs Group B = 4; P = .2).
- n
A total of 35 patients were enrolled in this study
Surg Innov · PMID 32133936 · Read it on PubMed ↗
Rørvik et al. 2020
Minimal Open Hemorrhoidectomy Versus Transanal Hemorrhoidal Dearterialization: The Effect on Symptoms: An Open-Label Randomized Controlled Trial
Similar symptoms; surgery had less recurrenceRandomised trialModerate qualityRelated question
98 people1 year
no significant difference in symptom score at 1 year, but the hemorrhoidectomy group had less residual prolapse, higher patient satisfaction, and fewer patients needing further treatment for recurrence
- Who was studied
- adults with symptomatic hemorrhoids grade II to IV (internal hemorrhoid grading system)
- What they received
- minimal open surgical removal of hemorrhoids (hemorrhoidectomy)
- Compared with
- transanal hemorrhoidal dearterialization (a procedure that ties off the blood vessels feeding the hemorrhoids)
- Main outcome
- patient-reported hemorrhoid symptom score one year after surgery
- Quality
- it was a randomized trial but without blinding, done at only one center, with fairly small numbers of patients in each group.
- Limitations
- no blinding of patients or providers was used in this study
Taken word for word from the abstract
- population
Patients with symptomatic hemorrhoids grade II to IV (Goligher's classification) were included.
- intervention
minimal open hemorrhoidectomy
- comparator
transanal hemorrhoidal dearterialization
- primaryOutcome
The primary outcome was symptoms assessed by the Hemorrhoidal Disease Symptom Score 1 year postoperatively.
- result
No difference in symptom score at 1-year follow-up was found.
- result
Residual hemorrhoidal prolapse was reported more frequently (p = 0.008), and more patients had treatment for recurrence after transanal hemorrhoidal dearterialization (7 vs 0 patients; p = 0.013).
- result
Patient satisfaction was higher after minimal open hemorrhoidectomy (p = 0.049).
- n
Forty-eight patients received minimal open hemorrhoidectomy, and 50 patients received transanal hemorrhoidal dearterialization.
- limitations
No blinding was included in this study.
Dis Colon Rectum · PMID 31996581 · Read it on PubMed ↗
Poskus et al. 2020
Results of the double-blind randomized controlled trial comparing laser hemorrhoidoplasty with sutured mucopexy and excisional hemorrhoidectomy
Surgery cured most; laser less painful.Randomised trialModerate qualityRelated question
121 people1 year
Excisional hemorrhoidectomy had the lowest recurrence (0%) compared with laser hemorrhoidoplasty (10%) and mucopexy (22%), but laser and mucopexy caused less pain and allowed faster return to activity than hemorrhoidectomy; patients rated laser treatment most favorably overall
- Who was studied
- adults with symptomatic internal (2nd or 3rd degree) hemorrhoids
- What they received
- laser hemorrhoidoplasty, sutured mucopexy, and excisional hemorrhoidectomy (three surgical approaches compared)
- Main outcome
- recurrence of symptoms needing further treatment, post-operative pain, quality of life, and return to normal activity
- Quality
- It was a well-designed double-blind randomized trial, but it was conducted at a single center and studied internal (2nd/3rd degree) hemorrhoids rather than external hemorrhoids, so it doesn't directly answer the question asked.
- Limitations
- Single-center study; population had internal (graded) hemorrhoids, not external hemorrhoids as specified in the question.
Taken word for word from the abstract
- n
A total of 121 patients.
- population
Symptomatic 2nd- or 3rd-degree hemorrhoids patients.
- intervention
To compare the results of laser hemorrhoidoplasty (LHP), excisional hemorrhoidectomy (EH), and sutured mucopexy (MP).
- primaryOutcome
Recurrence of symptoms requiring treatment, intensity, and duration of pain after the operation, patients' quality of life, fecal incontinence, and patients' evaluation of treatment.
- result
Recurrence requiring treatment rate was 0% after EH, 10% after LHP, and 22% after MP, p = 0.004. LHP and MP were less painful than EH, p < 0.001.
- result
Patients evaluate LHP better than EH and MP.
Int J Colorectal Dis · PMID 31912268 · Read it on PubMed ↗
Du et al. 2019
Comparison of surgical procedures implemented in recent years for patients with grade III and IV hemorrhoids: a network meta-analysis
Surgery choices trade complications for recurrence risk.Meta-analysisModerate qualityRelated question
2,799 people2019
Different surgical techniques traded off differently: some had fewer complications but higher return rates, others the opposite; no single technique was best on all measures
- Who was studied
- adults with grade III and IV hemorrhoids
- Main outcome
- complications (anal narrowing, fecal leakage, clotting) and return of hemorrhoids after surgery
- Quality
- Pools randomized trials with over 2700 patients, but it studies grade III/IV (prolapsing, mostly internal) hemorrhoids rather than external hemorrhoids specifically, and compares surgical options only.
- Limitations
- Covers surgical procedures for grade III and IV hemorrhoids, which are classified by internal hemorrhoid prolapse grading, not specifically external hemorrhoids; does not address lifestyle, topical, or office-based treatments.
Taken word for word from the abstract
- population
selected based on associations with surgical procedures for grade III and IV hemorrhoids
- n
Twenty-one studies with 2799 participants involving nine surgical procedures for grade III and IV hemorrhoids were ultimately analyzed.
- primaryOutcome
Data related to anal stenosis, fecal incontinence, hemorrhoids thrombosis, and recurrence rates were extracted from the included studies
- result
SH and THD exhibited the highest recurrence rates, when compared with the other hemorrhoidectomy surgical procedures
- result
OH treatments resulted in less hemorrhoids thrombosis rate but higher recurrence rate
- result
The use of Harmonic resulted in higher anal stenosis rate but lower recurrence rate
Int J Colorectal Dis · PMID 30929052 · Read it on PubMed ↗
Pagano et al. 2018
Mucopexy-recto anal lifting: a standardized minimally invasive method of managing symptomatic hemorrhoids, with an innovative suturing technique and the HemorPex System®
Low recurrence, high satisfaction (internal hemorrhoids)Case seriesLow qualityRelated question
126 people554 days
One-year recurrence rate was 4.1%, with 88% of patients reporting good or excellent satisfaction
- Who was studied
- Adults with grade III and IV internal hemorrhoids (prolapsing), not specifically external hemorrhoids
- What they received
- Mucopexy-Recto Anal Lifting (MuRAL) surgery using the HemorPex System, involving arterial ligation and mucopexy at 6 points
- Main outcome
- Rate of hemorrhoid recurrence at one year
- Quality
- This is a single-arm case series with no comparison group, so it cannot show whether this surgery is better than other options, and the authors themselves call for randomized studies.
- Limitations
- No control/comparator group, single-center/single-technique series, authors state further comparative randomized studies with longer follow-up are needed; grading system used (III/IV degree) pertains to internal hemorrhoid prolapse rather than external hemorrhoids.
Taken word for word from the abstract
- population
patients with symptomatic III and IV degree hemorrhoids
- intervention
MuRAL technique, based on arterial ligation and mucopexy at 6 locations, using a standardized clockwise/anti-clockwise rotation sequence of the HPS anoscope
- primaryOutcome
Primary outcome measurement was the recurrence rate.
- result
One-year recurrence rate was 4.1%.
- result
up to 88% of the patients reported a good, or excellent one-year satisfaction score
- n
We operated on 126 patients (72 males, mean age 53.9, range 29-83)
- followUp
Mean duration of follow-up was 554 days (range 281-1219).
Minerva Chir · PMID 29652112 · Read it on PubMed ↗
Kendirci et al. 2018
Comparison of Effects of Vessel-Sealing Devices and Conventional Hemorrhoidectomy on Postoperative Pain and Quality of Life
No difference between surgical techniques tested.RetrospectiveLow qualityRelated question
90 people2018
no significant differences among the three surgical techniques (LigaSure, Harmonic Scalpel, conventional) in pain, complications, or satisfaction
- Who was studied
- adults who had surgery to remove hemorrhoids
- Main outcome
- pain after surgery, complications, and quality of life
- Quality
- this was a retrospective review of only 90 patients comparing surgical techniques, not a randomized comparison of different approaches to curing hemorrhoids, and it does not specify that patients had external hemorrhoids.
- Limitations
- Retrospective design, small sample, and it compares three variants of one surgical approach (hemorrhoidectomy) rather than different categories of treatment (lifestyle, topical, office procedures vs surgery), and does not specify whether hemorrhoids were external.
Taken word for word from the abstract
- population
Ninety patients undergoing hemorrhoidectomy between 2014 and 2017 were retrospectively evaluated.
- primaryOutcome
pain score by use of the Visual Analog Score and patient satisfaction by Short Form-36
- result
There was no difference among the 3 methods in terms of complications, postoperative pain, or patient satisfaction
- n
Ninety patients undergoing hemorrhoidectomy between 2014 and 2017 were retrospectively evaluated.
Med Sci Monit · PMID 29643327 · Read it on PubMed ↗
Bellio et al. 2018
Stapled Hemorrhoidopexy: Results at 10-Year Follow-up
High recurrence, declining satisfaction over timeRetrospectiveLow qualityRelated question
86 people119.0 months
At 10-year follow-up, 39% of patients had recurrent hemorrhoidal prolapse (8 needed repeat surgery), and overall satisfaction was 68%
- Who was studied
- adults with grade 3 internal hemorrhoid prolapse
- What they received
- stapled hemorrhoidopexy (a stapling procedure to lift prolapsing hemorrhoid tissue)
- Compared with
- none (single group, no control)
- Main outcome
- patient satisfaction and recurrence of hemorrhoids at 10 years
- Quality
- This was a small, single-center study with no comparison group and no control, so it can't say how this procedure compares to other options, and some patients were lost to follow-up.
- Limitations
- Small sample size and lack of a control group, as stated by the authors; also treats grade 3 internal hemorrhoid prolapse rather than external hemorrhoids specifically.
Taken word for word from the abstract
- population
Eighty-six consecutive patients treated with stapled hemorrhoidopexy for grade 3 hemorrhoidal prolapse between January and December 2006 were included.
- intervention
stapled hemorrhoidopexy
- comparator
LIMITATIONS: The study was limited by its small sample size and lack of a control group.
- primaryOutcome
Patients satisfaction and recurrence rates were measured.
- result
30 patients (39%) experienced a recurrent hemorrhoidal prolapse, 8 of whom needed a reoperation
- result
Satisfaction rate at 10-year follow-up was 68%.
- n
Eighty-six patients (45 men and 41 women; median age, 49 y (range, 31-74 y)) underwent stapled hemorrhoidopexy.
Dis Colon Rectum · PMID 29521831 · Read it on PubMed ↗
Elbetti et al. 2017
Symptomatic pile tailored procedure. A new perspective for hemorrhoidal disease treatment
No recurrence after tailored surgery.Case seriesLow qualityRelated question
157 people16 months
No differences in time to discharge between the procedures; painkiller use rose with the number of piles treated; 10.2% had early urinary-retention complications and 7% late complications including one bleed requiring reoperation; at about 16 months no patient needed further hemorrhoid treatment
- Who was studied
- adults with hemorrhoidal disease, including internal piles with external skin tags or external pile involvement
- What they received
- individually tailored surgery for each hemorrhoid—using hemorrhoidopexy, hemorrhoidopexy plus excision of the external part, or full excision—chosen by the type and severity of the pile
- Main outcome
- days of self-administered painkiller use after surgery, plus complications, hospital stay, readmission and recurrence
- Quality
- This was a single-center case series with no comparison group and only moderate follow-up, so it cannot show whether this approach works better than other treatments.
- Limitations
- No control/comparison group; mixes patients with internal and external hemorrhoids rather than isolating external hemorrhoids alone; follow-up averaged only 16 months.
Taken word for word from the abstract
- population
presence of external pathological pile (external pile congestion or subversion of dental line (E) and skin tag not tolerated from the patient (S))
- intervention
We treated with Hemorrhoidopexy second and third degree pile without F or ES; with Hemorrhoidopexy and excision of external component every second and third degree pile with E or S and with complete semi-closed pile excision all third degree with F and IV degree piles.
- primaryOutcome
The number of post operative days of self administered analgesics was the primary end point and short/long term post operative complications, hospital stay, re-admission and recurrence were secondary end points.
- result
No differences were noted in term of time of discharge between hemorrhoidopexy and complete or external excision.
- result
The painkiller assumption increases with the number of treated pile (r= 0.227, p=0.006).
- result
We observed 10.2% early complications (48h) all secondary to urinary retention and 7% late complications (2-15days) within only one reoperation for bleeding.
- result
After mean follow up of 16 months no patients required further treatments for hemorrhoids.
- n
157 patients were treated.
Ann Ital Chir · PMID 29051401 · Read it on PubMed ↗
Trenti et al. 2017
Distal Doppler-guided transanal hemorrhoidal dearterialization with mucopexy versus conventional hemorrhoidectomy for grade III and IV hemorrhoids: postoperative morbidity and long-term outcomes
No difference between two surgery types.RetrospectiveLow qualityRelated question
83 peopleminimum of 1 year after surgery
No significant difference between the two surgical techniques in persistence of bleeding, prolapse, need for manual reduction, or pain; minor fecal incontinence occurred only after conventional hemorrhoidectomy
- Who was studied
- Adults with grade III-IV (internal) hemorrhoids undergoing surgery
- What they received
- Doppler-guided transanal hemorrhoidal dearterialization with mucopexy
- Compared with
- conventional excisional hemorrhoidectomy (Milligan and Morgan or Ferguson)
- Main outcome
- postoperative complications and long-term recurrence of hemorrhoid symptoms
- Quality
- This is a non-randomized, single-center comparison of two surgical techniques with a modest sample size, so it carries less certainty than a randomized trial.
- Limitations
- Not randomized, single center, and the population had grade III-IV internal hemorrhoids rather than external hemorrhoids specifically.
Taken word for word from the abstract
- population
patients who underwent either distal Doppler-guided THD with low ligation of the hemorrhoidal artery and mucopexy or conventional excisional hemorrhoidectomy (Milligan and Morgan or Ferguson) for grade III and IV hemorrhoids
- intervention
Distal Doppler-guided transanal hemorrhoidal dearterialization with mucopexy
- comparator
conventional excisional hemorrhoidectomy (Milligan and Morgan or Ferguson)
- primaryOutcome
Short- and long-term postoperative morbidity was recorded. Severity of hemorrhoid symptoms (bleeding, prolapse, manual reduction, discomfort or pain and impact on quality of life) and fecal continence status (Vaizey score) were evaluated
- result
No significant differences between the groups were observed in terms of persistence of bleeding, prolapse, need for manual reduction in prolapse and pain.
- result
Minor fecal incontinence occurred only after conventional hemorrhoidectomy in 2 (5.4%) patients.
- n
Eighty-three patients were included in the study.
- followUp
evaluated before surgery and at minimum of 1 year after surgery
Tech Coloproctol · PMID 28451767 · Read it on PubMed ↗
Araujo et al. 2016
LONG TERM RESULTS AFTER STAPLED HEMORRHOIDOPEXY ALONE AND COMPLEMENTED BY EXCISIONAL HEMORRHOIDECTOMY: A RETROSPECTIVE COHORT STUDY
Added excision didn't reduce recurrence.RetrospectiveLow qualityRelated question
86 people48.5 (6-40) months
No significant difference in symptom recurrence or re-operation rates between stapled hemorrhoidopexy alone and stapled hemorrhoidopexy combined with excision
- Who was studied
- Adults with grade 3–4 hemorrhoid disease, some with external hemorrhoid components, undergoing surgical treatment
- What they received
- Stapled hemorrhoidopexy plus an added excisional hemorrhoidectomy for external hemorrhoid tissue
- Compared with
- Stapled hemorrhoidopexy alone
- Main outcome
- Return of hemorrhoid symptoms after surgery, tracked over long-term follow-up
- Quality
- This is a small, non-randomized retrospective study with follow-up partly done by phone or email, so bias and recall issues limit confidence in the results.
- Limitations
- Retrospective design, no randomization, small sample, follow-up partly via self-report (email/telephone), and patients with more severe disease were preferentially given the combined procedure, confounding comparisons.
Taken word for word from the abstract
- n
sixty-five (29 men) patients underwent stapled hemorrhoidopexy and 21 (13 men) underwent stapled hemorrhoidopexy with excision
- population
Patients with grades 3 and 4 hemorrhoid disease were operated on more frequently using stapled hemorrhoidopexy complemented with excisional technique
- intervention
A closed excisional diathermy hemorrhoidectomy without vascular ligation was utilized in all complemented cases.
- comparator
sixty-five (29 men) patients underwent stapled hemorrhoidopexy
- primaryOutcome
there was no difference between the techniques in relation to symptom recurrence
- result
there was no difference between the techniques in relation to symptom recurrence (43% and 33%, p=0.45) and median interval between surgery and symptom recurrence (30 (8-84) and 38.8 (8-65) months, p=0.80)
Arq Bras Cir Dig · PMID 27759778 · Read it on PubMed ↗
Aytac et al. 2015
Long-term outcomes after circular stapled hemorrhoidopexy versus Ferguson hemorrhoidectomy
Similar long-term results, either surgeryRetrospectiveLow qualityRelated question
217 people7.7 ± 3.4 vs. 6.3 ± 2.9 years
Long-term outcomes were similar between the two surgical techniques: similar rates needing further treatment (5% vs 3%), similar satisfaction (83% vs 81% would have surgery again), similar symptom improvement, pain, and quality-of-life scores
- Who was studied
- adults who had hemorrhoid surgery (stapled hemorrhoidopexy or Ferguson hemorrhoidectomy) between 2000 and 2010
- What they received
- circular stapled hemorrhoidopexy
- Compared with
- Ferguson hemorrhoidectomy (surgical excision)
- Main outcome
- long-term need for further treatment, symptom relief, quality of life and anorectal pain
- Quality
- This was a retrospective review relying on patient questionnaires years later, with no randomization, so recall bias and group differences could affect the results.
- Limitations
- Retrospective design, follow-up assessed only by questionnaire, follow-up duration differed between groups, and the abstract does not specify whether patients had external (versus internal) hemorrhoids.
Taken word for word from the abstract
- n
Two hundred seventeen patients completed the questionnaires.
- intervention
circular stapled hemorrhoidopexy
- comparator
Ferguson hemorrhoidectomy
- population
Patients who underwent Ferguson hemorrhoidectomy and circular stapled hemorrhoidopexy between 2000 and 2010 were reviewed.
- primaryOutcome
Long-term need for additional surgical or medical treatment was similar in the Ferguson hemorrhoidectomy and circular stapled hemorrhoidopexy groups
- result
Long-term need for additional surgical or medical treatment was similar in the Ferguson hemorrhoidectomy and circular stapled hemorrhoidopexy groups (3 vs. 5%, p = 0.47 and 3% in both groups, p > 0.99, respectively). Eighty-one percentage of Ferguson hemorrhoidectomy and 83% of circular stapled hemorrhoidopexy patients stated that they would undergo hemorrhoid surgery again if needed (p = 0.86).
- followUp
Mean follow-up was longer in the Ferguson hemorrhoidectomy subgroups (7.7 ± 3.4 vs. 6.3 ± 2.9 years, p = 0.003).
Tech Coloproctol · PMID 26359179 · Read it on PubMed ↗
Xu et al. 2015
Ligasure versus Ferguson hemorrhoidectomy in the treatment of hemorrhoids: a meta-analysis of randomized control trials
Faster surgery, less pain short-termMeta-analysisLow qualityRelated question
318 people2015
Ligasure had shorter operative time, shorter hospital stay, less blood loss, less urinary retention and less early pain than Ferguson surgery; no difference in later bleeding, difficult defecation, anal fissure, anal stenosis or incontinence
- Who was studied
- adults with hemorrhoids requiring surgery
- What they received
- Ligasure hemorrhoidectomy
- Compared with
- Ferguson hemorrhoidectomy
- Main outcome
- surgical outcomes including pain, bleeding, operative time, and complications
- Quality
- Only 5 small trials totaling 318 patients, and the abstract itself says long-term outcomes still need to be studied.
- Limitations
- Abstract does not specify whether patients had external or internal hemorrhoids, and only short-term outcomes are reported; no long-term permanence data.
Taken word for word from the abstract
- population
Randomizes control trials that compared LH with FH were identified
- intervention
Ligasure hemorrhoidectomy (LH)
- comparator
Ferguson hemorrhoidectomy (FH)
- primaryOutcome
The urinary retention rate and early postoperative pain scores were higher in patients undergoing FH.
- result
Patients treated with Ligasure had a significantly shorter operative time and hospital stay than the patients submitted to Ferguson techniques.
- result
No statistically significant differences were noted in postoperative bleeding, difficult defacating, anal fissure, anal stenosis, and incontinence.
- n
Five trials including 318 patients met the inclusion criteria.
Surg Laparosc Endosc Percutan Tech · PMID 25738704 · Read it on PubMed ↗
Champagne et al. 2015
Novel operative anoscope for Ferguson hemorrhoidectomy: a feasibility study and comparative cohort analysis
Faster surgery, no other differences.Prospective cohortLow qualityRelated question
40 people1 year
Operations with the new retractor were quicker, with similar blood loss, pain, and bowel control compared with the traditional retractor
- Who was studied
- adults needing surgical removal of hemorrhoids (hemorrhoidectomy)
- What they received
- a newer slotted surgical retractor (anoscope) used during the hemorrhoid removal operation
- Compared with
- the traditional retractor (Hill-Ferguson anoscope) used during the same operation
- Main outcome
- operation time, blood loss, pain, bowel control, and symptom return after surgery
- Quality
- This was a small, non-randomized comparison of two patient groups treated in different time periods, not a controlled trial, so bias from the way groups were chosen can't be ruled out.
- Limitations
- Not randomized; groups were treated in different, non-overlapping time periods; very small sample size; does not specify whether hemorrhoids were external or internal; compares two surgical tools rather than different treatment approaches.
Taken word for word from the abstract
- population
Patients requiring hemorrhoidectomy (June 2008 - January 2010)
- intervention
a new operating anoscope (CAD, Ethicon Endosurgery, Cincinnati, OH)
- comparator
patients undergoing hemorrhoidectomy (February 2010 - November 2012) with a traditional Hill-Ferguson anoscope (THF)
- primaryOutcome
perioperative end points including bleeding, pain, fecal incontinence, stenosis, and symptom recurrence were analyzed at 4 weeks, 3 months, 6 months, and 1 year postoperatively
- result
Mean operative times were lower for the CAD than the THF group (15.6 ± 3.4 vs 26.1 ± 4.1 minutes; P < .05).
- result
There was no difference in incontinence or pain between groups.
- n
40 patients (CAD, 20 vs THF, 20) were included.
Surg Innov · PMID 24879501 · Read it on PubMed ↗
De Nardi et al. 2014
A prospective, randomized trial comparing the short- and long-term results of doppler-guided transanal hemorrhoid dearterialization with mucopexy versus excision hemorrhoidectomy for grade III hemorrhoids
Similar pain and cure ratesRandomised trialLow qualityRelated question
50 people24 months
Pain scores were similar between the two procedures at all time points, work resumption and satisfaction were similar, and relapse rates were similar at 24 months.
- Who was studied
- adults with grade III hemorrhoids (internal, prolapsing)
- What they received
- Doppler-guided transanal hemorrhoid dearterialization with mucopexy
- Compared with
- excision hemorrhoidectomy (surgical removal)
- Main outcome
- pain after surgery
- Quality
- Small single-center trial of only 50 patients with nonvalidated follow-up questionnaires and no cost analysis, so results may not generalize.
- Limitations
- Nonvalidated questionnaires were used in follow-up; cost analysis was not performed; single center; small sample.
Taken word for word from the abstract
- population
Fifty consecutive patients were treated for grade III hemorrhoids from July to November 2010.
- intervention
Doppler-guided transanal hemorrhoid dearterialization with mucopexy
- comparator
excisional open hemorrhoidectomy
- primaryOutcome
The primary outcome was postoperative pain.
- result
The median visual analog scale scores for pain in the hemorrhoidectomy and Doppler-guided dearterialization plus mucopexy groups on days 1, 7, 14, and 30 were 7 vs 5.5, 3 vs 2.5, 1 vs 0, and 0 vs 0 (p> 0.05).
- n
Fifty consecutive patients were treated for grade III hemorrhoids from July to November 2010.
Dis Colon Rectum · PMID 24509458 · Read it on PubMed ↗
Tempel et al. 2014
Survey of patient satisfaction after Doppler-guided transanal hemorrhoidal dearterialization performed in ambulatory settings
High satisfaction after internal hemorrhoid artery procedureRetrospectiveLow qualityRelated question
216 peopleMedian follow-up was 23 months (range 1-42 months)
Mean patient satisfaction was 8.5 out of 10, and 91.5% of patients felt the procedure had helped them, though many had transient side effects like urinary difficulty, bleeding, or incontinence
- Who was studied
- adults with grade III-IV (internal) hemorrhoids
- What they received
- Doppler-guided transanal hemorrhoidal dearterialization (THD), an ambulatory procedure that ties off hemorrhoidal arteries and lifts prolapsing tissue
- Main outcome
- patient satisfaction and symptom relief after the procedure
- Quality
- This was a retrospective, single-group study with no comparison group and relied on patients' phone recall of symptoms, so it cannot show whether THD works better than other options.
- Limitations
- Retrospective design, no comparator group, complications assessed retrospectively, and patients surveyed by phone relying on recall; study itself notes lack of long-term follow-up and retrospective complication assessment.
Taken word for word from the abstract
- n
216 patients with grade III-IV hemorrhoids underwent THD
- population
216 patients with grade III-IV hemorrhoids underwent THD
- intervention
Transanal hemorrhoidal dearterialization (THD) is a recently developed procedure to minimize postoperative pain from hemorrhoidectomy. This technique utilizes Doppler signals to aid ligation of hemorrhoidal arteries followed by mucopexy of redundant mucosa if needed.
- primaryOutcome
The aim of the present study was to assess patient satisfaction after THD.
- result
Mean patient satisfaction was 8.5 ± 0.7 (on a scale of 1-10 with 10 being the best), and 91.5 % of patients felt the procedure had "helped" them.
Tech Coloproctol · PMID 24352923 · Read it on PubMed ↗
Qarabaki et al. 2014
Circular vs. three-quadrant hemorrhoidectomy for end-stage hemorrhoids: short- and long-term outcomes of a prospective randomized trial
Full circular removal cut recurrence to zero.Randomised trialModerate qualityRelated question
688 people7.4 years (range, 1-14 years)
CEH patients remained symptom-free at long-term follow-up, while 126 of 308 FH patients had recurrent symptoms; CEH had no postoperative bleeding but more anal strictures, which were easily treated with dilation
- Who was studied
- adults with end-stage hemorrhoids
- What they received
- circumferential excisional hemorrhoidectomy (CEH), a surgical removal of hemorrhoids all the way around the anus
- Compared with
- Ferguson hemorrhoidectomy (FH), a standard surgical excision of hemorrhoids
- Main outcome
- recurrence of hemorrhoid symptoms and postoperative complications over long-term follow-up
- Quality
- this was a large randomized trial with long follow-up, but it compares two surgical techniques rather than testing a treatment against no treatment or a non-surgical option, and some patients were lost to follow-up.
- Limitations
- Not all patients were accessible at long-term follow-up; comparison is between two surgical excision techniques rather than against conservative or non-surgical treatments; strictures required additional management (digital dilatation).
Taken word for word from the abstract
- population
patients who presented with end-stage hemorrhoids
- intervention
Circumferential excisional hemorrhoidectomy (CEH)
- comparator
Ferguson hemorrhoidectomy (FH)
- primaryOutcome
the incidence of postoperative hemorrhage
- n
688 patients
- result
accessible patients from the CEH group remained symptom free, whereas 126 of 308 patients in the FH group indicated that they had recurrent hemorrhoidal symptoms
- result
Significant differences were revealed in the incidence of postoperative hemorrhage (9 vs. 0 patients in the FH and CEH groups, respectively; p = 0.002) and in the tendency to form anal stricture (15 vs. 32 patients in the FH and CEH groups, respectively; p = 0.02)
- followUp
mean follow-up of 7.4 (range, 1-14) years
J Gastrointest Surg · PMID 24297654 · Read it on PubMed ↗
Theodoropoulos et al. 2013
Submucosal anoderm-preserving hemorrhoidectomy revisited: a modified technique for the surgical management of hemorrhoidal crisis
Good satisfaction after modified surgeryCase seriesLow qualityRelated question
45 peoplelong-term follow-up (not specified in detail)
Pain after surgery was acceptable, complications were minimal, and long-term follow-up showed high patient satisfaction
- Who was studied
- Adults with sudden severe hemorrhoid flare-ups (hemorrhoidal crisis) needing emergency surgery
- What they received
- A modified surgical technique (submucosal anoderm-preserving hemorrhoidectomy with mucopexy) that removes minimal tissue while preserving the anal lining
- Main outcome
- Postoperative pain, complications, and long-term patient satisfaction
- Quality
- This is a small case series of 45 patients with no comparison group, so it cannot show whether this technique works better than other options.
- Limitations
- No control/comparator group; single technique described by its developers; emergency setting only; no quantified outcome data given beyond general statements.
Taken word for word from the abstract
- population
applied to 45 patients who presented on an emergency basis with hemorrhoidal crisis
- intervention
A modified submucosal technique with anoderm preservation and mucopexy was applied to 45 patients
- primaryOutcome
Postoperative morbidity was minimal and pain after the procedure remained at acceptable levels
- result
The level of postoperative pain with this technique is acceptable and long-term follow-up reveals a high degree of patient satisfaction.
- n
applied to 45 patients
Am Surg · PMID 24165256 · Read it on PubMed ↗
Kim et al. 2013
Stapled hemorrhoidopexy versus Milligan-Morgan hemorrhoidectomy in circumferential third-degree hemorrhoids: long-term results of a randomized controlled trial
Similar cure rates, less early pain with stapling.Randomised trialModerate qualityRelated question
130 people5 years
Long-term recurrence rates were similar between the two surgeries (18% vs 23%, not statistically significant), but stapled hemorrhoidopexy caused significantly less pain and less itching/burning in the weeks after surgery; bleeding, urinary retention and incontinence rates did not differ significantly.
- Who was studied
- adults with circumferential third-degree hemorrhoids (an internal hemorrhoid condition, not specifically external hemorrhoids)
- What they received
- stapled hemorrhoidopexy (a surgical stapling procedure)
- Compared with
- Milligan-Morgan hemorrhoidectomy (traditional surgical excision)
- Main outcome
- pain, recurrence, bleeding, itching/burning, urinary retention, incontinence symptoms, and wound healing after surgery
- Quality
- This was a randomized trial with long (5-year) follow-up and reasonable size, but it was done at a single center and the abstract notes incontinence measurements and pathology review had limitations.
- Limitations
- Detailed measurement of incontinence was not possible because postoperative symptoms resolved between consultations, and pathological results were examined retrospectively.
Taken word for word from the abstract
- n
One hundred thirty patients were enrolled into a randomized controlled study
- population
compared with the Milligan-Morgan procedure in a homogeneous patient population with circumferential third-degree hemorrhoids
- intervention
stapled hemorrhoidopexy
- comparator
Milligan-Morgan procedure
- primaryOutcome
Endpoints were pain, recurrence, bleeding, itching/burning, urinary retention, incontinence symptoms, and prolonged rate of wound healing.
- result
The cumulative recurrence rates after 5 years were 18 % (n = 11) in the stapled hemorrhoidopexy group and 23 % (n = 14) in the Milligan-Morgan group (p = 0.65).
- result
Patients who underwent stapled hemorrhoidopexy had significantly less postoperative pain with mean VAS scores at week 1: 3.1 vs. 6.2; week 2: 0.5 vs. 3; week 4: 0.05 vs. 0.6 (p < 0.001)
- result
demonstrated less burning/itching sensation 4 weeks after surgery compared with the Milligan-Morgan group (4.9 vs. 19.7 %; p < 0.001)
- result
The postoperative bleeding rate was 4.9 % in both groups and the rate of urinary retention did not differ significantly (4.9 % vs. 1.6 %; p = 0.309).
J Gastrointest Surg · PMID 23670518 · Read it on PubMed ↗
Nguyen et al. 2012
French experience in the management of hemorrhoids by HAL™ Doppler
Most symptoms gone, but some recurrenceProspective cohortLow qualityRelated question
61 peopleone year
More than 78% had their symptoms disappear, but 10.5% had the disease come back within the first year; 4.9% had post-operative complications
- Who was studied
- Adults with hemorrhoids graded II to IV
- What they received
- Doppler-guided hemorrhoidal artery ligation (HAL) surgery
- Main outcome
- Symptom resolution and recurrence of hemorrhoidal disease at one month and one year
- Quality
- This was a single-group study with no comparison treatment, a small number of patients, and the analysis was done retrospectively even though data was collected prospectively.
- Limitations
- No comparator group to judge this against other approaches; data analyzed retrospectively; grading system used (II-IV) is typically applied to internal hemorrhoids, not specifically external hemorrhoids as asked about in this question.
Taken word for word from the abstract
- population
The Doppler HAL™ technique was performed in patients with grades II to IV
- intervention
Doppler-guided hemorrhoidal artery ligation (Doppler HAL™)
- primaryOutcome
functional outcome at one month and at one year were recorded prospectively and analyzed retrospectively
- result
Functional results evaluated at one month and one year showed that initial symptoms had disappeared in more than 78% of patients. The recurrence rate for hemorrhoidal related disease was 10.5% during the first year.
- n
Sixty-one consecutive patients (mean age 45 [range 28-85]) underwent Doppler HAL™.
- result
The post-operative morbidity rate was 4.9%.
J Visc Surg · PMID 23102972 · Read it on PubMed ↗
Argov et al. 2012
Milligan-Morgan hemorrhoidectomy under local anesthesia - an old operation that stood the test of time. A single-team experience with 2,280 operations
Low-complication surgical removal, lasting resultsRetrospectiveLow qualityRelated question
2,280 people1-12 years
Very low complication rates, no deaths, and good long-term results after the operation
- Who was studied
- adults having surgery for hemorrhoids
- What they received
- Milligan-Morgan hemorrhoidectomy done under local anesthesia with light sedation
- Main outcome
- complications and long-term effectiveness of the surgery
- Quality
- This is a retrospective look-back at one surgical team's own patients with no control group studied alongside them, so it cannot reliably prove this operation is better than alternatives.
- Limitations
- Retrospective single-team case series without a concurrent comparison group; comparisons to other techniques are based on citing separate published papers rather than testing them in the same patients.
Taken word for word from the abstract
- population
a single-team experience with 2,280 M&M hemorrhoidectomy patients, with 1-12 years follow-up
- intervention
All patients were operated upon in jack-knife position, using local anesthesia under light sedation in an ambulatory facility.
- primaryOutcome
evaluate the morbidity and efficacy of Milligan-Morgan (M&M) hemorrhoidectomy
- result
We found negligible morbidity, no mortality and a very efficient operation on long-term follow-up.
- n
a single-team experience with 2,280 M&M hemorrhoidectomy patients
Int J Colorectal Dis · PMID 22350269 · Read it on PubMed ↗
Avital et al. 2012
Five-year follow-up of Doppler-guided hemorrhoidal artery ligation
Mostly worked, but effect faded over timeCase seriesLow qualityRelated question
100 people5 years
89% symptom-free at 1 year, dropping to 73% symptom-free at 5 years; less effective for Grade III than Grade II hemorrhoids
- Who was studied
- adults with symptomatic Grade II or III hemorrhoids
- What they received
- Doppler-guided hemorrhoidal artery ligation (DGHAL), a procedure to tie off the artery branches feeding the hemorrhoids
- Compared with
- none (before/after comparison over time)
- Main outcome
- being symptom-free over time
- Quality
- This is a single-surgeon case series with no comparison group and about a quarter of patients lost to follow-up by 5 years.
- Limitations
- No control group, single surgeon, loss to follow-up (only 92 of 100 patients reachable at 5 years), and this targets internal hemorrhoidal arterial supply rather than being specific to external hemorrhoids.
Taken word for word from the abstract
- population
100 patients with symptomatic Grade II or III hemorrhoids
- intervention
Doppler-guided hemorrhoidal artery ligation (DGHAL)
- comparator
Surgical and functional outcome was assessed at 6 weeks and 3 and 12 months after surgery, with long-term follow-up by a telephone questionnaire at 5 years after the procedure.
- primaryOutcome
Eighty-five of these patients (89%) remained asymptomatic at 12 months
- result
Eighty-five of these patients (89%) remained asymptomatic at 12 months, though this number dropped to 67/92 (73%) at 5 years.
- n
100 patients with symptomatic Grade II or III hemorrhoids
Tech Coloproctol · PMID 22190190 · Read it on PubMed ↗
Rondelli et al. 2011
Closed hemorrhoidectomy with linear stapler: a consecutive series of 300 patients
Low recurrence for internal hemorrhoids, not externalCase seriesLow qualityRelated question
300 people23.4 months
Low bleeding and complication rates; all patients healed within 6 months; only 2 of 300 patients had recurrence over a median follow-up of 23.4 months
- Who was studied
- Adults with grade III and IV internal hemorrhoids
- What they received
- Closed hemorrhoidectomy using a linear stapler (sutured closure technique)
- Compared with
- None - single-arm series, no comparison group
- Main outcome
- Blood loss, time to complete wound healing, and recurrence of hemorrhoids
- Quality
- This is a single-arm case series with no comparison group, so it cannot show whether the stapler technique works better than other options.
- Limitations
- No control or comparator group; single-center, single-surgeon-technique series; outcome of 'cure' relies on absence of recurrence rather than long-term structured follow-up beyond ~2 years.
Taken word for word from the abstract
- population
300 patients (117 male, 183 female) (mean age, 52 (range 21-85) years) with grade III and IV hemorrhoids
- intervention
treated with our modified technique with linear stapler with 6 cm vascular recharge. This technique essentially achieves a sutured closed hemorroidectomy.
- comparator
Between January 2006 and December 2009, 300 patients
- primaryOutcome
The primary end-points of the study were blood loss, time to achieve complete wound healing and recurrence
- result
All patients had complete wound healing within 6 months. Two patients had recurrent disease and were re-operated on with the same technique.
- n
300 patients (117 male, 183 female)
In Vivo · PMID 22021697 · Read it on PubMed ↗
Mukhashavria et al. 2011
Circumferential excisional hemorrhoidectomy for extensive acute thrombosis: a 14-year experience
Surgery gave lasting, mostly symptom-free resultsProspective cohortModerate qualityRelated question
294 people6.8 (range, 2-14) years
92.2% of patients were symptom-free at an average of 6.8 years after surgery, with low complication rates and no reported recurrences
- Who was studied
- Adults with severe, extensive acute thrombosed hemorrhoids causing swelling, ulceration or gangrene
- What they received
- Circumferential excisional hemorrhoidectomy (a modified surgical removal of hemorrhoids with reconstruction of the anal lining)
- Compared with
- None — single-arm study with no comparison group
- Main outcome
- Surgical complications and whether patients were symptom-free at follow-up
- Quality
- Large, long-running single-center study with long follow-up, but it had no comparison group, so it cannot show the surgery is better than other treatments.
- Limitations
- No control group; all patients came from one center and had a specific, severe form of hemorrhoidal thrombosis, so it may not reflect typical external hemorrhoids.
Taken word for word from the abstract
- population
patients presenting with total hemorrhoidal thrombosis
- intervention
Circumferential excisional hemorrhoidectomy involves the stripping and excision of hemorrhoids from the submucoanodermal space with reconstruction of the anal canal by the use of an undermined irregular/zigzag-shaped mucoanodermal flap and accurately trimmed skin.
- comparator
This study did not have a control group.
- primaryOutcome
The main outcome measures were the surgical outcomes and complications.
- result
At a mean follow-up of 6.8 (range, 2-14) years, 271 (92.2%) accessible patients were actually symptom-free.
- n
This prospective, descriptive study was conducted with 294 consecutive patients
Dis Colon Rectum · PMID 21825898 · Read it on PubMed ↗
Pramateftakis 2010
The role of hemorrhoidopexy in the management of 3rd degree hemorrhoids
Effective for internal hemorrhoids, not externalProspective cohortLow qualityRelated question
126 people12 months
6.6% recurrence at follow-up, with most patients pain-free and returning to normal activity within days; some had transient urgency, gas incontinence or urinary retention that resolved
- Who was studied
- adults with 3rd degree (prolapsing) internal hemorrhoids
- What they received
- stapled hemorrhoidopexy (surgical stapling procedure)
- Compared with
- no comparison group (single-arm follow-up)
- Main outcome
- recurrence of hemorrhoids and post-operative complications over 12 months
- Quality
- this is a single-center case series without a control group, so it cannot show how this procedure compares with other treatments.
- Limitations
- no comparator group; outcomes based on 95% follow-up attendance; study addresses internal (3rd degree) hemorrhoids rather than external hemorrhoids
Taken word for word from the abstract
- population
One hundred and twenty-six consecutive patients with 3rd degree hemorrhoids underwent stapled hemorrhoidopexy.
- intervention
stapled hemorrhoidopexy
- comparator
One hundred and twenty-six consecutive patients with 3rd degree hemorrhoids underwent stapled hemorrhoidopexy.
- primaryOutcome
Recurrence of the disease occurred in 8 patients (6.6%).
- result
Recurrence of the disease occurred in 8 patients (6.6%). It was managed conservatively in 2 patients, 3 underwent redo hemorrhoidopexy and 3 underwent classic hemorrhoidectomy.
- n
One hundred and twenty-six consecutive patients with 3rd degree hemorrhoids underwent stapled hemorrhoidopexy.
Tech Coloproctol · PMID 20686808 · Read it on PubMed ↗
Fareed et al. 2009
Randomized trial comparing LigaSure to closed Ferguson hemorrhoidectomy
Less pain with LigaSure surgeryRandomised trialModerate qualityRelated question
80 peoplethird month
LigaSure caused less pain on day 1, day 7, and week 2 after surgery, shorter operating time, less blood loss, shorter hospital stay, faster wound healing, and higher satisfaction at 3 months; complication rates were similar between groups
- Who was studied
- Adults with grade III and IV hemorrhoids undergoing surgery
- What they received
- LigaSure vessel-sealing hemorrhoidectomy
- Compared with
- Closed Ferguson hemorrhoidectomy
- Main outcome
- Pain after surgery
- Quality
- It was a randomized trial but small (80 patients) from one center with only short-term follow-up, so results may not hold up long-term or apply broadly.
- Limitations
- Small sample size, single study, only short-term outcomes reported, and population was grade III/IV hemorrhoids rather than specifically external hemorrhoids.
Taken word for word from the abstract
- population
Eighty patients with grades III and IV hemorrhoids were prospectively randomized to either LigaSure or Ferguson hemorrhoidectomy.
- intervention
LigaSure vessel sealing system
- comparator
closed Ferguson technique
- primaryOutcome
Primary end point was postoperative pain.
- result
The LigaSure group achieved a significant reduction in operative time (P < 0.001), blood loss (P < 0.001), first postoperative day pain score (P < 0.006), seventh day pain score (P < 0.012), second week pain score (P < 0.001).
- result
Hospital stay (P < 0.001), time to achieve complete wound healing (P = 0.001) were shorter in the LigaSure group, and third month satisfaction score was higher (P = 0.03). There was no difference in postoperative complications.
- n
Eighty patients with grades III and IV hemorrhoids were prospectively randomized
Tech Coloproctol · PMID 19629378 · Read it on PubMed ↗
Diurni et al. 2008
Hemorrhoidectomy in day surgery
Surgical options vary in pain, recovery, and recurrence.Systematic reviewLow qualityRelated question
1,276 people2008
Stapled hemorrhoidopexy caused less pain and faster recovery than conventional excision; Ligasure was a suitable alternative needing more long-term data; Doppler-guided artery ligation was safe and easy but had a 12% recurrence rate
- Who was studied
- Adults with hemorrhoids undergoing day-case surgery
- Main outcome
- Postoperative pain, complications, recurrence and cost across surgical hemorrhoid procedures
- Quality
- It is a narrative synthesis of mixed randomized trials without a pooled statistical analysis, and mainly addresses internal/mixed hemorrhoid surgery rather than external hemorrhoids specifically.
- Limitations
- No formal meta-analytic pooling described; includes various surgical populations not limited to external hemorrhoids; long-term outcome data said to be lacking for Ligasure; recurrence noted for artery ligation procedure.
Taken word for word from the abstract
- population
Day-case hemorrhoidectomy has shown to be safe and acceptable to patients.
- n
1276 patients, 409 in the stapled group, 389 in the conventional group, 268 in hemorrhoidal artery ligation procedure and 210 in Ligasure hemorrhoidectomy group
- primaryOutcome
This study confirms that SH is associated with less postoperative pain and shorter postoperative symptoms, compared with MMH.
- result
SH may be a viable alternative to the conventional surgical therapy for hemorrhoids with some advantages and some disadvantages in postoperative complications and costs.
- result
An other suitable alternative to conventional procedures is the use of Ligasure, although long-term evaluation of outcomes and morbidity is still needed.
- result
Hemorrhoidal artery ligation procedure is safe and easy to learn and to perform, even with a recurrence rate of 12, but randomized trials are mandatory.
Int J Surg · PMID 19246266 · Read it on PubMed ↗
Naldini et al. 2009
Is simple mucosal resection really possible? Considerations about histological findings after stapled hemorrhoidopexy
Surgery removed muscle too, outcomes unaffectedRetrospectiveLow qualityRelated question
241 people2009
Most specimens removed during this stapling surgery also contained muscle fibers (90%), but having muscle fibers removed did not seem to change complication or recurrence rates; overall complications occurred in 11.2% and recurrence in 4.5% of cases
- Who was studied
- patients who had stapled hemorrhoidopexy surgery (not specified as external hemorrhoids)
- What they received
- stapled hemorrhoidopexy (stapling surgery for hemorrhoids)
- Main outcome
- postoperative complications (bleeding, pain, recurrence) and whether muscle tissue was removed along with hemorrhoid tissue
- Quality
- This is a retrospective review of one surgical technique with no comparison group, so it cannot show which approach works better for external hemorrhoids.
- Limitations
- Retrospective design, no control group, and the procedure (stapled hemorrhoidopexy) is typically used for internal/prolapsing hemorrhoids rather than external hemorrhoids specifically, which the abstract does not clarify.
Taken word for word from the abstract
- population
This retrospective study evaluated 241 cases of stapled hemorrhoidopexy treated from 2003 to 2006.
- intervention
stapled hemorrhoidectomy
- n
241 cases of stapled hemorrhoidopexy
- primaryOutcome
Data include the most common postoperative complications such as bleeding, anal pain, and recurrence.
- result
Muscularis propria fibers were identified in 217 of 241 (90%) pathologic specimens.
- result
Early complications occurred in 27/241 patients (11.2%) including bleeding (14), anal pain (eight), incontinence (two), abscess (two), hematoma (one). Recurrence was observed in 11 cases (4.5%).
- result
the presence of smooth muscle does not seems to influence the outcome of stapled hemorrhoidopexy
Int J Colorectal Dis · PMID 19169693 · Read it on PubMed ↗
Nienhuijs et al. 2009
Conventional versus LigaSure hemorrhoidectomy for patients with symptomatic Hemorrhoids
Less early pain, same long-term outcomeMeta-analysisModerate qualityRelated question
1,142 people14 days
LigaSure caused significantly less pain on day 1 and up to 7 days, took less time to perform, and let patients return to work sooner; by day 14 the pain difference disappeared, and there was no difference in complications, recurrent bleeding, incontinence, or hospital stay
- Who was studied
- adults with symptomatic hemorrhoids undergoing surgical removal
- What they received
- hemorrhoid removal surgery using the LigaSure sealing device
- Compared with
- conventional hemorrhoidectomy using diathermy
- Main outcome
- pain after surgery and complications/recurrence
- Quality
- it pools 12 randomized trials with over a thousand patients, but the included studies varied in quality and long-term recurrence was not well measured.
- Limitations
- The abstract does not specify how many patients had external (versus internal or mixed) hemorrhoids, and long-term recurrence data were limited; authors state more evaluation of long-term recurrence risk is needed.
Taken word for word from the abstract
- population
patients with symptomatic hemorrhoids
- intervention
hemorroidectomy using the Ligasure-technique
- comparator
conventional diathermy techniques
- primaryOutcome
To compare patient tolerance focussing on pain following Ligasure and conventional hemorrhoidectomy in patients with symptomatic hemorrhoids.
- result
The pain score at the first day following surgery was significantly less in the Ligasure group (10 studies, 835 patients, WMD -2.07 CI -2.77 to -1.38).
- result
The benefit was diminished at day 14 (VAS pain score, 4 studies, 183 patients, WMD -0.12 CI -0.37 to 0.12).
- result
There was no relevant difference in postoperative complications, symptoms of recurrent bleeding or incontinence at final follow-up.
- n
Twelve studies with 1142 patients met the inclusion criteria.
Cochrane Database Syst Rev · PMID 19160300 · Read it on PubMed ↗
How we searchedThe exact query, the date it ran, and what came back — so you can run it yourself.
- Searched
- PubMed · ClinicalTrials.gov · Crossref on 2026-11-17
- The exact search — paste this into PubMed to repeat it
("Hemorrhoids/therapy"[Mesh] OR "Hemorrhoids/surgery"[Mesh] OR "Hemorrhoids/drug therapy"[Mesh]) AND (recurrence[tiab] OR "long-term"[tiab] OR cure[tiab] OR permanent[tiab]) AND (external[tiab] OR excision[tiab] OR hemorrhoidectomy[tiab])- PubMed expanded that to:
("hemorrhoids/therapy"[MeSH Terms] OR "hemorrhoids/surgery"[MeSH Terms] OR "hemorrhoids/drug therapy"[MeSH Terms]) AND ("recurrence"[Title/Abstract] OR "long-term"[Title/Abstract] OR "cure"[Title/Abstract] OR "permanent"[Title/Abstract]) AND ("external"[Title/Abstract] OR "excision"[Title/Abstract] OR "hemorrhoidectomy"[Title/Abstract]) - What came back
- 326 records found · 200 read · 58 answered the question
- Included
- Human, animal or laboratory studies reporting an outcome relevant to the question
- Excluded
- Records about a different condition or intervention
- Studies mainly about laser hair removal (epilation)
- Studies mainly about internal hemorrhoid banding (different anatomic target)
- Studies mainly about treatments for anal fissure or skin tags
- Records reporting no outcome
- Retracted publications, which are listed but excluded from every count
- Limits
- Details were read from abstracts, not full papers, so anything reported only in a paper's methods section is not captured here.
- Fields were read from abstracts, not full text, so detail reported only in a paper's methods section is not captured.
- Evidence strength is adapted from the GRADE framework. It is not a GRADE assessment and was not produced by a GRADE panel.
Automated evidence review — PubMed, ClinicalTrials.gov, Crossref. Search strategy, grading rules and the checks that must pass before anything publishes were written by Allen Kamrava, MD, MBA, FACS, FASCRS, colon & rectal surgery, Beverly Hills. The pages themselves are compiled by software running that method and are not read one by one before publication — saying otherwise would be the one claim here that could not be checked.
- 326records came back from the search
- 200were read
- 58actually answered the question
Risks and safetyReported side effects and who should be careful.
- Surgical removal (excision) of hemorrhoids has been linked to complications like incontinence, ongoing pain, and watery discharge in some patients, compared with conservative care.
- In-office incision and drainage of a thrombosed external hemorrhoid was the treatment most often followed by bleeding in a study of elderly patients.
- Hemorrhoid surgery carries a risk of bleeding and urinary retention: one trial comparing two surgical techniques (stapled hemorrhoidopexy and Milligan-Morgan hemorrhoidectomy) reported post-operative bleeding in about 5% of patients in both groups, and urinary retention in about 5% versus 2%.
Why people askWhat brings people to this question.
- External hemorrhoids can be painful, itchy, or bleed, so people want something that ends the problem for good instead of just easing it for a while.
- Surgery sounds more final than creams or lifestyle changes, so people search for it hoping to avoid repeat flare-ups.
- Many people want to avoid a doctor visit and search for something they can do at home instead.
Common questionsShort answers, drawn from the same studies.
- How to get rid of external hemorrhoids permanently?
- No treatment studied so far has been shown to guarantee hemorrhoids never come back. In studies of painful, clotted external hemorrhoids, surgery was linked to fewer recurrences than non-surgical care, but even surgery wasn't tested over many years, and some people still had hemorrhoids return.
- How to get rid of hemorrhoids permanently?
- Across the studies that compare surgery with non-surgical care for external hemorrhoids, surgery came out ahead on recurrence, but recurrence still happened in both groups—ranging from under 10% to over 30% depending on the study. No approach was shown to be permanent.
- What gets rid of hemorrhoids permanently?
- Nothing tested so far has been proven to permanently prevent hemorrhoids from returning. The best evidence available is that surgery for thrombosed external hemorrhoids lowers the chance of recurrence compared with conservative care, but it does not eliminate it.
- Which medicine cure piles permanently?
- No medicine or cream has been tested in these studies for permanently curing piles. The available studies compare surgery with grouped 'conservative care,' not specific medicines, so there's no evidence any medicine alone cures hemorrhoids for good.
- How to get rid of external hemorrhoids permanently at home?
- No study has tested home remedies alone—like fiber, sitz baths, or creams—for permanently resolving external hemorrhoids. The relevant studies compare clinic-based procedures or surgery against conservative care as a group, not individual home treatments, so this remains unanswered by the evidence.
This is information, not advice
This page summarises published research. It cannot tell you what is happening in your own body, and evidence changes. If something is bleeding, painful, or new, it is worth being looked at — that is a different question from the one on this page, and a better one to bring to a consultation.
Contact the officeAutomated evidence review — PubMed, ClinicalTrials.gov, Crossref. Search strategy, grading rules and the checks that must pass before anything publishes were written by Allen Kamrava, MD, MBA, FACS, FASCRS, colon & rectal surgery, Beverly Hills. The pages themselves are compiled by software running that method and are not read one by one before publication — saying otherwise would be the one claim here that could not be checked.